The Trials - ENDGAME

[Gypyx]

I'd say that my gut proves true around 70% of the time personally, might have just gotten lucky a few times in a row though

[Noraa]

I believe that ur gut is right most the time.
my problem is I can't tell if ur town
if ur scum, ur gut doesn't do anything here since u already know who the scums are anyways

[Gypyx]

That's fair, i'm gonna try to case Vecna anyways

But i mean, kinda weird that the main problem you see with scum!me making gut reads is that i would know the scumguys lmao

[Noraa]

well the problem is that u would mislead me lmao

[Gypyx]

nah I didn't say I could be a CL, I was pointing out that the c caused much confusion and I should get an alt
continuing with this logic it could start with anything beginning with c.

shelly crayon-lover?

VOTE: BM are you confident you can pass the trial?

Not a great fan of taylors early posts. Jumping on the strange titus opening even though it was clear what she meant, but jumping straight off again to this.

Ill refrain from talking about sending town to trials before catching up because I bet that horsey has already been beaten to a pulp by now.

i mean im pretty serious. BM asked for the vote. i assumed there was either good reason for why or it was some kind of reaction test. either way ill play along

Way to change my mind with the next two posts

Very weird entrance, i don't really get what this is supposed to mean, like tayl0r is becoming more scummy? Something else?

VOTE: Vecna

Sonething isn't right in the game without Vecna spamming it.

This was your second post. Why didnt you kick these slimes into shape before my arrival?

your house is in disarray

vote taylor

super SRS, can even wagon nosferatu

i respect a mans right to self-determination

does this come off as genuine paranoia to you, shelly?

it does.

So you think that town would geniunely think that finishing your username by a "C" is scummy?

personally i think names ending in x to be much more scummy
whats the x stand for?
what are you hiding?

VOTE: leia
no one is allowed to vote taylor
id vote you all if i could

I was already wondering why u werent partaking in all this hi-fi stonertalk, and then u go and one-up everything.

wat

Also, BM, why are you so less much involved and way less opinionated and catchy than u were in the saw game?

Basically these posts : anyone else than nosferatu, doesn't participate much
Vecna "pls post content man, that's susp"

Nosferatu jokes around
Vecna "lmao nice one, yeah he's town"

Nosferatu, stop being such a non-factor, please. I know you got some gems that wanna come out.

I think Nos is probably town. I can almost taste his happy stoner face flapping about as he ridicules' people thier reasoning

Schoddinger's posting, it's simultaniously ok and not ok to be pretty much a non-factor (kinda exagerating there, but that's to examplify my case)


Anyways that's all i've got, i also don't like the way Vecna doesn't feel really concerned to find town / think about the game with others, but that's not really caseable

[Noraa]

good case but also vecna isnt in the limpool for today ... right?

[Noraa]

im sus of vecna but towns consensus seems to be against that from what I've gathered

[Gypyx]

The thing is, if vecna is scum, a quarter of the PList will already be against Venca's Exe, so yeah, it's hard pushing a wagon

Also idk, is it really? I think lot of people have him as null

[Fidget]

What makes Vecna's ISO worse than, say, Nosferatu's?

@Gypyx

It probably wouldn't be terribly difficult to make a similar case for Nos.

[Fidget]

No. Titus is scum

VOTE: Titus

Care to develop on this vote?

Titus has been on both of the town lynches that have happened. I can see her making smart plans and kills to keep the heat down.

I'm just gonna toss some more accusations into the EddieFenix thunderdome here

What a shift between these two posts. It's like he was going for the "X is scum. I am certain." vibes at first, but when pressed for reasoning it's more like, "I could see Titus being scum. You saw she was on both town wagons?"

..

I don't how to check who's scum (if any) in Titus/Vecna. I'd rather save that for another time. I liked both of them at different points.

I want to say Tayl0r/Gypyx/Noraa is a good townbloc.

Nosferatu I'm particularly wary of since he just survived the last gladiate, I sort of hope there was 1 scum inside the gladiate, and I lean him over DGB.

[Vecna]

and I do feel theres a pretty good chance that titus is naughty.

gypyx' silly push might actually be coming from a good space. My game thus far has been rather weaksauce. titus not noticing that, dgb not noticing any differences....might be bad news.

Why is it AI for titus / DGB to not notice your scuminess, like pretty sure that as scum, they'd try to capitalize of your scuminess right?

They know im normally obv-town and completely unlynchable as town. To the point of it being an absolute waste to even try, and usually scum knowing me will just townread me from the get-go.

Redicule my reads, sure. But not going for a scumread.

Weirdly enough, when im town, people scumreading me tend to be town in the vast majority of cases.

[Vecna]

Care to develop on this vote?

Titus has been on both of the town lynches that have happened. I can see her making smart plans and kills to keep the heat down.

Well that's a good point, and i've also found some slightly worrying stuff with titus, but i'm not interested in wagoninh titus rn

Oh really? What's worrying. No cloak and daggers. Give it to us straight.

Like, without having caught up, I bet this questioned wont have been posed towards my exact same read.

Why? Because scum titus knows its totally pointless to throw shade on me since im unlynchable.

You on the other hand? Not so much.

[Vecna]

@Vecna, I have always felt your game was weak when you can only say Titus is scum. Just you kept the volume manageable so I could scumhunt but if you want to go at me for not being a dick to you, then come at me. I doubt scum Vecna can pull the facade. Of course Civilization Vecna would know when to back down.

Case in point. I guess

[Noraa]

Vecna I'm basically randomly throwing shade at u rn. All I have said is that my gut tells me ur scum. The normal town reaction is a nice version of "fuck off"

im not seeing that. explain why and dont say something like "well it seems all ur reads suck ass" bc like no that's not a valid reason. A townie would jump at me for throwing shade like that.

[EddieFenix]

I'mma be honest, I haven't been fully invested into the game as I should be due to IRL stuff. DGB, you funny and probably scum too. I don't have a 3rd pick at th moment. But, I gotta dip because I gotta reset my sleep schedule for a midnight job. GL to my fellow townies, y'all got this.

@Mod: Can you find my replacement?

[Vecna]

Vecna I'm basically randomly throwing shade at u rn. All I have said is that my gut tells me ur scum. The normal town reaction is a nice version of "fuck off"

im not seeing that. explain why and dont say something like "well it seems all ur reads suck ass" bc like no that's not a valid reason. A townie would jump at me for throwing shade like that.

Whenever I engage people that scumread me too much, the next step is always that some clown throws out something along the lines of "OMG look he's so defensive" and then it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

Your scumreads dont bother me too much. They will probably help me read you better.

[Vecna]

The one thing ill say though: Those things that gypic (or w/e it spelled) picks out to scumread me over in his case are not actually scummy behaviour.

Changing my mind on taylor within 3 posts? is that scummy? no its not

Townreading Nos while working with the little he provided at that time, while im also unhappy by his participation? Why wouldnt I be. That type of playstyle attracts the mislynches like shit attracts flies.

If im scum, then either make the case im white knighting Nos, or try to flip Nos to even see whether the team-defense argument is valid. Yet for some reason he skips that step and votes for me.

so yeah, some critical thought process, please.

[Tayl0r Swift]

im for sure down for an eddie wagon here. wont vote there until the replacement shows up, but i think itll be good to get some pressure on that slot straight away. eddie if youre still here youll have to PM the mod, you shouldnt state replacement requests in thread.

[Pickaxe Pete]

I'mma be honest, I haven't been fully invested into the game as I should be due to IRL stuff. DGB, you funny and probably scum too. I don't have a 3rd pick at th moment. But, I gotta dip because I gotta reset my sleep schedule for a midnight job. GL to my fellow townies, y'all got this.

@Mod: Can you find my replacement?

This is weak.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'mma be honest

, I haven't been fully invested into the game as I should be due to IRL stuff. DGB, you funny and probably scum too. I don't have a 3rd pick at th moment. But, I gotta dip because I gotta reset my sleep schedule for a midnight job. GL to my fellow townies, y'all got this.

@Mod: Can you find my replacement?

This is weak.

When you have to start by declaring your honesty

"I'mma be honest"

usually what follows isn't.

[Nosferatu]

wow

still think there's no scum in the gladiate

[Nosferatu]

selection is too specific to be random
i think scum just finessed an elim

[Fidget]

selection is too specific to be random
i think scum just finessed an elim

If scum got to choose the gladiate, wouldn't they put some of the towniest looking players in it?

Granted, there aren't a lot of those.

But you and PlusJOYED? You both were probably already good candidates for the D2 elimination, gladiate or no gladiate. You had already received some suspicion d1, and Plus just came off the terrible hammer.

You make a good point that it felt specific. But in the wrong direction, almost.

[Vecna]

I'mma be honest

, I haven't been fully invested into the game as I should be due to IRL stuff. DGB, you funny and probably scum too. I don't have a 3rd pick at th moment. But, I gotta dip because I gotta reset my sleep schedule for a midnight job. GL to my fellow townies, y'all got this.

@Mod: Can you find my replacement?

This is weak.

When you have to start by declaring your honesty

"I'mma be honest"

usually what follows isn't.

This probably makes the top 10 of bullshit reasons people get scumread for, that is completely NAI.

Cause imma be honest with you, I say that shit all the time. And its just an easy ass way to formulate a scumread when U cant find a real reason.

Having said that, I was all up on thinking the same way about wagoning him, but that post stating how he feels about you did actually sound pretty honest to me. He might very well be scum, but that post actually makes me feel "huh"

[Vecna]

selection is too specific to be random
i think scum just finessed an elim

If scum got to choose the gladiate, wouldn't they put some of the towniest looking players in it?

Granted, there aren't a lot of those.

But you and PlusJOYED? You both were probably already good candidates for the D2 elimination, gladiate or no gladiate. You had already received some suspicion d1, and Plus just came off the terrible hammer.

You make a good point that it felt specific. But in the wrong direction, almost.

Totally worth it if they couldve gotten multiple people murdered with it though. I still agree with the people that said due to the phase timing its unlikely scum had any say in the group.