Bad Idea Mafia III: Still Bad, Less Broken [GAME OVER]

[PokerFace]

link to old game i am refering to Dynamite Stick Mafia http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?t=8119

[PokerFace]

My reads are I don't like those that claimed to have checked murdercat because I lean toward goons not having guns and that makes murdercat flipping town inevitable

[PokerFace]

or being seen as innocent by a cop as inevitable

[Toogeloo]

So, you are certain MurderCat is Town? You more or less are saying that with your posts passively while shading the "cop scans."

[MURDERCAT]

@pf we already are making it harder for cops with the hypo, I do think there is potential benefit but only at like D4

[PokerFace]

So, you are certain MurderCat is Town? You more or less are saying that with your posts passively while shading the "cop scans."

Certain, no
very likely, yes

point I am making is the setup says we have town day vigs and goons and gf. gf's have had day kill in past and gf's always appear innocent to cops. So unless goons can day kill, Mudercat will appear innocent to any cops. So checking mudercat is a waste

[Toogeloo]

MurderCat, you said you didn't want to shoot again. However, there might be benefit in you shooting at the 24 hour mark (or after that at least). Since you can't be the Cop, you firing again keeps them masked for longer.

PEdit: I didn't play previous games, but I know the game seemed easily broken with the last setup.

[PokerFace]

anyone play with tripod often? I don't think I ever did despite how long we both been on the site

[Toogeloo]

Also, my play times have gone down significantly since last I played. I no longer play on Sundays (device free day in our home), and Friday nights (family night).

I am headed to bed shortly, so you won't see me again until Monday.

[Toogeloo]

If anyone has anything for me, now's the time. Otherwise...

[Toogeloo]

Good night.

[MURDERCAT]

MurderCat, you said you didn't want to shoot again. However, there might be benefit in you shooting at the 24 hour mark (or after that at least). Since you can't be the Cop, you firing again keeps them masked for longer.

If there is general consensus this is best I'm fine with it, but I think there is a lot of benefit in picking someone scummy and saying "hey you, daykill this other scummy person or you get shot"

[shellyc]

Bah!

[MURDERCAT]

If people agree with me, I think we should vote with a format like

VOTE: MURDERCAT kills shelly

[PokerFace]

And in case it wasn't obvious you claiming you saw murdercat as innocent makes you suspect in my mind because you are not acting like a good cop and you need to act that way. Claiming him as innocent kinda gives us all less info since I kinda already explained why it very likely he would been seen as innocent by cops

This why I
VOTE: Toogeloo kills echovision
or
VOTE: echovision kills toogeloo
either one is fine and equal in my mind

[MURDERCAT]

Wouldn't scum be more likely to be aware of that?

[PokerFace]

Wouldn't scum be more likely to be aware of that?

Can you elaborate? You calling them scum, me scum, or them town?

[MURDERCAT]

I'm thinking that town dayvig is more likely to give a lazy hypo compared to scum. Also a chance that if others had the thought about goons shooting they genuinely looked at me as that's valuable setup info

[the worst]

My reads are I don't like those that claimed to have checked murdercat because I lean toward goons not having guns and that makes murdercat flipping town inevitable

he's also like the only memorable player in this game so far (no offense to you, esurio or peta who are tied for a close second) and, despite mechanically probably being town, is also the only person making towny posts.

But functionally yes I'm perplexed by the MURDERCAT checks. I also think they're weakly >rand town.

[T-Bone]

I wanna kill something tell me why it shouldn't be you????

[the worst]

MurderCat, you said you didn't want to shoot again. However, there might be benefit in you shooting at the 24 hour mark (or after that at least). Since you can't be the Cop, you firing again keeps them masked for longer.

PEdit: I didn't play previous games, but I know the game seemed easily broken with the last setup.

interesting
if we operate under the assumption we'll never know whether scum can dayvig, it might be better to mechanically lean into cop checks more than vigclears and basically let the godfather run deep until we kill them in the endgame~

Toogeloo you make my brain tingly

[the worst]

anyone play with tripod often? I don't think I ever did despite how long we both been on the site

he doesn't play mafia much, it's either a skittle worrying that UT can read them or someone trying to make us think a skittle is worrying that UT can read them or it's just a lolrandom kill

what happened to the "must be excited because pre-in" theory?

[the worst]

killvoting smh

you guys really want to use the added utility of dayvigs to hand scum the game huh

[petapan]

personally i would kill him because the mods are my enemy

[Micc]

Whew good thing I’m not a mod any more