Musician Mafia: Guitarists GAME OVER

Almost50 · Post Post #5575 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 12:04 pm

In post 5569, davesaz wrote:Rude's way of asking the question implies he's one of the 3p btw.

I also got that same impression.

TiphaineDeath · Post Post #5576 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 1:33 pm

Wait, @Baker, wasn't I voting Rude?

Also, Rude, you need to claim 3P or die today, and then if you do grendel can have the same option.

pisskop · Post Post #5577 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 1:39 pm

yea, im pretty sure that was a 3p slip

davesaz · Post Post #5578 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 3:24 pm

Yo pisskop your vote is misplaced again.

Grendel · Post Post #5579 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 3:27 pm

TiphaineDeath wrote:Wait, @Baker, wasn't I voting Rude?

Also, Rude, you need to claim 3P or die today, and then if you do grendel can have the same option.

So if he claims 3rd party, and I dont claim 3rd party you'd flip me?

That train of thought makes no sense. Both players (Him and I) openly said that our role pm said that others in the band dont share our alignment. Him claiming 3rd party means Im not 3rd party.

I;ve siad this a couple times now, but for some reason players keep insisting this is some kind of 3rd party v 3rd party scenario with no basis outside of the Mod's being quirky.

Grendel · Post Post #5580 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 3:34 pm

In post 5568, pisskop wrote:it says, according to both:

you know that the other band members are not your alignment. 3 3p with differing wincons does seem to constitute that.

Im town not 3rd party, and I'll die on that hill lol.

Grendel · Post Post #5581 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 3:45 pm

Baker

In post 5550, Grendel wrote:
@Baker

Hmm, do indies with separate win-cons counted as separate alignments? or same?

Can you answer this please?

-/-/-/-

I dont find this 3rd party vs 3rd party talk to be an effective use of speculation. Hopefully if my assumptions are correct then we can just move things along.

Grendel · Post Post #5582 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 3:53 pm

Given that everybody has checked in to the thread since I cliamed. I feel I can safely say Rude is 3rd party, Im town, and the other member of our band is scum.

Theres a very slim chance the remining member is 3rd party, and rude is scum. If that were so then that 3rd party is prob anti-town indie. Pro-town indie would have calimed so we could safely consolidate onto rude scum. Ergo, its less complicated for rude to just be an indie, and the hidden member is scum.

-//-/-/-

I guess im still ok flipping rude, but I'd rather hit scum... :/

I have to think.

Doctor Drew · Post Post #5583 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 3:59 pm

In post 5581, Grendel wrote:
Baker

In post 5550, Grendel wrote:
@Baker

Hmm, do indies with separate win-cons counted as separate alignments? or same?
Can you answer this please?

-/-/-/-

I dont find this 3rd party vs 3rd party talk to be an effective use of speculation. Hopefully if my assumptions are correct then we can just move things along.

Not sure how I missed your post about this, but I was thinking about this as well today. I would assume different alignments mean town, scum, 3p. I can't see how you can call separate 3p's as a 'different alignment'.

Also I am

Fredrik Thordendal from Meshuggah

.

Pre Edit: Ya I came to that conclusion, more or less, yesterday Grendel...and I do feel confident you would be the town in this 1v1.

The Baker · Post Post #5584 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 4:40 pm

In post 5581, Grendel wrote:
Baker

In post 5550, Grendel wrote:
@Baker

Hmm, do indies with separate win-cons counted as separate alignments? or same?
Can you answer this please?

-/-/-/-

I dont find this 3rd party vs 3rd party talk to be an effective use of speculation. Hopefully if my assumptions are correct then we can just move things along.

In most cases, win con determines my understanding of alignment.

NoPowerOverMe · Post Post #5585 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 4:52 pm

Of Course Grendel will say that he is town but is there really any evidence of that?

Gamma Emerald · Post Post #5586 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:02 pm

:/
Maybe he scum/3p, but where’s the evidence of THAT? Imo his posting lacks scummy vibes both generally and from what I know of him, but I don’t profess to read him especially well. I remember he sorta fooled me in a game a little bit back. Even then, compared to my last game with him his posting feels leagues more natural, bearing in mind he replaced in for both games which means about even slates for evaluation.

Doctor Drew · Post Post #5587 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:17 pm

Tbh, I was null on Walter and Grendel has seemed very townie since he subbed in. If it is a choice between who is town between Rude and Grendel I will choose Grendel 9 times out of ten.

NPOM, kind of seems like you are trying to protect Rude.

NoPowerOverMe · Post Post #5588 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:21 pm

Not at all, I'm for shredding him.

Gamma Emerald · Post Post #5589 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:26 pm

Why are you trying to push the target on Grendel, then?

a2rudeboy · Post Post #5590 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:38 pm

In post 5588, NoPowerOverMe wrote:Not at all, I'm for shredding him.

Your vote says differently.

NoPowerOverMe · Post Post #5591 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:46 pm

I just don't see the difference either way.

Doctor Drew · Post Post #5592 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:51 pm

In post 5591, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I just don't see the difference either way.

If this whole Periphery business is to be believed, it means that only one of them is town.

Seems to make a bit of difference.

a2rudeboy · Post Post #5593 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:53 pm

In post 5592, Doctor Drew wrote:
In post 5591, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I just don't see the difference either way.
If this whole Periphery business is to be believed, it means that only one of them is town.

Seems to make a bit of difference.

Do you not believe the Periphery business?

NoPowerOverMe · Post Post #5594 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:54 pm

I don't necessarily believe any of them is town

a2rudeboy · Post Post #5595 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:57 pm

NPOM, i'm curious what you think your own town credentials are

NoPowerOverMe · Post Post #5596 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 6:01 pm

A green roll pm.

Doctor Drew · Post Post #5597 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 6:02 pm

In post 5593, a2rudeboy wrote:
In post 5592, Doctor Drew wrote:
In post 5591, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I just don't see the difference either way.
If this whole Periphery business is to be believed, it means that only one of them is town.

Seems to make a bit of difference.
Do you not believe the Periphery business?

Oh I am pretty sure I do, more making a point to NPOM.

a2rudeboy · Post Post #5598 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 6:07 pm

It's no use makng points to NPOM, he's just waiting to see which wagon gains more cred so he can hop on

Doctor Drew · Post Post #5599 (ISO) » Mon Nov 09, 2020 6:11 pm

In post 5598, a2rudeboy wrote:It's no use makng points to NPOM, he's just waiting to see which wagon gains more cred so he can hop on

Also, you did basically 3p slip...any response to that?

This is directed to Rude.