Mini Theme 2165: MafiaSunny (Complete!)

[Gamma Emerald]

Tbh I think if you want to try to decide between me and Noraa our mindsets are very lucrative to look at. Noraa is trying to push the obvious answer of “it’s not me so it’s Gamma” while I’ve been trying to suss out the best path, which I believe is to vote between duppin/Haschel despite the fact Noraa is confirmed scum to me.

Also with six it takes four for a yeet to happen, not three

[Noraa]

Since everyone is dropping votes, I want to make my stance crystal clear as well. VOTE: Gamma

ig it was very clear since a long time ago but im formalizing my strong strong strong SR with a vote. I just thought about something and I think the scum team is actually gamma/haschel. I've flip flopped a lot about who gammas partner is. Im sorry. But the reason is that town!gamma's logical vote today is me but he is instead sheeping duppin's SR on haschel. I think this is scum bussing and pocketing in preparation for a win tomorrow.

[Noraa]

I agree with this for the most part but I wanted to say that duppin's claim is one of the big reasons I believe in a duppin/gamma solve

That seems highly risky though, doesn't it? It definitely made a connection between them that everyone noticed.

this is wifomy but people would normally think that so I actually thought this could be scum big brain moves

[Noraa]

Either way, I've decided I like the other solve more.

[Noraa]

That might flip back but idk im somewhat sold on haschel/gamma :/

[duppin]

okay last post before i sleep, its really simple. VP and Ythan if you believe I am town, then vote on Haschel. If you believe noraa is more town than me then i understand if you vote on gamma.

but i really suggest you to read her doggos game because her reaction to the haschel vote is very concerning also the post saying that she now believes in haschel/gamma is meaningless if she votes on gamma since it is in mylo. i am biased since i was counterclaimed and whatever, anyway goodnight hopefully the game isnt over when i wake up tomorrow

[VP Baltar]

Haschel says I was targeted by a miscellaneous action after I ask in the thread if I can reveal someone visited me. Ig that is fairly meh but directly countering duppin was a bold move if he is scum cuz duppin is definitely TRed more...

That's not a bold move at all though? Counterclaiming today and going for a 50-50 is a great scum move in Xylo.

why?

If I'm Haschel, and I counterclaim someone who is already slightly suspected, I could have a good chance of swaying town to yeet that person. I mean, you yourself are saying Haschel could be town here. Scum's chances of winning become less tomorrow.

6 alive today, 2 confirmed.
Let's say Haschel doesn't counter, and Gamma is scum. We lim gamma correctly.
5 alive, 1 scum.
NK
4 alive, 1 scum....and either duppin gets to motion detect Haschel, or haschel kills duppin and has two confirmed towns in xylo.

That feels like a worse situation than today and a counter claim to victory

[VP Baltar]

her reaction to the haschel vote is very concerning

I actually agree with this point a little bit. Not loving that reaction.

[Noraa]

I've thought about what town!gamma would do so many times with so many different possibilities ... none of which are what he is currently doing. Im 100000000000% sold on gamma scum. There is no doubt left in my mind on this whatsoever. Literally none zero nada nulch.

[VP Baltar]

Haschel or both Gamma and Duppin are scum or it doesn't matter what we say now.

I don't think there are enough votes out there to prove anything at this point.

There won't be anything bad until you and I start voting. I'd love some analysis from you on the things I've said and where your vote is leaning today. I keep going back and forth on this.

[Gamma Emerald]

I've thought about what town!gamma would do so many times with so many different possibilities ... none of which are what he is currently doing. Im 100000000000% sold on gamma scum. There is no doubt left in my mind on this whatsoever. Literally none zero nada nulch.

Why would you have to even think about it? Once Haschel and duppin started counterclaiming each other it became clear 1 was between us.

[Haschel Cedricson]

UT caught Reck N2 actually. That would make you the most compromised (hypothetical) scum N3 to kill UT. If I had just lost my roleblocker, I probably wouldn't want to risk increasing the bleeding by my third buddy potentially getting caught.

Right, got the nights wrong. At any rate that's a bit of a WIFOM argument that I don't buy in to.

I had not claimed my N3 action at that point I believe. So I think that's incorrect.

Where did you actually claim N3? The was an implied claim before Duppin claimed but I guess it can be read as unidirectional.

At any rate, I'm going to

Vote: Gamma

even though Duppin is more of a lock. Then tomorrow I'll accurately know how many people visited a person I guess and we can get Duppin.

[Noraa]

I've thought about what town!gamma would do so many times with so many different possibilities ... none of which are what he is currently doing. Im 100000000000% sold on gamma scum. There is no doubt left in my mind on this whatsoever. Literally none zero nada nulch.

Why would you have to even think about it? Once Haschel and duppin started counterclaiming each other it became clear 1 was between us.

no it could be smart scum play

[Noraa]

Haschel sheeps my vote. Gamma sheeps cup-in's vote. Its a perfect scum team

[Noraa]

*duppins

[Noraa]

What duppin said is absolutely correct tho. It all depends on whether you buy a Noraa town or a Duppin town more.

[Noraa]

In the end it boils down to that.

[Gamma Emerald]

But that means the setup is
FN
Tracker
Doctor
2shot bus driver
Mask vendor
5 VTs
vs. scum RB and presumably scum MD and voyeur, one possibly being a fakeclaim

That seems bit unbalanced imo, what with scum having 1 to 2 investigatives and a RB

[Gamma Emerald]

But that means the setup is
FN
Tracker
Doctor
2shot bus driver
Mask vendor
5 VTs
vs. scum RB and presumably scum MD and voyeur, one possibly being a fakeclaim

That seems bit unbalanced imo, what with scum having 1 to 2 investigatives and a RB

@1537

[VP Baltar]

Lol I was having fun in this game until just now

[Noraa]

But that means the setup is
FN
Tracker
Doctor
2shot bus driver
Mask vendor
5 VTs
vs. scum RB and presumably scum MD and voyeur, one possibly being a fakeclaim

That seems bit unbalanced imo, what with scum having 1 to 2 investigatives and a RB

if duppin/haschel was the solve, I would assume one of them is goon lying

[Noraa]

Lol I was having fun in this game until just now

im sorry ;(

it must be tough having to decide knowing that ur one click away from destroying town. I sincerely hope we get scum!gamma today bc my opinion on haschel/duppin has wavered too much for me to be anywhere near confident limming there and honestly I'd be really stressed limming there today.

[Noraa]

Im still a lil worried duppin/gamma is the solve which is why im not confident in a haschel lim but then I could also see a town!duppin pushing scum!haschel hard rn.

[VP Baltar]

Ythaaaaaan

[Noraa]

I think I will just stay silent for a bit bc my stubborn ass won't compromise on a wagon besides gamma bc that's the one that im certain is scum. I'm being a stubborn ass and duppin(if town) is pretty dissatisfied with it. Either way, if duppin is town, he'll have to convince me tomorrow since my SR on haschel still isnt that strong that im certain I would vote there tmrw.