Musician Mafia: Guitarists GAME OVER

[a2rudeboy]

It's no use makng points to NPOM, he's just waiting to see which wagon gains more cred so he can hop on

Also, you did basically 3p slip...any response to that?

This is directed to Rude.

Nah.

[Doctor Drew]

It's no use makng points to NPOM, he's just waiting to see which wagon gains more cred so he can hop on

Also, you did basically 3p slip...any response to that?

This is directed to Rude.

Nah.

Compelling argument, but you did basically say you were 3p.

[NoPowerOverMe]

Says the player who only wants to policy.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: rudeboy
Frozen 3p ez

[NoPowerOverMe]

What makes Grendel in a more favorable position than rude besides him saying that he's town.

[Doctor Drew]

What makes Grendel in a more favorable position than rude besides him saying that he's town.

Did you miss Rude basically 3p slippling??

[NoPowerOverMe]

That doesn't make grendel not 3P or Scum.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

im down to elim rude unless he claims a 3p role thats honest

[TiphaineDeath]

I find myself in agreement with the bear. My only issue is that this game has been so full of trolls that I'm worried we gonna flip rude and he's gonna be 3P without claiming, then we're gonna flip grendel and he's gonna be town, then we gonna cry :/. Like, I kind of wanted to kill rude and grendel before this all started, but this whole situation feels funky x_X.

[a2rudeboy]

I find myself in agreement with the bear. My only issue is that this game has been so full of trolls that I'm worried we gonna flip rude and he's gonna be 3P without claiming, then we're gonna flip grendel and he's gonna be town, then we gonna cry :/. Like, I kind of wanted to kill rude and grendel before this all started, but this whole situation feels funky x_X.

I already claimed.

[TiphaineDeath]

But this doesn't-make-sense. You 100% cannot both be town, otherwise you are 100% trolling, but I can't find the scum motivation for this play, at all, unless you are both scum, which, is actually kind of starting to go back to being the most likely possible reality....

[NoPowerOverMe]

I still don't see the reason for presuming town grendal besides setup spec.

[pisskop]

good news is if rude flips green then we powerrope grendel.

and if rude flips red we never shred grendel.

[NoPowerOverMe]

I'm still confused why they can't both be red/grey.

But whatevs.

VOTE: Rude

[TiphaineDeath]

Yeah, same thing I said to rude applies to grendel, if you are 3P in all this you really do need to hardclaim it now, because it looks like we are after rude first, but if rude flips green then you're gonna die mate. Like, if he is an idiot and doesn't claim and flips gray then MAYBE you get to live, but if you're gray you gotta tell us.

Honestly at this point if rude flips red I am like 75% tempted to call this a gambit and powerlynch grendel ANYWAY.

[Almost50]

@NPOM: THANK YOU for TOTALLY confusing me. Now my mind is ponging me that I may have been pocketed by my "strongest 2 TRs" and that you may actually be Scum with Rude (which would make me look like the biggest fool of all).

I am precisely referring to your vote being parked on Grendel while:

(A) Arguing he might be "3P"

simultaneously

with rude also being 3P
(B) Claiming you would shred rude, but not voting him when he has the larger wagon of the two

My own reason for not having voted rude is I TR'd him (didn't think he was 3P to begin with). I was also kind of happy to see you leaning towards a Grendel shredd because it coincided with my read (of rude being a stronger TR), and because I has TR'd you the most.

The last few posts though suggest I may have been a fool, and although I know rude claimed 3P it still puts a dent in my read on YOU, the way you are voting and arguing.

VOTE: rude

@rude: So many "theories" are running through my mind, and I apologize if one of them is true.

Explanation: I am thinking "maybe" rude is a Survivour, or he may have needed to outlive the other 2, or he maybe an Eliminator on one of them.. etc. I mean, this is a Baker game and I'd rather not bet on the kind of weird shit he is capable of implementing (but I'd happily place my mortgage that there IS some kind of weird shit)


P-edit: Did I take THAT long in typing this up??

[Almost50]

Honestly at this point if rude flips red I am like 75% tempted to call this a gambit and powerlynch grendel ANYWAY.

I said THE BAKER thinks of weird shit. You are NOT The Baker, so why on earth did your mind go in that direction? And -more importantly- what do they gain from it?

[NoPowerOverMe]

I didn't vote Rude initially because I felt I was already on a potential red/grey slot. Nothing sinister.

[Grendel]

I believe thats Elim minus 1.

Im good to go for a rude flip, but i would liked if we finished the mass flavor claim first. Tmk Pooky claimed a trolly flavor, and Lavender hasnt said anyhting on the subject. Was there anybody else?

[Bambi Jay]

If you want you can help me decide my night 6 action that would be nice.

[NoPowerOverMe]

What options do you have left?

[Grendel]

Baker

@Baker

Hmm, do indies with separate win-cons counted as separate alignments? or same?

Can you answer this please?

-/-/-/-

I dont find this 3rd party vs 3rd party talk to be an effective use of speculation. Hopefully if my assumptions are correct then we can just move things along.

In most cases, win con determines my understanding of alignment.

well i guess techincally this means that nothings stopping baker from putting muti-3rd parties in the band if they have differnt win-cons. Mmm disappointing.

I still stand by my thoughts that its not the case in this game. Since i know im town, and if the other band member were a pro-town indie they would've claimed so we could confidently flip rude who is at best a anti-town indie from thier pov.

[TiphaineDeath]

@A50 if they are both scum, and we believe all the things they have said, they have a hard-cleared scum player and can ride to victory. It's gutsy, but it would be a really powerful gambit actually.

[NoPowerOverMe]

People forget this is a bastard game obviously. I think it's wrong to make setup spec assumptions as fact.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

how is he hardcleared lol