for day 1??? thats way too powerful[/quote]In post 637, pob long wrote: I find it really fitting tbh, and maybe scum has a say in the result
Is this real? We were warned in the OP that the game could be swingy, which is why who gets sent to trial is important.In post 658, pob long wrote:??????????/ did I miss something completely Ridiculous???
In post 662, Titus wrote:TS: Plus is obvscum, so he can't be scum. So let's vote the vocal townie out inside because of gut.
Me: Gut is not a valid reason. Town should vote out obvious scum. There's no evidence to support scum picking the gladiate.
I agree that it's unlikely that scum picked the gladiate, but I disagree that shellyc picked the gladiate, largely because looking at shellyc's reads, she had plus and pete as partners, so the gladiate as her solve feels weird to me. I'm not sure how the gladiate was created, but it was probably the result of the trial. I just don't think it was the trial itself.In post 664, Fidget wrote:I'm guessing shelly picked out the gladiate, and the results of her trial is determined by how many scum she picked. 0 - horrible consequences for town and she loses, 1 - better, she doesn't lose and we got a chance, 2+ she wins on the spot and we get great odds.
Something like that.
Sure scum could have picked it too but that feels a lot less elegant of a game mechanic. Cause then there'd be obviously 2 town 1 scum gladiated and it just seems like it'd be messy to me.
In post 618, PlusJOYED wrote:jokes on you im trying to get put on trial town be damnedIn post 593, shellyc wrote:yes. PlusJoy is a stronger scumread to me atm with even less of a solving mindset / overall blendiness
guess I haven't done a good job if only you have voted me, how can I scumslip harder?
Why did you want to go to trial? Why are you not trying to go to trial now?
oh good catchIn post 679, Marashu wrote:Not sure if it's coincidence, but all 3 in the gladiate were on the shellyc wagon.
cause it seemed fun and I was null on shelly, and mildy wanted to mess with shellyIn post 678, Marashu wrote:In post 618, PlusJOYED wrote:jokes on you im trying to get put on trial town be damnedIn post 593, shellyc wrote:yes. PlusJoy is a stronger scumread to me atm with even less of a solving mindset / overall blendiness
guess I haven't done a good job if only you have voted me, how can I scumslip harder?Why did you want to go to trial? Why are you not trying to go to trial now?
This post bothered me at the time because 1) I wasn't feeling Titus's VCA and 2) it seemed a little too complimentary from DGB.
In post 575, Saudade wrote:2 days is plenty of timeIn post 573, Gypyx wrote:Yeah i agree that he's scum, but now's not really the time to start new wagons, especially considered that we're like 2 days until deadline
And there's this.
In post 677, Marashu wrote:In post 662, Titus wrote:TS: Plus is obvscum, so he can't be scum. So let's vote the vocal townie out inside because of gut.
Me: Gut is not a valid reason. Town should vote out obvious scum. There's no evidence to support scum picking the gladiate.I agree that it's unlikely that scum picked the gladiate, but I disagree that shellyc picked the gladiate, largely because looking at shellyc's reads, she had plus and pete as partners, so the gladiate as her solve feels weird to me. I'm not sure how the gladiate was created, but it was probably the result of the trial. I just don't think it was the trial itself.In post 664, Fidget wrote:I'm guessing shelly picked out the gladiate, and the results of her trial is determined by how many scum she picked. 0 - horrible consequences for town and she loses, 1 - better, she doesn't lose and we got a chance, 2+ she wins on the spot and we get great odds.
Something like that.
Sure scum could have picked it too but that feels a lot less elegant of a game mechanic. Cause then there'd be obviously 2 town 1 scum gladiated and it just seems like it'd be messy to me.
Yeah I agree looking at it now. It wasn't shelly. If it was scum, they definitely had to put at least 1 member in. But I feel like having scum pick is kinda lame. Maybe there's a mystery behind it that can be solved?In post 687, Pickaxe Pete wrote:I don't think there's any way Shelly picked the gladiate without me in it.
This. No one, actually, has provided a good reason for scum reading nosferatu other than saying it's so.In post 660, Titus wrote:Regardless of Nos alignment, you're still scummy to me. I don't know whether this is mislynch bravado or bussing but you have provided no articulable reason for a NOS fos.In post 659, Tayl0r Swift wrote:yesssssss
im glad to see people coming around on my nos read
VOTE: nos
What is your read on Plus joy? He was the major turning point against the PickAxe wagon. Your ignorance of him makes no sense.
In post 226, EddieFenix wrote:I'm not actually.... I'm -watching- Pob because there's somethings that give me some bad vibes. Which is why I am asking you to show me why you think he's a lock for being town.In post 131, Princess Leia wrote:You see what I'm seeing? You go first.In post 129, EddieFenix wrote:Reasons for Locktown on Pob, please.
What is bothering you about pob? I thought Battle Mage was decently town.In post 648, EddieFenix wrote:Very, very annoyed to come back to a quick lynch. I should have been in here on Monday, I take responsibility for not being in here. But, ok. Battle Mage was one of my reads that was off. However, I don't think this one is...
VOTE: Pob Long
This post didn't make sense either. TvT is more likely to come from scum? She can't believe that.In post 453, DrippingGoofball wrote:"Girls you're both pretty" or "it's town vs. town" is more likely to come from scum than from town.In post 371, shellyc wrote:Townleaning fidget and Titus. Titus reaction test is pretty indica to ice of a solving mindset and fidgets posting gives me a good vibe (this is more gut)
this, or i just have some tacit reason for thinking Nos is scum. we did your thing yesterday, look how that worked out.In post 660, Titus wrote:Regardless of Nos alignment, you're still scummy to me. I don't know whether this is mislynch bravado or bussing but you have provided no articulable reason for a NOS fos.In post 659, Tayl0r Swift wrote:yesssssss
im glad to see people coming around on my nos read
VOTE: nos
What is your read on Plus joy? He was the major turning point against the PickAxe wagon. Your ignorance of him makes no sense.
The class is waiting for your reason on Nos?In post 693, Tayl0r Swift wrote:this, or i just have some tacit reason for thinking Nos is scum. we did your thing yesterday, look how that worked out.In post 660, Titus wrote:Regardless of Nos alignment, you're still scummy to me. I don't know whether this is mislynch bravado or bussing but you have provided no articulable reason for a NOS fos.In post 659, Tayl0r Swift wrote:yesssssss
im glad to see people coming around on my nos read
VOTE: nos
What is your read on Plus joy? He was the major turning point against the PickAxe wagon. Your ignorance of him makes no sense.
You can sass me or you can actually use common sense that I am holding your feet to the fire and demanding a reason.In post 695, Tayl0r Swift wrote:Definition of tacit
1: expressed or carried on without words or speech
the blush was a tacit answer
you think there are multiple scum there? who do you think is scum? i dont see any coherent line of thought from you this game.In post 698, Titus wrote:I propose that if we hit scum, regardless of who we lynch, that we keep lynching in these 3 until we hit town or win lol.