i mean, of course i am? that's why it was a hypothetical
unless you just mean i'm assuming the silencer role could be used at any point? not exactly a wild assumption, but i suppose it's *possible* they were forced to use it N1 if that's what you're implying? seems incredibly unlikely though because i'd just ask "why?" from a design pov
also it's kind of ironic that you said you don't think 420's role can exist with yours but you're saying i'm making a lot of assumptions to get to that point
In post 4976, zMuffinMan wrote:also it's kind of ironic that you said you don't think 420's role can exist with yours but you're saying i'm making a lot of assumptions to get to that point
i am only acting on information that has been concretely observed in the game or claimed in the game
because otherwise how do you conclude that your role can't coexist with his? like, theoretically from your POV, scum could have any number of roles that counter one or both of you so...?
In post 4979, zMuffinMan wrote:right... which means at the very least you're making assumptions about what power scum have
this is semantics but whatever, sure
if i am to make an assumption, the fact that when ELO is is somewhat open to interpretation considering this silence shit makes me somewhat inclined to believe that scum can't use it to force a game end early
In post 4980, zMuffinMan wrote:because otherwise how do you conclude that your role can't coexist with his? like, theoretically from your POV, scum could have any number of roles that counter one or both of you so...?
i mean, yeah, you're right. scum could have some crazy high powered shit to counter all this, fine
I still think doc++, weak neighborizer, and my role is just a really strong combo and i think 420 is the thing that doesn't belong and i don't know what else to do to qualify that
In post 4981, Remilia Scarlet wrote:if i am to make an assumption, the fact that when ELO is is somewhat open to interpretation considering this silence shit makes me somewhat inclined to believe that scum can't use it to force a game end early
that makes no sense as an assumption because it directly tells scum there's zero way to prevent a night kill in this game on top of the utility of the role lol
unless youre saying you think they could use it but the moderator wouldn't honour it if it removed someone at night when the day would have otherwise been lylo?
*shrug*
probably not an interesting line of conversation to continue since it's impossible to know, but that seems more absurd than my assumptions tbh and even still, you're only talking about one role and not considering other stuff scum could hypothetically have to counter town power
the only interesting thing about it is that you had to have made all the assumptions you're making about the setup prior to claiming when you didn't know what other power town had and as a result shouldn't have known what power scum had to counter it
there's nothing inherently wrong with what you're claiming and a white mage co-existing
In post 4985, zMuffinMan wrote:the only interesting thing about it is that you had to have made all the assumptions you're making about the setup prior to claiming when you didn't know what other power town had and as a result shouldn't have known what power scum had to counter it
i still am never going to know what power scum has to counter anything unless they flip, but my reactions were to the combination of maid / 420 / april in regard to my own role and that seemed like a bridge too far to me
i read a bit of the game your sig originated from muffin. Spiffeh is funny and I wish he still played. Also I liked Dunnstral wanting to delay voting and then being shut down by the mod. Wisdom is too strong, that's another one I wish still played.
In post 4995, 420 Blaze It wrote:i read a bit of the game your sig originated from muffin. Spiffeh is funny and I wish he still played. Also I liked Dunnstral wanting to delay voting and then being shut down by the mod. Wisdom is too strong, that's another one I wish still played.
Hi plox confirm how your role interacts with daykills and with weak roles with the mod kthnx.
In post 4982, Remilia Scarlet wrote:I still think doc++, weak neighborizer, and my role is just a really strong combo and i think 420 is the thing that doesn't belong and i don't know what else to do to qualify that
If you're town did you ever consider a... toelvloxker???!!?
Rolvleocker. Roleblocker. Roleblocker there we go I'm good at this I swear