Mini Normal 2168 | So Many Bats! | Game Over!

[Redados]

why are we thinking about what to do as scum
is 1267 a scumslip

nah, I entertained it and it's because 1266 doesn't make sense. I don't follow her logic.

I don't follow 1271 either.

[Redados]

I don't see why scum!redados would wanna say shelly and I aren't scum but that might be something that ur saying to try to make me think its not a shelly/redados solve

stop doing preflip associatives

+1

[shellyc]

No I think it would be to get me off ur tail. The reason is that anyone that assumes Shelly and I ended up both rolling scum again has to be a low-key delusional townie that wants the pieces that clearly don't fit together to fit together. You saying you ruled out the possibility just makes u sound more town cuz the probability of that happening is literally god knows how low. And considering a possibility that is literally so damn small definitely looks town imo. But then I'm kinda like mmm what if scum!redados is trying to change my mind with this bc he knows I overthink the shit outta everything and anything?

this is like super weird? I don't think entertaining me+noraa scumteam = delusional? I don't like you using the numbers to read redados and you end up wifoming yourself

quoting myself, sometimes town are just town. and scum are just scum.

[shellyc]

redados saying +1 to everything taylor says is concerning

im trying to entertain counterfactuals as much as I can

[Tayl0r Swift]

why are we thinking about what to do as scum
is 1267 a scumslip

no its not. stopppppp

[Tayl0r Swift]

yeah I think you're scummy, but the past couple of pages point to ShellyC and Noraa not being scum partners imo

1250 was directed at @taylor, but sure I'll take it

if you think we aren't S/S do you think scum is noraa and town is me then?

yes.

why?

[shellyc]

taylor why are you blatantly defending redados

hmmm im thinking taylor/redados or noraa/owen as The Worlds

[Tayl0r Swift]

No I think it would be to get me off ur tail. The reason is that anyone that assumes Shelly and I ended up both rolling scum again has to be a low-key delusional townie that wants the pieces that clearly don't fit together to fit together. You saying you ruled out the possibility just makes u sound more town cuz the probability of that happening is literally god knows how low. And considering a possibility that is literally so damn small definitely looks town imo. But then I'm kinda like mmm what if scum!redados is trying to change my mind with this bc he knows I overthink the shit outta everything and anything?

i mean theyre independent probabilities. saying the two of you were scum together last time does not mean youre not scum together this time. it doesnt mean you are. its just a thing that is.

[Tayl0r Swift]

taylor why are you blatantly defending redados

hmmm im thinking taylor/redados or noraa/owen as The Worlds

im gonna continue to defend everyone from what i see are bad arguments. im still voting redados and i still scumread redados. and youre doing preflip associations again.

[shellyc]

why are preflip associations bad

interactions are literally the whole point of Mafia

[shellyc]

also, why do you feel obligation to be everyone's knight in shining armour and defend them from bad arguments because its not your job to do that

[Redados]

redados saying +1 to everything taylor says is concerning

that one was tongue in cheek because I think Noraa was complaining about it. I didn't realize that it was to Taylor every time, I was just doing it to stuff I agreed with, oops

[Redados]

yeah I think you're scummy, but the past couple of pages point to ShellyC and Noraa not being scum partners imo

1250 was directed at @taylor, but sure I'll take it

if you think we aren't S/S do you think scum is noraa and town is me then?

yes.

why?

I think Noraa is pretty scummy, I scumread her more than I scumread Shelly. I also think Shelly is scummy, but like I explained I don't think that she and Noraa are scum together.

[Redados]

also, why do you feel obligation to be everyone's knight in shining armour and defend them from bad arguments because its not your job to do that

she keeps saying stuff that makes a lot of sense, I'm not complaining

[shellyc]

second sentence of that is kinda self aware? or am I reading too much into things

pedit: can you explain WHY I am scummy? since ive seen your noraa minicase

[Tayl0r Swift]

why are preflip associations bad

interactions are literally the whole point of Mafia

but trying to say "this person is mafia because this person is mafia" only works if you know one is mafia. otherwise its just pure speculation that could be TvT and its much easier for scum to do preflip associations since they actually know who has what alignment. two people being scum together is only helpful if theyre scummy. them having interactions or defending each other does not make them scum. its a bad way of solving

[Tayl0r Swift]

also, why do you feel obligation to be everyone's knight in shining armour and defend them from bad arguments because its not your job to do that

its everyone's job. bad arguments lead to bad lunches.

[Noraa]

Yeah redados' reads still have absolute zero content and I'm not sure what to think about that at this point

[shellyc]

having interactions with each other and defending each other is partner equity which could be townblock or scum partners

either way i think it's a valid way of solving but we'll agree to disagree

pedit: noraa stop sheeping

[Noraa]

who did I sheep?
u tell me shelly

[shellyc]

you sheeped my suspicion on redados for not compellingly casing me.

[Tayl0r Swift]

having interactions with each other and defending each other is partner equity which could be townblock or scum partners

either way i think it's a valid way of solving but we'll agree to disagree

pedit: noraa stop sheeping

line 1: true, but you only know which one it is with a flip. so its a bad argument.
line 2: ok, you do you.
line 3: fair point

[Tayl0r Swift]

you sheeped my suspicion on redados for not compellingly casing me.

wait, nope. what?

[Redados]

second sentence of that is kinda self aware? or am I reading too much into things

pedit: can you explain WHY I am scummy? since ive seen your noraa minicase

I haven't really felt that you were scummy since I started being more active but reading through your ISO I see you tunnel, play aggressively, I'm not a fan. If you play like this for the rest of the game though I would feel better.

[Noraa]

you sheeped my suspicion on redados for not compellingly casing me.

no wtf

you sheeped my suspicion on redados for not compellingly casing me.

wait, nope. what?

Taylor is witness and here to prove I'm not the insane one :3