Musician Mafia: Guitarists GAME OVER

[Bambi Jay]

Hyper

Gravity

Compressor

'True Byppass'



Not clue what that means.

Whut. That sounds FUN! Too bad I can't effect myself I think. Unless Killswitch legit just makes me kill myself. I'm scared yet also very tempted to press that one.

[DrippingGoofball]

See? All I did was claim my role and now I'll just be scum in her eyes. Sad times.

All this AtE is awkward and weird.

[DrippingGoofball]

also a strong

FoS chkflip

Fucking come at me, dude.

You couldn't get it done yesterday.

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Then, you took out Titus at night, for the reasons I previously mentioned.

And you hard-rode a mislynch D2.

It's not enough for a vote, but it's enough for suspicion.[/quote]

Don't be a chicken, just vote. Join me.

[Galron]

Hyper

Gravity

Compressor

'True Byppass'



Not clue what that means.

Spectra townpoint vintage.

[Galron]

Toneprint

[Doctor Drew]

also a strong

FoS chkflip

Fucking come at me, dude.

You couldn't get it done yesterday.

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Then, you took out Titus at night, for the reasons I previously mentioned.

And you hard-rode a mislynch D2.

It's not enough for a vote, but it's enough for suspicion.

Don't be a chicken, just vote. Join me.[/quote]
Maybe it's the broken quote tags, but wasn't Chk hard against the IKS wagon? That's a weird way to buss.

[Gamma Emerald]

On that note, anyone who wants to attack a50 for pushing Looker can put their votes on me because I'm telling y'all a50 is town and you're gonna have to go through me first
That's right I'm holding myself accountable for someone else's vote, what you gonna do about it?

Scummilicious.

You are more certain of another player's towniness than your own.

Or I’m convinced enough of it to put myself on the line (if you’re serious)

[DrippingGoofball]

On that note, anyone who wants to attack a50 for pushing Looker can put their votes on me because I'm telling y'all a50 is town and you're gonna have to go through me first
That's right I'm holding myself accountable for someone else's vote, what you gonna do about it?

Scummilicious.

You are more certain of another player's towniness than your own.

Or I’m convinced enough of it to put myself on the line (if you’re serious)

Nah.
Not buying it.

[Gamma Emerald]

@Gamma because he was HARD pushing the mislynch, and I think of the two Pook is more likely scum here.

I guess that’s an okay thought process, but chk also hard DEFENDING IKS, who flipped scum as well. Not a great track record.

[Gamma Emerald]

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Wait what? I definitely recall chk defending IKS quite strongly, at least starting off.

[Doctor Drew]

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Wait what? I definitely recall chk defending IKS quite strongly, at least starting off.

Literally just said the same thing.

And Gamma, help me with A50...why exactly are you so certain of his towniness?

[Gamma Emerald]

The fact he suggested voting out a VT over a PR is in line with what I know of him, and the way he said it feels like town trying to actually play safe versus scum using it to get a miselim for cheap

[Doctor Drew]

I also think we could shred the VT claim rather than out a PR. We are not guaranteed to actually wagon scum if we chose not to go through with this wagon, so "we lose a town vote" isn't really a good argument. (Also, if VTs are meant to eat NKs, this one isn't because they've already claimed)

I'm surprised more people haven't chimed in on whether or not they believe my claim.

Personally, I do. I just think it's best if we eliminated a VT than force a PR to claim. Playing it safe, I guess.

In my experience, many a player act weird/scummy when they get a PR role. That doesn't mean everyone acting scummy is a PR, but it used to be a problem for me when I started playing Mafia and stayed that way for a while that whenever I received a PR role I'd be MUCH more suspected than when I was a VT. Even after I've learnt to adjust my play, I still couldn't help but suspect OTHER players acting weird, and then finding out the reason was they were PRs not scum.

So, let's put this all together: You were scummy to me (or I wouldn't have voted you in the first place). Them you claimed VT (which doesn't really explain why you were acting scummy to begin with). So the way I see it is if you are a VT 9and I have reason to think you might be) it's no big loss. If you are NOT (minor chance of that) then you are still SCUM who is faking to try and survive.

The alternative is to push/wagon someone else who appears to be acting scummy, force them to claim and go "Oh, SHIT! They're <Insert your favourite PR here> and THAT explains why they appeared to be acting scummy. Oh, well.. let's move on). Do you like this last scenario better??

I dunno, I just think these two posts show him too willing to go through with a shred on someone who he is relatively certain is town. Seems somewhat impersonal(if that makes sense) and calculated.

Doesn't scream town to me.

[Gamma Emerald]

that’s just how A50 thinks

[DrippingGoofball]

The fact he suggested voting out a VT over a PR is in line with what I know of him

That's NAI.

[Gamma Emerald]

That’s a building block for the actual reasoning for my read there.

[BrightEyedFish]

In other news fish is dumb or scum. I'm not betting on scum.

What is the point of this? Insecurity?

[a2rudeboy]

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Wait what? I definitely recall chk defending IKS quite strongly, at least starting off.

honestly, we are 120 pages in, so my recall may be shitty.

but, even then. chk defending the IKS developer role plays even more into a theory of why he would be scum.

[Doctor Drew]

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Wait what? I definitely recall chk defending IKS quite strongly, at least starting off.

honestly, we are 120 pages in, so my recall may be shitty.

but, even then. chk defending the IKS developer role plays even more into a theory of why he would be scum.

Have you ever played with Chk?

[a2rudeboy]

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Wait what? I definitely recall chk defending IKS quite strongly, at least starting off.

honestly, we are 120 pages in, so my recall may be shitty.

but, even then. chk defending the IKS developer role plays even more into a theory of why he would be scum.

Have you ever played with Chk?

I have not. This is my first game on site in 10 years.

[Doctor Drew]

All I'm saying is you replaced in, quickly saw there was no way anyone would believe you backing IKS, bussed him the fuck outta here.

Wait what? I definitely recall chk defending IKS quite strongly, at least starting off.

honestly, we are 120 pages in, so my recall may be shitty.

but, even then. chk defending the IKS developer role plays even more into a theory of why he would be scum.

Have you ever played with Chk?

I have not. This is my first game on site in 10 years.

He tends to get, how do I say nicely, passionate about his initial read and won't back down. His refusal to view IKS as scummy was terrible, but somewhat NAI for him.

I am not saying don't push him, but just my experience with him(and for the record I am leaning town on him).

[a2rudeboy]

Drew- that is fair.

There's a reason i haven't pushed it as far as bringing it to a vote.

But, the big thing for me was Titus getting killed N1, when I can't see a reason for it. And then I saw the scumthread chk posted, where he basically said "we get rid of titus or else we are fucked in the endgame" . Might just be confirmation bias. But I don't think all of these things combined are completely clean.

[Assemblerotws]

Day's started, but I won't be able to read through until tomorrow. Please be patient.

[Bambi Jay]

Oh... THAT Assemble. The guy who still has a quote from me misquoted and also I remember being a lurker and drunk one time.

[Lavender]

Need to read tomorrow, busy busy busy day