mystery box of silver 10. (done)

[MathBlade]

Right. I don’t trust Gamma. He was outed scum.

Plus also Menalque flipped town when Gamma said they weren’t town.

So what exactly stops this?

[MathBlade]

I mean it’s much more likely there’s group scum or that’s a Hell of a gambit by Titus and Mastina but I will be damned if the idea of evil 3P doesn’t leave my brain.

[Almost50]

I mean. You’re taking gamma at his word after he outed “not town” aligned.

What non-Scum claims Scum upon their death?? Why tag his whole faction as SCUM if they are not???

[MathBlade]

I mean. You’re taking gamma at his word after he outed “not town” aligned.

What non-Scum claims Scum upon their death?? Why tag his whole faction as SCUM if they are not???

Mastina’s wolverine game for starters. I claimed about 20 different things other than scum to try to give my team an edge.

3P is technically scum to most people on site as site meta.

[Titus]

is april flipping scum? how confident are you?

95% confident
The made up sole read on Gamma I believe it's actually Chemist who posted that.
The fact April's disappeared
The fact April went after the 3ps so aggressively
The fact April was a non-entity on the wagons d1 minus the shelly wagon
The fact April tried to push a lynch on Shelly pre-"clear" without arguing there was a flaw in the clearing mechanism
The fact April allegedly motion detected me, while claiming to have me as town. Yet, she comes in supposing her motion detect is a guilty rather than scum visiting me. She investigated a townread over a scumread like mastina.
The fact April wanted a townread based on her detecting motion.
The fact April egged on the cultist bullshit.
The fact April crapped on my VCA but never puts forth any army reads of her own.
The fact mastina and I agree on this read.

The only concern I have is how easy it is.

[Almost50]

It's not even 50/50. If she's scum and got something and she knows you're either loyal or disloyal, then obviously she knows you're disloyal and should claim she didn't get anything.

= mechanically I am more likely to be scum

How does the quote translate to what you say?? If I draw a ball form a bowl that contains 3 red balls and 6 blue balls, how likely do I get a.. BALL??

My point is your reaction would have been the exact same thing regardless of your alignment. If the same alignment as Plus you got nothing, and if a different alignment you got it and would have known he was Disloyal because he is not in your PT.

That would have applied if Plus targeted ME, btw (except I would have claimed I got it because I already outed on D1). But if we hypothetically assume we didn't out and Plus handed me that Cop shot on N1 and we didn't want to out yet, then I'd know I got a Cop shot and it most definitely didn't come from ny Mason partners, so if someone claims they did it and they're either Loyal or Disloyal I'd know for a fact they're Disloyal and would say I didn't get it. Now if I was pure Town (green PM) I still would have said I didn;t get it, because I really didn't.

IT IS NAI

[superbowl9]

they didn't know it was disloyal

GDI that's NOT the issue. Lets' assume HYPOTHETICALLY that shelly is scum here. Let's assume that she did get a Cop shot. Now.. in that very situation she knows a) Her own alignment is NOT Town, b) that she did receive the Cop shot, and c) That you are NOT of the same alignment as she is.

This means that she knows she got a Cop shot from someone who IS NOT ALIGNED WITH HER, thus she KNOWS you are DISLOYAL.

You can TR shelly as much as you want based in PLAY, but when it vomes to MECHANICS she is NOT AT ALL CLEARED.

And this is why we dont give out info baselessly kids, even if we think it's nice to have everyone on the same page

[MathBlade]

they didn't know it was disloyal

GDI that's NOT the issue. Lets' assume HYPOTHETICALLY that shelly is scum here. Let's assume that she did get a Cop shot. Now.. in that very situation she knows a) Her own alignment is NOT Town, b) that she did receive the Cop shot, and c) That you are NOT of the same alignment as she is.

This means that she knows she got a Cop shot from someone who IS NOT ALIGNED WITH HER, thus she KNOWS you are DISLOYAL.

You can TR shelly as much as you want based in PLAY, but when it vomes to MECHANICS she is NOT AT ALL CLEARED.

And this is why we dont give out info baselessly kids, even if we think it's nice to have everyone on the same page

Correct. I said that before when we had two claims out.

But some information you do give.

[Almost50]

meanwhile, while you all argue Nero is vote parked on scum.

Why is Taylor scum? I want her to be scum but my scumhunting is leading me a different way.

i want taylor to be scum too!!

Hmmm.. that explains why you put a 0 instead of the o. So are you Katy Perry, Nicki Minaj, or Scooter Braun??

Oh, WAIT! I know who you are.. Kanye West!

[MathBlade]

meanwhile, while you all argue Nero is vote parked on scum.

Why is Taylor scum? I want her to be scum but my scumhunting is leading me a different way.

i want taylor to be scum too!!

Hmmm.. that explains why you put a 0 instead of the o. So are you Katy Perry, Nicki Minaj, or Scooter Braun??

Oh, WAIT! I know who you are.. Kanye West!

Nope! That’s my job. I stole the mic from Titus and Mastina and declared April should be Townie of the year
But we’re gonna give April the execution anyway.

[MathBlade]

I guess shouldn’t try humor Okay I tried to make people smile.

No more jokes.

[Almost50]

I want Titus to neighborize someone they townread so the win con is public.

i volunteer

OBJECTION!

You are NOT confirmed and I -for one- still SR you, so HELL NO!

(Also I am not telling Titus/mastina/Nero how to play, so they do what they want to and I will give them my opinion IF they ask for it.. in private)

[Almost50]

just hoods sound cool and i wanna try being in one and I'll not lurk so yeah

plus there is no guarantee of tp, but with the not mason theory it sounds plausible
im in not masons camp btw

VOTE: shelly

This is the exact same thing Gamma attempted here:

Tbh I really need a place where I can ramble away from the thread so if anyone's a neighborizer please target me

This series has "

heavy information to mafia

"

(check the signups thread), and I am now POSITIVE Scum already knew about the neighborizer thing being in-play.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I also thought for a couple seconds they were claiming member of the scum army tbh.

Hey EE, care to talk reads with me?

Anyone specific?

Pickaxe and Chemist

I townread Pickaxe Pete pretty strongly, as for Chemist1422 i townread them less but not really seeing them as all that scummy.

[NorwegianboyEE]

This is the exact same thing Gamma attempted here:

Is that before or after Neighborizer claimed?

[NorwegianboyEE]

When Shelly did it i mean.

[superbowl9]

After

[NorwegianboyEE]

Then i don't really see how it's scummy A50.

[MathBlade]

This is the exact same thing Gamma attempted here:

Is that before or after Neighborizer claimed?

Gamma died D1
Titus claimed D2 iirc

Correct me if wrong please

[Almost50]

I want Titus to neighborize someone they townread so the win con is public.

i volunteer

Titus doesn’t say who except she gives a list of townreads at EoD and then picks one at random who she thinks won’t get killed. Then she and her buddies share the wincon and it gets paraphrased out.

None of this generic “i side with town crap” I want specifics.

I'll say it again: Society will decide on their own and they know what to do best. Also, since we share a hood the 2 factions combined know a whole lot more than the average Townie, so excuse me when I say you are drifting far far away from the correct path to Town victory with your wild theories. (You're entitled to them, but this is a gentle reminder that I do know MUCH more than you do now, plus -as I said to Swift- what the hell are you thinking? If we are "scorched earth" and they are also, how the hell does that make us allies? Shouldn't we be fighting each other because -to my understanding- scorched earth means we win when everyone else has lost. No?

[Almost50]

I mean, seriously now.. why do people join Larges when they can't keep up and do not intend to read AT ALL? I can understand if you have a sudden IRL issue, and I appreciate that everyone could miss one or two details through this mess, but someone who doesn't read AT ALL, and wants to be spoon fed everything like they are the center of the universe is unacceptable.

/end rant

[Titus]

I also thought for a couple seconds they were claiming member of the scum army tbh.

Hey EE, care to talk reads with me?

Anyone specific?

Pickaxe and Chemist

I townread Pickaxe Pete pretty strongly, as for Chemist1422 i townread them less but not really seeing them as all that scummy.

Can you explain how you TR them?

Who do you think is scum?

[Bell]

Sorry.
Sorry.

It’s irl stuff+Health issues.
I’m contemplating taking a 24 hour v/la or something.

Also, yay another 2 and a half hour nap.

[Bell]

Though, even in the best of times i’m Severely underequipt to solve this kind of complex game format. I lack the fundamental experience.

[MathBlade]

I want Titus to neighborize someone they townread so the win con is public.

i volunteer

Titus doesn’t say who except she gives a list of townreads at EoD and then picks one at random who she thinks won’t get killed. Then she and her buddies share the wincon and it gets paraphrased out.

None of this generic “i side with town crap” I want specifics.

I'll say it again: Society will decide on their own and they know what to do best. Also, since we share a hood the 2 factions combined know a whole lot more than the average Townie, so excuse me when I say you are drifting far far away from the correct path to Town victory with your wild theories. (You're entitled to them, but this is a gentle reminder that I do know MUCH more than you do now, plus -as I said to Swift- what the hell are you thinking? If we are "scorched earth" and they are also, how the hell does that make us allies? Shouldn't we be fighting each other because -to my understanding- scorched earth means we win when everyone else has lost. No?

1) Okay then. Decide your plan. But if you come up with trust me it’s conf and back off I will give you the same shit as Titus.

2) You clearly misread my point or i miss explained it. As. I said it was moon logic and it’s eating at me that doesn’t make it right. I am thinking a lot of things. I just have a really strong feeling this April exe is bad. Nearly everything Titus is doing is bad. I am thinking do anything to stop her so we don’t lose.