X is already fixed at NoraaIn post 1791, Hopkirk wrote:The issue is this
If Taylor is town and thinks you're scum then the actual order would be
Taylor-Pooky-One of Taylor's townreads
That's a shit bargain for Taylor. If she dies she absolutely wants to be in the middle.
Like nobody would EVER accept that because it's literally the worst possible outcome except for hitting 3 town since she dies and the mafia get the effective nightkill. It's far superior for her to kill someone she scumreads with the first slot. I especially don't get why you think Taylor as a player would like the deal based on the personality read I'm forming around her. What you SHOULD be asking her is whether she'd accept Pooky-Taylor-X since that's a deal town would consider taking. Choosing not to make that deal ensures she'll never take it as either alignment.
You're also definitely overestimating your game impact.
I might be over-estimating game impact sure.