Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[MURDERCAT]

Through page 15, more later

[Noraa]

I'd like an answer to this.

I believe this is normal Noraa voting behavior

I dont remember where exactly this was but I think it was when I didn't understand/know what a gravedigger was and I just thought it was some important pr and was like wtf y would u claim?

I think I'm clicking with primate on page 6

Good. Primate is in my town block so I like that you click with him.

Herta giving off major "you caught me for the wrong reasons" vibes here.

keeping my vote where it is for now, because a) i don't know how close Herta is to execution, and b) Assemble has given me no reason to stop wanting to vote him, but Herta wagon is good wagon.

I do agree with this

I did not agree with this. anyone want to go back to the herta thing and explain to me a bit about the "caught for the wrong reasons" thing?

[MURDERCAT]

The idea is Herta is upset because in his mind he did nothing scummy and is being poked at regardless. Obviously town could also be upset for being falsely accused.

[Noraa]

Ah so its a subjective type of thing. If you choose to see a scum!herta, this is scummy yet if you choose to see a town!herta, it is merely an upset townie

[MURDERCAT]

Well I think you should consider whether a townie actually gets upset there, there wasn't that much pressure

[Noraa]

Fair point. I've been having a hard time reading people lately as I realize that I react really weirdly to pressure at times which can get me a shit ton of SRs. I feel like its kind of like you mess up once and you just keep messing up until town mislims u. I struggle with reading flailing bc I flail as town more than I actually flail as scum. Idk its a big struggle for me to understand to what extent these are scum tells. I can see why Herta is really fishy now so ig I'd be more willing to go there than to go to ranny for now.

[Noraa]

Fair point. I've been having a hard time reading people lately as I realize that I react really weirdly to pressure at times which can get me a shit ton of SRs. I feel like its kind of like you mess up once and you just keep messing up until town mislims u. I struggle with reading flailing bc I flail as town more than I actually flail as scum. Idk its a big struggle for me to understand to what extent these are scum tells. I can see why Herta is really fishy now so ig I'd be more willing to go there than to go to ranny for now.

[SirCakez]

Votecount 1.8

Rannygazoo (4) - NoPowerOverMe, redcardinal, EchoVision, iamausername
Herta (2) - shellyc, Primate
redcardinal (1) - Noraa
shellyc (1) - Herta

Not voting (5) - Wiyvern, Iconeum, MURDERCAT, Rannygazoo, Titus

(expired on 2020-10-23 09:11:00) remain until day end

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to reach a majority.

Iconeum is V/LA until the end of the week
shellyc is V/LA through Sunday

[MURDERCAT]

VOTE: Herta

For now

[MURDERCAT]

Not voting (5) - Wiyvern, Iconeum, MURDERCAT, Rannygazoo, Titus

Curious why everyone who is not voting right now is not voting

[MURDERCAT]

just because no one is really pushing against it? consider that we likely have multiple small scum factions, and i don't think that's a reason to doubt that Herta is scum.

Hard agree

[MURDERCAT]

I don’t have an opinion on shelly v. Noraa, but yikes. Look at shelly’s record and she might make a good policy elim.

I feel like I’ll know more after a flip, and night actions start flying. That will allow us at least to count the scum factions, maybe

This post and the last sketch me out

[Noraa]

Oh wait why am I still on red cardinal?

[Noraa]

UNVOTE:

[EchoVision]

I do have a history of pushing and tunneling town hard

you don't say smh

[EchoVision]

ok so shelly is still on herta but constantly throwing shade at ranny. interesting.

i don't think it's that interesting
two scum reads
one is more confident than the other i'd imagine

[EchoVision]

Titus who should I be voting for.

Not sure. Either Ranny or shelly but they are not teamed. Gtmh shelly but i am not certain or else I would be voting there.

yeah titus is lock town thank u and good night

[NoPowerOverMe]

How is Titus lock town?

[EchoVision]

also shelly's null for me right now
which means shelly's prob town

whenever shelly's scum she pockets me and makes me town read her but i don't really read her this game but i haven't paid much attention to her because she hasn't pocketed me yet

part gut, also i like the uncertainty for town!titus
i'm thinkin scum is more certain on someone
the fact that her vote isn't down doesn't strike me as being careful, it reads with different intention

[EchoVision]

MURDERCAT replaces Assemble!

hi murder i missed u
let's keep you alive into d2 okay? thank u

[EchoVision]

huh no I'm not

this is the noraa case against me:
"player X is scum because they're playing in a protown way"
"player X is scum because they're sussing me"
"Noraa votes redcardinal"
"ah but I'm sussing player Y because they sus player X"

scum shelly doesn't defend herself this hard and shelly's been sus to noraa all game
scum shelly goes noraa shhhh then pockets noraa

long story short i think shelly's town because i don't know if shelly's town

[EchoVision]

the next step is to sort noraa which i cant because noraa's actually a pretty good scumplayer

also their trajectories as town are super weird and (no offense) incapable of obvtowning a lot of the time

you found the need to add on that its actually *GASP* possible that I am town?
I just think ur scum that realized u threw too much shade and backtracked like this

unlike you I do not have tmi

also you love meta, my scum play consists of hard tunnelling and taking strong action a lot of the time (and you know it). i almost never backtrack as scum

u fuck i hate this post

[EchoVision]

yes

Noraa constantly says herta/ranny are "not preferred" and "meh"
lightbulb moment that the solve is Noraa/herta/ranny (?)

is the 3 the game?
or is that one fac
or what
how many players are here, 13?
i guess 3 makes sense but i'm thinkin 4 at the least so who's your fourth
or do you think mb

[EchoVision]

I mean you should know from Roses that town Noraa can produce bad tunneled reads, what makes you think this is different?

sayyyy lesssssssssss

[EchoVision]

Im not engaging you any more. I've made it clear that I think you are scum but rn you are a vanity wagon so stop asking me.

noraa is your pfp a selfie