Newbie 2037 - Game Over

[Rockhopper]

Hey Norwboy!

Would you like to continue the chess match?

Let's leave that for the scum PT.

:>

Okie :3

[NorwegianboyEE]

Rocky, Dunnstral and Italiano - if i'm scum, who is my scumbuddy?

Wtf is this post?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Also, I have no problem with being eliminated, but lets be sensible and give it another calendar day or 2 before we go through the E1 process.

Hmm. I’m trying to figure out if this is scum-motivated or town-motivated. What do his voters think? What does everyone else think?

It always sounds scummy to say "i'm fine being eliminated but just wait a little plz".

[NorwegianboyEE]

Also, I have no problem with being eliminated, but lets be sensible and give it another calendar day or 2 before we go through the E1 process.

In what universe is town ever okay with being eliminated? Being okay with being eliminated is not game solving at all

VOTE: NorfolkBoy1

That makes it E-1

I disagree with this notion.
The vote looks kinda sus to me ngl

Why is the vote sus?

[Rockhopper]

I'm getting more townie feels from rockhopper currently

Wanna form a townblock?

Honestly, I feel this isn't how townblocks are supposed to work. A townblock is an agreement that forms gradually between two players, without a formal request, where they will townread each other and defend each other through anything. This feels more like buddying to me.

^
I don't think Rockhopper is scummy for suggesting this as they are new. But their trust in Facebones here seems very premature.

Aren't D1 townblocks the most accurate?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Norfolk claiming tracker. I suppose that makes sense with their play of "who is scum buddy" "just wait" and etc. They were trying to use their role as a way to hunt.
I see what they were doing now. I believe their claim.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I'm getting more townie feels from rockhopper currently

Wanna form a townblock?

Honestly, I feel this isn't how townblocks are supposed to work. A townblock is an agreement that forms gradually between two players, without a formal request, where they will townread each other and defend each other through anything. This feels more like buddying to me.

^
I don't think Rockhopper is scummy for suggesting this as they are new. But their trust in Facebones here seems very premature.

Aren't D1 townblocks the most accurate?

According to what?

[NorwegianboyEE]

I’m not sure if I believe this. I think you’re really stretching it with all the “crumbs”. I’m sure everyone can go through their posts and highlight words and say they’re crumbing a role.

[MiniMegabyte]

Current Reads List (Updated since my most recent posts)

Spoiler:

Town

Norfolk

(Non-CC Claim Tracker)

Billy

(AT the beginning it was a bit strange that they had their votes everywhere but as they got further into the game they are probably one of the few people that I know of actually giving the game a kick forward. I see this by them asking a lot of questions and attempting to engage others.)

Facebones

(Asks a lot of questions and tries to get the game moving. Again one of the few people to do so and just seems townie atm)

Rockhopper

(Makes a lot of comments and asks people to gain information through reactions and this to me seems like a pretty townie move along with their post of the unlikely pairings from what they think. It seems as though they arent afraid of sharing thoughts which is pretty townie in my eyes)

Null

Backslash

(Very few posts but there is two of them that really contradict each other one of the posts being the answers to Italiano's RQS 46 and 116 - Though this could just be the truth but to me their answer to question 3 really contradicts their next post after that. While they are contradicting I do think that post 169 is a townie post as they are throwing their thoughts out there. This is why they are null for now because i am just not sure.)

Italiano

(I dont really know what to think about them something seems weird to me but I cant really explain it. Its bad I know i am going to do a full ISO dive on them to see if anything can give me some real direction)

Wiyvern

(Not many posts so really cant get anything from what they have said apart from their read list and its not really somethign i would like to go off of at this point but it is good they shared their reads with everyone.)

Scum

Dunnstral

(Very few posts and barely any content. Now this is going to seem very OMGUS but really look at their ISO they vote Norfolk outta gut-which isnt too bad- and then unvotes Norfolk because of no CC which is fair. However they dont give any reason as to why they vote me apart from the points made from two other players are "good enough for a vote". These are the only content points and one of them is sheeped)

Based on this read list i am going to put my vote here

VOTE: Dunnstral

[MiniMegabyte]

That’s for Norwegian is regards to 393

[NorwegianboyEE]

UNVOTE:

[NorwegianboyEE]

Gonna be honest with you, i'm not seeing scum!Dunn so far.

[MiniMegabyte]

Can you explain why? They literally haven’t got many posts and with barely any content

[NorwegianboyEE]

I was definitely hoping that people would be able to sense what was happening without me having to explicitly say it.

Come on. No one here are mind readers. You gotta do better than this. Again your tracker claim is a role that can’t be confirmed unless there is a flip because it’s easy to fake missed tracks and just say you tracked who was night-killed. Your plea didn’t seem like you wanted to stay alive to find scum, but to simply stay alive.

I really don't like your continuing voting Norfolk. I get that Billy can be the stubborn type, but you as well? Why don't you believe their tracker claim?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Can you explain why? They literally haven’t got many posts and with barely any content

That's how they always play.
Why is low content and posts scummy?

[MiniMegabyte]

Can you explain why? They literally haven’t got many posts and with barely any content

That's how they always play.
Why is low content and posts scummy?

It’s what I’ve learnt from me playing my games

[MiniMegabyte]

Sorry to cut this short but it’s 11:20pm and I’m off to bed will check in again in the morning night all!

[NorwegianboyEE]

Can you explain why? They literally haven’t got many posts and with barely any content

That's how they always play.
Why is low content and posts scummy?

It’s what I’ve learnt from me playing my games

Are those mostly newbie games perhaps? I would understand if you were referring to that because most newb!scum say barely anything because they are afraid to mess up and get exposed. But some town just don't say a lot in general, Dunnstral is that type from my experience. And they are SE so i don't think they would lose their cool from rolling scum and have low content on purpose.

[Rockhopper]

I'm getting more townie feels from rockhopper currently

Wanna form a townblock?

Honestly, I feel this isn't how townblocks are supposed to work. A townblock is an agreement that forms gradually between two players, without a formal request, where they will townread each other and defend each other through anything. This feels more like buddying to me.

^
I don't think Rockhopper is scummy for suggesting this as they are new. But their trust in Facebones here seems very premature.

Aren't D1 townblocks the most accurate?

According to what?

Probability (if we don't elim scum D1)

[NorwegianboyEE]

Probability (if we don't elim scum D1)

Probability...?

[NorwegianboyEE]

If your townblock depends on probability then it's bad.
Sorry to crush your world there.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Also, I have no problem with being eliminated

I'm Town Tracker.

Um what? I go back to my point of asking in what universe is Town especially a Town PR ever okay with being eliminated????

Like i said, their play makes sense and fits with their claim.
Sure it's not optimal play, but it makes sense and it's something i'd believe coming from a newbie.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Norfolk Boy 1- Town. He claimed tracker and there hasn't been a cc. I don't see any reason to lynch him.

Fair enough.

@Italiano
Do you scumread Norfolk still, even though most players seems to believe their claim and there's been no CC?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Spoiler:

Thanks for the welcome everyone! Anyways, I just finished reading everything so, here's my reads.

Norfolk Boy 1- Town. He claimed tracker and there hasn't been a cc. I don't see any reason to lynch him.
Facebones- Town. I've liked their posts, and they seem to be solving pretty well. I also agreed with a lot if things they saud when I was reading through everything.
Rockhopper- Slight Town. Basically for the same reasons as Facebones, but to a lesser extent. And tbh, I'm not entirely sure I agreed with things they said because them and Facebones started to blur together after some time. I might iso them seperately later so I get a better idea, but for now, I think this is good.
Billy Pilgrim- Very Slight Town. Man, I've been flip-flopping around with this slot so much. I originally town read them a little bit, then some posts of theirs pinged me, and eventually I went back to just town reading them. It's kind of a gut read ig.
Dunnstral- Null(mostly). They exist. I don't think they've done that much, but I got to admit, none of their posts seem necessarily bad to me, so if I had to call them town or mafia, I'd say town.
Bakslash- Null probably. I really just don't remember a lot from them, so I don't have much to say. Will probably iso later.
ItalianoVD- Leaning Scum. They seem to be agreeing with a lot of stuff. From their posts, I don't remember seeing a ton of individual thoughts not said by others ready. IIRC they made two or three consecutive posts saying they agreed with something. I'm not saying you can't ever agree with anyone, but I feel like Italiano might be agreeing a bit too much.
MiniMegabyte- Scum. I flip flopped on her originally, but after I read through the game more and more, my scumread on her grew more and more. It's mostly because I don't feel like they've contributed much. A lot of their posts(iirc) have been more like fluff posts and/or not related to reads and game advancing stuff.

This is a scum reads list. Noticing how many of the slot descriptions have essentially the exact same reasoning of: "They haven't contributed much."
Yet some are null, town, scum. None of it really makes a whole lot of sense. Making me believe it was more likely manufactured than genuine.
Their words on Italiano: "Agreeing too much." Most ridiculous thing i've heard. There are some reasons to suspect Italiano, that isn't one of them. Are we even reading the same game?

VOTE: Wiyvern

[NorwegianboyEE]

Rockhopper, wanna vote scum with me?