Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[Primate]

@RedCardinal: I don't see how you could possibly reach that conclusion in a game that's quite likely to not have group scum.

[Herta]

Eh..

meh.

[shellyc]

herta are you conceding?

can we just powereliminate herta now

[Primate]

If you're claiming saulus I'm not sure this is the right play, but hey.

[shellyc]

does the saulus start out as a traitor and is it mafia aligned?

[shellyc]

*before being eliminated and becoming town if that wasn't clear

[Primate]

Saulus starts mafia, when dies turns town. Judas the other way round.

Saulus doesn't wake with the Mafia N1 for obvious reasons.

[EchoVision]

If shelly says you are scum 53 times than you are town.

what if she says it 52 times

[EchoVision]

echo whos scum

listen im gunna drop a solve next page, this game is very close to solved tbh

titus is town as well. engagement with noraa seemed like solving when scum!titus could just wagon on renny

ico and arachnids are a team; they're posting in their private topic right now instead of in the actual thread
they wanna make that fashionably late entrance but they can't decide who shows up first
whoever shows up first has to bring the alcohol

VOTE: ico

Don’t like this. I also check AG’s latest activity and it was today, BUT her name isn’t bolded in the mod’s first post, meaning she hasn’t confirmed her role via pm. Personally I doubt she’s still playing.

What do you think voting on inactives will accomplish?

Your next line will be: “My vote was just a joke.”

nah it wasn't a joke; ico has checked in so i'm assuming he knows the games going on
maybe he's reading and chillin like a villain and my vote will bring his attention to post

i doubt he's just lurking but maybe when he comes in and sees he has a vote on him he'll "oh shit" then obvtown or something

[Rannygazoo]

Fine, I’ll wait and see

VOTE: Herta
I want this situation sorted out.

[EchoVision]

People going around asking "who's scum?" less than 24 hours into this game is weird. If it was just one person along, I might tr it as some scum hunting style.

Is that the point you're making, Primate?

herta who's scum

[EchoVision]

Yeah, sounds like newbscum to me.

did you just scumclaim

herta's scum, serious vote

what the fuck did i just watch happen

[Noraa]

Shelly the way u started off this game reminds me a shit ton of ur scum games. Ur scum games always start off looking very very protown. However when ur town, u always start off meh or really scummy :/

this is very wifomy and I can improve at being town

meh response
noraa you tryna rock this shit or do you wanna rock ico's shit with me since he's not even here yet
or the other person who's name i can't even remember
it starts with an a

the arachnid one. I plan on focusing on shelly bc her entrance pings me of all her scum games so far where she started off being TRed a shit ton for "protown behavior"

echo who is scum im gunna solve this on this page

why are we asking for solves day 1? none of them r gonna be right. Just ask for reads. Plus its still half rvs and I doubt anyone has a read that's half decent. Chill ur butt, wait for info to collect itself and magically everyone will have reads

bc i’m a fucking expert and my best friend shelly knows i’m an expert
but shellys bein a lil bit of a weirdo so i am accepting new best friend applications
i don’t really like how towny shellys being

but it’s never the person you most suspect nor least suspect it’s whoever you middle most suspect
shelly+ noraa scum team again throwback to doggos

Yeah I'm not feeling the right vibes here for shelly to be town. I've never had a game with her that felt more scum!shelly than this one. All her town games seem very very scummy whereas those scum games start off with a shit ton of towncred. She pockets an insane amount until she reaches day 3/4 and people are like huh I don't really think she's town anymore. Every town game has made me think "huh she's being scummy but I can't tell what alignment she is" but her scum games always strike me as "huh she's being so protown she must be town ... right?"

*stretched reasons to SR me

also I am quite a fan of bussing and townbinning my partner for "gut" is... risky

Noraa/Shelly's not the solve here, no. Shelly busses partners day one in case they die. I may have said this too early but either way if anythin fishy happens today like a SR turns into a strong TR .... :/ I won't elaborate but I'm 99% sure shelly is scum here and she's probably already bussed her partners a lil by now. If she flips red, I'm gonna prove my theory to be true by pushing for her bussed partners.

VOTE: Herta

get this slot now

Shelly flips red = Herta is likely partner.

kok red is gunna have a early townish pass, scum don't really bus super early d1. red is town, herta slipped and scumclaimed.

pocketing.

redcardinal lets hard push herta and be our little townblock

I agree with noraa's logic but don't entirely trust atm

can you ~explain~ this a bit more? is it gut that makes you distrust them? because coherent logic is usually town!AI

U-U my curlies have officially affected the shelly welly.

shelly how many games have you played with noraa, ballpark

a shit ton but all except one are ongoing

[Noraa]

Love ya shelly welly but ur not town this game.
u could be some other wonky faction but ur definitely not town.

[EchoVision]

@RedCardinal: I don't see how you could possibly reach that conclusion in a game that's quite likely to not have group scum.

can you explain "likely to not have group scum" for me
like you think there's no factions, and each non-town aligned player is like 1sk, 1ww, etc?
or am i reading it wrong

[Rannygazoo]

What do you think voting on inactives will accomplish?

policy lynch sometimes but it's not a high info elim, eliminations d1 generally should be info elims

ranny is this your first non newbie game

Are you asking if I’m an alt? I’ll tell you the same thing I put during account creation. I had an account here years ago and I played a couple of games but I don’t remember my username and I don’t really want to, as I don’t remember anything about my games except that the last one was pretty toxic.

Some of the names I see around the site are tickling my memory but I don’t remember whether or not I played with them, and I definitely don’t know anything about their meta.

[Herta]

Jeez people. Get a grip.

You got me scumclaiming to conceding to claiming saulus. How does that work?

[Herta]

I mean, how do you get scumclaim out of that, Shelly? Seriously. Because that's what people do is scumclaim.

[Herta]

And red cardinal. What the hell kind of vote is that? "Serious vote." So when you switched from RVS it wasn't a serious vote? Or that was a second RVS vote? Maybe explain that.

[Primate]

@RedCardinal: I don't see how you could possibly reach that conclusion in a game that's quite likely to not have group scum.

can you explain "likely to not have group scum" for me
like you think there's no factions, and each non-town aligned player is like 1sk, 1ww, etc?
or am i reading it wrong

The latter, but think I'm wrong after running some example setups. Most of them had at least one pair. I'm used to smaller games of this. I retract any comments I had about this, feel free to do associations.

[Primate]

Jeez people. Get a grip.

You got me scumclaiming to conceding to claiming saulus. How does that work?

I didn't think you were actually scumclaiming, I think that faking a scumclaim is in itself scummy.

I did seal=saulus because that gif/post seemed to be a "I can't be bothered to do this, I'll roll over and die" concession, there's a slight name association, and Saulus is one of the few roles that might actually want to be lynched D1.

[Primate]

Also, Noraa, maybe I'm old fashioned, but I'm not comfortable with you referring to ongoing games in the way you are doing, if there's only the one completed game? Can you at least try and keep discussion limited to finished games and this game? I can't properly engage with the way you're presenting your argument at the minute.

[Noraa]

Also, Noraa, maybe I'm old fashioned, but I'm not comfortable with you referring to ongoing games in the way you are doing, if there's only the one completed game? Can you at least try and keep discussion limited to finished games and this game? I can't properly engage with the way you're presenting your argument at the minute.

Ah no its in her finished games. I can quote them if u want

[Noraa]

Also, Noraa, maybe I'm old fashioned, but I'm not comfortable with you referring to ongoing games in the way you are doing, if there's only the one completed game? Can you at least try and keep discussion limited to finished games and this game? I can't properly engage with the way you're presenting your argument at the minute.

Ah no its in her finished games. I can quote them if u want

just go meta dive her rq. its quite obvious

[Primate]

I haven't been a meta freak (or a good player) in like 12 years but I'll take a look then, much more comfortable now, thanks, sorry.