Newbie 2035 - Movie Facts (Game Over)

[NorwegianboyEE]

his/her being newbie doesn't mean that she/he has to be the townie! he/she can a newbie scum too, right? how do you reach the conclusion of his/her being townie here?

Their tone in their 3 posts so far have been very town. Newb!scum doesn't have the pre-necessitated skills to fake the type of content they've made, they just don't.
It's true that if i was scum i would know everyone's alignment beforehand. But calling out someone that could easily be elimination bait later on as town if i'm scum would be contrary to my wincon if i was mafia.

[NorwegianboyEE]

@Trendall
Yes, i understand what your actual motivation was now.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Just going off a gut feeling here,

This is an incredibly reliable method of decision and he is absolutely 100% scum.

These two stances don't match well so i'm wagering this slot is scum for now.

[Trendall]

fake the type of content they've made

They wouldn't have to 'fake' anything. Hypothetically a person could ask 'does the game last ten days' or 'can I replace into a new game'

without even knowing what role they are

.

[Trendall]

Just going off a gut feeling here,

This is an incredibly reliable method of decision and he is absolutely 100% scum.

These two stances don't match well so i'm wagering this slot is scum for now.

You know he was being ironic in the second one, no way you don't know that.

Vote: NorwegianboyEE

[Salsabil Faria]

his/her being newbie doesn't mean that she/he has to be the townie! he/she can a newbie scum too, right? how do you reach the conclusion of his/her being townie here?

Their tone in their 3 posts so far have been very town. Newb!scum doesn't have the pre-necessitated skills to fake the type of content they've made, they just don't.
It's true that if i was scum i would know everyone's alignment beforehand.

But calling out someone that could easily be elimination bait later on as town if i'm scum would be contrary to my wincon if i was mafia.

English is not my first language, can you explain me more about the green part of your quote? I don't understand properly

[NorwegianboyEE]

fake the type of content they've made

They wouldn't have to 'fake' anything. Hypothetically a person could ask 'does the game last ten days' or 'can I replace into a new game'

without even knowing what role they are

.

I didn't consider that possibility.
But even so, they've confirmed their role before the game started so this argument is void.

[Trendall]

Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if Zurel put those questions about replacing etc. in the mafia quick chat and NorwegianboyEE said to them 'say those in the main thread, it'll make you look really town'.

[Trendall]

fake the type of content they've made

They wouldn't have to 'fake' anything. Hypothetically a person could ask 'does the game last ten days' or 'can I replace into a new game'

without even knowing what role they are

.

I didn't consider that possibility.
But even so, they've confirmed their role before the game started so this argument is void.

It's not void, I said hypothetically and the hypothetical I had in mind was one where the person didn't have to confirm their role PM

[NorwegianboyEE]

Just going off a gut feeling here,

This is an incredibly reliable method of decision and he is absolutely 100% scum.

These two stances don't match well so i'm wagering this slot is scum for now.

You know he was being ironic in the second one, no way you don't know that.

Vote: NorwegianboyEE

Even if it was ironic i find the post awkward.

[Trendall]

What about it is awkward now though? Either it contradicts the other post, or it's being ironic and there's no contradiction. What's left that's awkward?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if Zurel put those questions about replacing etc. in the mafia quick chat and NorwegianboyEE said to them 'say those in the main thread, it'll make you look really town'.

Lol, i've never coached a newbie scum player in my life. And if i did i wouldn't be this blatant about it.
Do you think i'm a proponent of how to lose a game 101?

[NorwegianboyEE]

What about it is awkward now though? Either it contradicts the other post, or it's being ironic and there's no contradiction. What's left that's awkward?

God you're such a bore.

[Salsabil Faria]

Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if Zurel put those questions about replacing etc. in the mafia quick chat and NorwegianboyEE said to them 'say those in the main thread, it'll make you look really town'.

Lol, i've never coached a newbie scum player in my life. And if i did i wouldn't be this blatant about it.
Do you think i'm a proponent of how to lose a game 101?

[Trendall]

What about it is awkward now though? Either it contradicts the other post, or it's being ironic and there's no contradiction. What's left that's awkward?

God you're such a bore.

In other words you are now completely unable to explain your vote?

[NorwegianboyEE]

I have explained my vote.

[Trendall]

I have explained my vote.

You said that one post contradicted another post. I pointed out that there is no contradiction because the guy was being ironic.

You have gone 'it's still awkward tho'.

Which isn't an explanation.

What happened in the 30mins between post 11 and post 12? Did you go and read up on all the members of the game?

[NorwegianboyEE]

What happened in the 30mins between post 11 and post 12? Did you go and read up on all the members of the game?

Lol.
I said hello and was waiting to see if other players would post anything exciting, but they didn't so i took a break/looked at other games and then made an RVS vote because i thought it would spur discussion.

[Trendall]

Also NorwegianboyEE keeps putting these dismissive 'lols' and insulted me because they are a

mafia under pressure

.

Like those lols, if someone was doing that sort of nervous laughter in real life you'd know what was up straight away.

[NorwegianboyEE]

You have gone 'it's still awkward tho'.

Which isn't an explanation.

I disagree.
I find making a single post with a vote that combines jokey atmosphere but also is a player that's been voted previously to be awkward.

[Trendall]

That is a fair argument. Shame it took you a while to come up with it.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Also NorwegianboyEE keeps putting these dismissive 'lols' and insulted me because they are a

mafia under pressure

.

Like those lols, if someone was doing that sort of nervous laughter in real life you'd know what was up straight away.

No. I'm laughing at how seriously you're taking my posts.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Like you actually looked at the time i spent between my first and second post and had to question it.
That was funny to me.

[Trendall]

You have to take my posts seriously in order to assume that I'm taking yours seriously though, that's the thing.

[Trendall]

I didn't look at the times, when I was online yesterday I was following the threads and it struck me as weird that you double posted with a random vote after a bunch of time had passed. Because why not put the random vote in the first post?