Mini Normal 2168 | So Many Bats! | Game Over!

[Battle Mage]

in case that's a wrap, a reminder:

I'm a confirmable town PR - doctor, please gimme some love tonight.

[Battle Mage]

in case that's a wrap, a reminder:

I'm a confirmable town PR -

doctor, please gimme some love tonight.

what a pagetop

[Battle Mage]

I don't think bugs being scum = hectic is scum
hectic was just standing up for bugs like I stand up for plus. I get the logic behind it and if plus flipped red, that would most definitely not mean we have a scum!noraa. The logic on ur part I get. But I don't think it means either hectic or me is scum if one of them flips red.

I know what you mean, but I think it's different because Hectic was like VERY VERY sure that Bugs is town, and basically put his rep on the line. So sure that he'd rather eliminate someone he believes is likely to be a town PR, rather than elim Bugs. We can agree to disagree though!

I'll give this to u. This is a fair point and I agree that his thing on bugs was a more extreme version of mine. Eh if bugs flips red, I won't be surprised but I doubt I will think hectic is scum. Cuz like u have a fair point and all but hectic has seemed really towny so far so I'm keeping that TR on the table.

Town's current ~situation~ worries me. We are so split up on wagons rn that I think its honestly very possible that we end up with a no lim so I will be supporting the biggest wagon no matter which one it is. Heck even if it was outside of my final limpool, I would go there anyways cuz no lim is worse than anything else

you think we should get a redados claim now then? He's at something like L-2 anyway I guess, so currently he's the main wagon.

He's at E-2 already? dayum his wagon built up fast. Idk I'm not fond of the idea of a Redados lim anymore but if its the only one going thru, my vote will be there tmrw.

I agree with you on Redados I think, I'm not super confident, but we need to end this day.

[Battle Mage]

I make that 5 votes, meaning L-2:

UNOwen, Norweg, bugspray, hectic and me

[Noraa]

in case that's a wrap, a reminder:

I'm a confirmable town PR - doctor, please gimme some love tonight.

1) I don't think we have a doctor but idk. Here's my take on stuff : If Norwee isn't lying about the setup info and we have a Mafia doctor, I don't think town will have a doctor. Idk if the logic works but idk generally what the town has, the mafia has the "opposite" of. Not sure if that's completely correct at this point in time cuz closed setup is confusing but I think its right.

2) Even if we have a doctor, don't tell them what to do. I think the reasoning is simple. We have three outed prs. I think at most, one is lying. There is never a case where two scums out pr day 1. They'd have to be stupid. In this case, the scums will have to decide which one to kill and if they know the doctor is protecting u, they will kill off the other. But if u don't say anything, the scum might try to kill the one the doctor saves and that benefits everyone.

[Battle Mage]

I agree with you mostly - it's a WIFOM game.

I want to assume there is a Doc, rather than speculate we might not, as otherwise scum might gamble on just killing me. And most games have a town protective role. Even if you disagree, let's run with that for now.

I'm not massively worried about Norweg being killed given he has told us his information, so really it's 2 town PRs who might have enduring value. You're right that one of them might be lying too.

Me directing the Doctor doesn't change the decisions really - scum and doctor can both still play the uncertainty game. However, I'm mostly just trying to remind the Doc that I am a claimed PR so they don't forget, or have missed it because of so much posting.

[Noraa]

I think the plan should be doc protect Taylor and Taylor protect u. rolestopper is protective ... I think?

idk disregard if u think its a bad plan and again we wanna be unpredictable and give scum one hell of a time trying to figure anything out

[Battle Mage]

I think the plan should be doc protect Taylor and Taylor protect u. rolestopper is protective ... I think?

idk disregard if u think its a bad plan and again we wanna be unpredictable and give scum one hell of a time trying to figure anything out

yep defo not the plan, as rolestopper also roleblocks right? that would not be good. I think my role is also more valuable for town than Taylor's, so would prefer to err on side of caution.

[Noraa]

idk what rolestopper does tbh but I think I've heard it be classified as a protective role so idk
disregard the plan then. ig we're back to the plan with the doctor

[Battle Mage]

dream as if you'll live forever
live as if you'll die today
and maybe if we stick together
I might have the chance to stay
roll up your faith, and pack your trust
and please don't let me be betrayed
I'll always go just where I must
so that your truth can be conveyed

[Noraa]

dream as if you'll live forever
live as if you'll die today
and maybe if we stick together
I might have the chance to stay
roll up your faith, and pack your trust
and please don't let me be betrayed
I'll always go just where I must
so that your truth can be conveyed

This doesn't beat
Dream as if you'll live forever like Noraa, live as if you'll die today like Shelly

[Noraa]

still good tho

[Battle Mage]

still good tho

thanks

how do you feel about shelly in this game? she seemed to scumread you very hard early, and then didn't really explain why she stopped pursuing it.

[Noraa]

still good tho

thanks

how do you feel about shelly in this game? she seemed to scumread you very hard early, and then didn't really explain why she stopped pursuing it.

typical shelly play right there

[Noraa]

I always have a hard time reading my old scum buddy shelly. Thats just how it is. sooo asking me for a read on shelly is a bad idea cuz generally the most I can say is eh she seems town or eh she seems scum but even I'm never really convinced in that soooo

[Battle Mage]

hmm my gut was saying scum here, even though i felt that since i joined she was talking a lot of sense. also, knowing that shelly often gets a lot of pressure early in games, i'd have thought scum would have kept her on the table as a possible mis-elim if she was town. The fact nobody is gunning for her, even a little bit, makes me lean scum.

[Noraa]

Meh idk. Each game reacts differently to her. She's an interesting one that's hard to read. Idk what else to say.

[Battle Mage]

Meh idk. Each game reacts differently to her. She's an interesting one that's hard to read. Idk what else to say.

fair enough! i think we just need to end the day now lol - 117 pages for Day 1 aint bad.

[Noraa]

You put redados at E-2 right? Any objections to me dropping a E-1?

[Battle Mage]

no objections from me. ideally we should get a claim from him before anyone hammers though.

[Noraa]

Yeah that's what I'm a bit worried about in case someone hammers since this game is a bit ~spammy~

[Noraa]

Normally E-1 + an announcement is sufficient but I'm worried someone will actually accidentally hammer if my E-1 warning is lost in the thread

[Battle Mage]

maybe just wait for a pagetop, then post your vote really big and bold with the words:

LET HIM CLAIM BEFORE HAMMERING.

quick-elimming another freakin' power role after 117 pages would be too much...

[Battle Mage]

i do know how you feel though!

[Noraa]

How do I get page top? I've never actually counted how many posts til page top lmao