Mini Normal 2163: MItGBSMoD [game over!]

[shellyc]

bunno spectator?

congrats on getting that 5000th post

[Bunno]

bunno spectator?

mafia wins are fun to watch

[shellyc]

they sure are real fun to spectate.

what did you think the solve was?

[innocentvillager]

sorry for self voting town

i guess my reads were a lot better than i thought they were :/ hopefully i can build up more confidence and reasoning to push them.

[Bunno]

they sure are real fun to spectate.

what did you think the solve was?

I read the last pages after it was already over/spoiled, I wasn't following the game before.

[Ydrasse]

gg everyone, was fun!

[Andresvmb]

I am a little annoyed I will admit at Town self-voting in ELo. I understand that you think the game is almost over there plus and I agree that was a tough situation to get out of. But next time accept the defeat instead of speeding it up.

Mafia played well man. We should have listened to Osuka who played a good game. This was a bit of a down game for me so I apologize. I had a bad feeling about Menalque after seeing Osuka’s flip, but I think Menalque did well, and the bussing of Kerset was well done.

[Andresvmb]

Good job Mod! I have a lot of thoughts about the setup but why bother? Hahaha it was fun so that’s all good.

[bob3141]

i struggle to follow games with loads of posts. to be honest i actualy only read half the thread. I like my games low tempo

but i did try and warn town at the end when menal fliped to vote me.

if the thread hadnt locked i would more directly said there is a serous chance menal is scum.

[Andresvmb]

I really should have listened to Osuka and in part after they flipped I’m glad I did. I just wasn’t around to make anything happen. I constantly re-evaluated Menalque and Shellyc and always came to the wrong conclusion. Definitely a bummer for me. And I did all of the hard work of sidelining the one person that was actually on point in Osuka, and I wasn’t fair to plus. Most of my Town Reads actually turned out okay and I’m glad I was sure of Ydrasse, but overall not a good game for me.

[bob3141]

i was wrong on plus though. That vengful fake claim was awful even if he was right on shelly. Would always have pushed for menal lynch if i was alive that day. on the pr claim alone. not sure if i would have lynched him before plus though if he had claimed vt.

[Andresvmb]

Sigh plus made a few mistakes that really colored my view of him, and I should have been more understanding. The backup Jailkeeper claim was laughable honestly hahaha I had a good chuckle at that.

[Andresvmb]

And yes I told you that the Claim did not make any sense hahaha it just happened to come from Town.

[Andresvmb]

There’s a player that I respect that told me that putting every single read you have out there when you’re really not sure or don’t have a good reason for is not a good idea. I should have listened to that advice this game.

[Andresvmb]

Anyway, onto the next one.

Also, my very first post this game was so on point. DAMMIT.

[Andresvmb]

VOTE: shellyc

I’m not losing to you twice!

AAAAA

[Menalque]

i was wrong on plus though. That vengful fake claim was awful even if he was right on shelly. Would always have pushed for menal lynch if i was alive that day. on the pr claim alone. not sure if i would have lynched him before plus though if he had claimed vt.

Yes, this is why we misguillotined you before the game reached gylo :p

[Menalque]

I really should have listened to Osuka and in part after they flipped I’m glad I did. I just wasn’t around to make anything happen. I constantly re-evaluated Menalque and Shellyc and always came to the wrong conclusion. Definitely a bummer for me. And I did all of the hard work of sidelining the one person that was actually on point in Osuka, and I wasn’t fair to plus. Most of my Town Reads actually turned out okay and I’m glad I was sure of Ydrasse, but overall not a good game for me.

I think you played pretty well. If you read scum PT you’ll see that I was very much focused on pocketing you and then if that failed eliminating you. The fact that you TR us meant we were able to use you as the person to push for osuka, but also that you needed to die once you knew you were wrong there because there was too much risk from you looking closely at me/shelly afterwards.

[Menalque]

Also, I don’t think people should be hard on plus. Was a tough game, there wasn’t really any possibility that he wouldn’t die there, and also, very much to his credit, he figured out exactly what the scumplan was: he just easy right about who was executing it.

[Menalque]

For anyone interested, I think a definite scumtell of mine in lylo was not referring back to the reads of dead townies v much. If I’d been town I would have been quoting the shit out of osuka/Andres/bob’s final reads, which I considered doing for cred by ultimately it wasn’t worth the extra attention on my slot/on shelly.

[Kerset]

Subject: Mini Normal 2163: MItGBSMoD VOICE OF MOD:

I think teacher might be a PR

Oh shit I still need to crumb rolestopper hmmm

does he actually plan to claim rolestopper oh my fucking god
when i was sending out role PMs i had a flashforward of "mena claims rolestopper teacher forceyeets his ass"
hopefully he doesn't have to claim it on day one and they figure out just *what* the cop is informed about aaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

ftr this is why i originally wanted to have an informed rolestopper

i love that

[Kerset]

One thing i don't like about this setup is how RS is neg utility. The only thing that RS can do in here is to fool cop but cop is informed about this possibility. Checker can counter RS by revealing whenever cop investigation failed due to RS or disalignment. You can't really prevent JK protection with RS, so in the end this role was useless. The only way for this role to have impact on this game was by claim slip.

[PlusJOYED]

gj maf, especially mena. Impressive, i never woulda thought you would hard defend a townie as maf when you coulda just ended day 1 right there
I don't feel bad self voting there cause everyone was locked on voting me and I was exhausted.

[bob3141]

gj maf, especially mena. Impressive, i never woulda thought you would hard defend a townie as maf when you coulda just ended day 1 right there
I don't feel bad self voting there cause everyone was locked on voting me and I was exhausted.

Certainly do wonders. If scum is not at risk of being lynched it becomes the better option. Once deadlocked two town wagons (on day two) to try and get a flash lynch on a third. It didnt work but town still got lynched. And i ended up looking good

[NDMath]

Love the mod pt.
Surprised my ascetic claim was as unexpected as it was. Very curious to see if scum were close to killing me early on or not really.

I am a little annoyed I will admit at Town self-voting in ELo. I understand that you think the game is almost over there plus and I agree that was a tough situation to get out of. But next time accept the defeat instead of speeding it up.

I didn't mind it, even if we did flip to vote shelly I don't think I vote Mena over plus in mylo.