Questionable Balcony

[Jake The Wolfie]

I got a Blue Result

[fferyllt]

We're not saying what ANY of us got back tonight and not speculating on Syr's sanity in the game thread.

[fferyllt]

Do we want to explain that we know via the modpost that there are one of each of the sanities?

I think it would be ok not to answer that question definitively for now.

[Tammy]

No idont think we need to answer that. And I think you actually stated it in your coming out post iirc so make them go back and read. Plus it’s kind of interesting to see who asks what

[Jake The Wolfie]

I think it'll be wise if we keep one of our scumreads hidden, so we can cop them and test our sanity.

[Tammy]

nacho is off tonight, so we're hanging out. I'll be around later if he passes out before me; otherwise I'll be around tomorrow.

[Tammy]

uhhh nadia's not knowing about the dethy feels a bit genuine?

[Tammy]

what is midway bear claiming?

[Tammy]

like midway bear more again.

[Tammy]

peta's scum are in ( ) is fairly similar to what we've been suggesting.

[fferyllt]

yeah. I like his list.

I'm starting to feel paranoid about cabd.

[fferyllt]

Paranoia alert downgraded to background noise.

[fferyllt]

Tammy, I know you want to take a slow approach to developing reads, so I don't want to pressure you at all in the game thread. Please tell me here if you don't want to get into it in the game thread, if you think the solve is problematic or if we're being way too complacent about the game have 2 masonries plus the dethy.

[Tammy]

I mean it’s pretty insane right?

Scum have got to have something to counter all this.

I don’t disbelieve the claims off the bat. Let me wrap my head around it.

I’ve got to get some stuff posted for one of my classes and then hang out with my sister. Should be back after unless I pass out but mafia insomnia is a thing!

[fferyllt]

I like what's happening in the game thread with Cabd and me not posting.

[Tammy]

Passed out almost as soon as I got done chatting with my sister.

I did think about the setup some.

But let me wale up and get my shit together and I’ll be back in here.

[Tammy]

I think we just got really lucky with the rand. The dethy in and of itself is swingy as hell; the likelihood that we end up with four masons is probably about equal to the likelihood we eat each other alive and potential confirmed town vote each other out. We just got really lucky that Taylor pretty much outed herself right away and you guys had the courage, and lack of paranoia, to out it at the appropriate time and be correct.

(NY 169 Cabd was a mason lol. I know think? that he wasn't crumbing that and that the the 169/167 referenced NY games, but I chuckled.)

Once the lover masons are outed they lose the utility of being masons really. AND one of the pair being doctors means that our protection is minimal.

Did cabd say they were vigilantes as well? What does novice mean?

I'm not totally on board with the idea that mafia new the identity of their traitor or vice versa. If she had no contact with her team, what is the use of the rolecop? I should read the mafia wiki on traitors again actually.

We'll be lucky if we get to resolve one of our sanities and have one useful result.

I would expect that scum have some decent power though. And I wonder if they have any extra killing power.

If cabd is fake claiming scum he set this up pretty early, but I don't think that's the world we're living in.

I didn't go back to see how Alisae/pooky were treating each other to verify if that claim makes sense. I'd like to believe they're not because I was already leaning townish on that pair anyway, so it'd be nice if I were right on those beginning leans.

I still only skimmed yesterday's stuff, but I'll be around pretty much all day. i have to get some lectures posted and grading done, but that still means I'm tethered to my computer so I'm here.

(still confused by bell)

[Tammy]

Dethy Masons:

Tammy (naive or sane)
Ffery (paranoid or insane)
Jake (naive or sane)
(Syryana ) (paranoid or insane)

Lover Masons (Millerizer/Vigs?)

Cabd
Something_Smart

Lover Masons Doctors

Alisae
Pooky

The rest

The Bulge - no neighborhood
Bell - no neighborhood?
sircakez -
midwaybear -
petapan -
GammaEmerald -
Diamond Sentinel -
Nadhia -

Mafia traitor rolecop

Tayl0r Swift - replaced out just as she was getting lynched properly dirty dirty

[Tammy]

I stopped filling in the neighborhood things because I don't know really what people have claimed and I just really wanted things separated out for reference

[Tammy]

What do you think about Nahdia? (My autocorrect sucks and keeps changing the spelling of their name)

I haven't gone to read back, but their not knowing about the dethy felt somewhat genuine in the moment when I read it. Not sure if they're one for attempting dumbtelling as scum. I'll have to see how I feel about it when I reread from start of day.

It does feel like Diamond Sentinel is focusing on names given to him and that feels just wrong. Day one he kept talking about us after midway asked him if he was having trouble reading us, and then I asked him about Nahdia and he's started to focus there. It's entirely possible this is coincidence! His scumhunting is super shallow, but I don't really expect too much more depth from him. Doesn't make him town though.

[Tammy]

Bulge still doesn't have any readable content.

[Tammy]

Gods this is so nice not having the paranoia I had yesterday. Now I just get to hang out and work on solving.

[Tammy]

I'll be back to reread from start of today once I get this lecture information posted. Shouldn't take me too long as this one is almost done.

[fferyllt]

Bell asked about mass claim, so he may have some sort of role.

Cabd/Something_Special are miller/lovers/novice vig, so N2 is the first chance they get to vig someone.

My strong townreads are: petapan, sir cakez.

I had midway bear in this tier because I thought Cabd had him so high in his reads list because midway was also in that neighborhood. But he's not.

since the lovers both die, I'm counting them as 1 player each for figuring out how good our solve has to be.

By that notation right now, we have 5 masons, and I have 2 strong town reads, leaving 8 unsorted players 3 of which are scum.

[fferyllt]

What do you think about Nahdia? (My autocorrect sucks and keeps changing the spelling of their name)

I haven't gone to read back, but their not knowing about the dethy felt somewhat genuine in the moment when I read it. Not sure if they're one for attempting dumbtelling as scum. I'll have to see how I feel about it when I reread from start of day.

It does feel like Diamond Sentinel is focusing on names given to him and that feels just wrong. Day one he kept talking about us after midway asked him if he was having trouble reading us, and then I asked him about Nahdia and he's started to focus there. It's entirely possible this is coincidence! His scumhunting is super shallow, but I don't really expect too much more depth from him. Doesn't make him town though.

I like Nadhia's day 2 content a lot better than day 1.

Does it seem at all odd that Nahdia focused on both of us on day 1, but didn't seem to care about the two players we were interacting with in odd ways? Or at least I was. Cabd and Syr.