Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[EchoVision]

page top
drop top

[EchoVision]

npom who’s scum

It's the beginning of day one how would I know?

bc you're town
so who's not

[shellyc]

echo who is scum im gunna solve this on this page

[shellyc]

wym by number 2

the name of the setup is great idea
theres a town grave card and a wolf gravedigger card

[Noraa]

Shelly the way u started off this game reminds me a shit ton of ur scum games. Ur scum games always start off looking very very protown. However when ur town, u always start off meh or really scummy :/

this is very wifomy and I can improve at being town

meh response
noraa you tryna rock this shit or do you wanna rock ico's shit with me since he's not even here yet
or the other person who's name i can't even remember
it starts with an a

the arachnid one. I plan on focusing on shelly bc her entrance pings me of all her scum games so far where she started off being TRed a shit ton for "protown behavior"

echo who is scum im gunna solve this on this page

why are we asking for solves day 1? none of them r gonna be right. Just ask for reads. Plus its still half rvs and I doubt anyone has a read that's half decent. Chill ur butt, wait for info to collect itself and magically everyone will have reads

[shellyc]

I plan on focusing on shelly bc her entrance pings me of all her scum games so far where she started off being TRed a shit ton for "protown behavior"

sigh can you use occam's for once

quoting myself, sometimes town are just town
and scum are just scum

[shellyc]

why are we asking for solves day 1? none of them r gonna be right. Just ask for reads. Plus its still half rvs and I doubt anyone has a read that's half decent. Chill ur butt, wait for info to collect itself and magically everyone will have reads

I didnt ask echo to give a solve I wanted their reads so I could solve their alignment
and they may be right, ive gotten all the scum in my PoE d1 twice before
you dont magically get reads, by interacting with echo I will get them

[shellyc]

Town
username - efforts to solve renny and move the game out of RVS is protown
titus - engaging noraa instead of chilling off and further the game is protown
npom - because of claim
noraa - gut town + critical thinking and paranoia in 129

TBD
everyone else

i prefer to find town early on and PoE this through tbh

[EchoVision]

wym by number 2

the name of the setup is great idea
theres a town grave card and a wolf gravedigger card

understood have a good day

[EchoVision]

wym by number 2

the name of the setup is great idea
theres a town grave card and a wolf gravedigger card

echo who is scum im gunna solve this on this page

lebron james and shaquille o’neal

[EchoVision]

wym by number 2

the name of the setup is great idea
theres a town grave card and a wolf gravedigger card

echo who is scum im gunna solve this on this page

Shelly the way u started off this game reminds me a shit ton of ur scum games. Ur scum games always start off looking very very protown. However when ur town, u always start off meh or really scummy :/

this is very wifomy and I can improve at being town

bc i’m a fucking expert and my best friend shelly knows i’m a fucking expert
meh response
noraa you tryna rock this shit or do you wanna rock ico's shit with me since he's not even here yet
or the other person who's name i can't even remember
it starts with an a

the arachnid one. I plan on focusing on shelly bc her entrance pings me of all her scum games so far where she started off being TRed a shit ton for "protown behavior"

echo who is scum im gunna solve this on this page

why are we asking for solves day 1? none of them r gonna be right. Just ask for reads. Plus its still half rvs and I doubt anyone has a read that's half decent. Chill ur butt, wait for info to collect itself and magically everyone will have reads

[EchoVision]

wtf why is mobile stupid hold on

[EchoVision]

Shelly the way u started off this game reminds me a shit ton of ur scum games. Ur scum games always start off looking very very protown. However when ur town, u always start off meh or really scummy :/

this is very wifomy and I can improve at being town

meh response
noraa you tryna rock this shit or do you wanna rock ico's shit with me since he's not even here yet
or the other person who's name i can't even remember
it starts with an a

the arachnid one. I plan on focusing on shelly bc her entrance pings me of all her scum games so far where she started off being TRed a shit ton for "protown behavior"

echo who is scum im gunna solve this on this page

why are we asking for solves day 1? none of them r gonna be right. Just ask for reads. Plus its still half rvs and I doubt anyone has a read that's half decent. Chill ur butt, wait for info to collect itself and magically everyone will have reads

bc i’m a fucking expert and my best friend shelly knows i’m an expert
but shellys bein a lil bit of a weirdo so i am accepting new best friend applications
i don’t really like how towny shellys being

but it’s never the person you most suspect nor least suspect it’s whoever you middle most suspect
shelly+ noraa scum team again throwback to doggos

[shellyc]

this is ridiculous, so apparently echo and noraa think im scum for... being town? wtf

echo is finding very stretched reasons to TR me, -2 townpoints

[shellyc]

*stretched reasons to SR me

also I am quite a fan of bussing and townbinning my partner for "gut" is... risky

[NoPowerOverMe]

If shelly says you are scum 53 times than you are town.

[NoPowerOverMe]

and she is scum.

[shellyc]

I think half the plist has seen my scumgame considering my difficulties in rolling town

nah NPOM is proooobably town here considering the claim, whats your thoughts on noraa and echo scumreading me for apparently being town?

[Primate]

I did see that there was a gravedigger claim, but I didn’t realize at the time that it was from NPOM.

i find the minor details here to make your story believable. you could have said the claim drew your attention and was thusly the reason for your vote, you could have said that you hadn't seen the claim at all, but saying neither is an unexpected twist.

you have passed the test. congratulations.

Don't get this, but alright.

UNVOTE:
To people who have played setup before, would you care to link to a typical game so the rest of us know what to expect?

I've played this setup a lot face to face so I can answer, although its not really a useful discussion to have until later in the day imho.

1. Don't be surprised if there are weird scum arrangements. 1 werewolf/1 alien/1 SK is plausible. Group scum is possible but not certain.
2. The amount of named townies and the fact that a lot of roles have scum equivalents makes role claiming odd.

Tracking NPOM to two people doesn't mean anything. If the Mafia kill X and Werewolves kill Y, NPOM is still going to be tracked to two people, regardless of whether they actually targetted either of them. It's only relevant if NPOM gets tracked to someone that *doesn't* die.

Shelly the way u started off this game reminds me a shit ton of ur scum games. Ur scum games always start off looking very very protown. However when ur town, u always start off meh or really scummy :/

Interesting shout, this one.

username - efforts to solve renny and move the game out of RVS is protown
titus - engaging noraa instead of chilling off and further the game is protown
npom - because of claim
noraa - gut town + critical thinking and paranoia in 129

Yeah, I think this is broadly correct. It's kind of a shallow reading, as expected, this early in the game, but these are the people signalling town, and for these reasons.

[Primate]

Yes one tracker should get two kill results now that I think about it.

Wait no. The watcher has to watch the person being killed. Tracker could get two results though if I am thinking about it correctly.

The roled are random so a vanilla majority is not guaranteed.

Yes, yes, and yes.

IMO posting about mechanics like this is a scumtell because it’s just fluff. It gives the illusion of contributing without bringing us any closer to finding scum. Don’t do this after I said I believed your claim

Just not wild about this post generally, it made from the perspective of someone who has been challenged on their vote on someone and hasn't yet removed it. Could be performative justification. Maybe I'm tunneling too early, idk.

[Rannygazoo]

echo whos scum

listen im gunna drop a solve next page, this game is very close to solved tbh

titus is town as well. engagement with noraa seemed like solving when scum!titus could just wagon on renny

ico and arachnids are a team; they're posting in their private topic right now instead of in the actual thread
they wanna make that fashionably late entrance but they can't decide who shows up first
whoever shows up first has to bring the alcohol

VOTE: ico

Don’t like this. I also check AG’s latest activity and it was today, BUT her name isn’t bolded in the mod’s first post, meaning she hasn’t confirmed her role via pm. Personally I doubt she’s still playing.

What do you think voting on inactives will accomplish?

Your next line will be: “My vote was just a joke.”

[Primate]

@RedCardinal: Who's scum?

What do you think voting on inactives will accomplish?

Agree w/this sentiment.

[shellyc]

Interesting shout, this one.

this is true broadly that im townread more as scum and scumread/elim'd more as town

[shellyc]

What do you think voting on inactives will accomplish?

policy lynch sometimes but it's not a high info elim, eliminations d1 generally should be info elims

ranny is this your first non newbie game

[Herta]

People going around asking "who's scum?" less than 24 hours into this game is weird. If it was just one person along, I might tr it as some scum hunting style.

Is that the point you're making, Primate?