There's also this:In post 190, Ydrasse wrote:as for reads i have a faint scumread on gypyx for that one post, and something about ari also gave me one but it’s more a vague wrinkling of the nose for no real reason
but I couldn't tell whether this was serious/jokeyIn post 220, Tsunami Slayer wrote:gyp is confscum*
Complaining that my reads haven't dramatically changed over like 5 pages does sound pretty much exactly like what a scumbutt being scumread would scumplain aboutIn post 297, The Pelican Brief wrote:It irks me that HUB has the same reads in 87 as he does in 289 despite his presence.
I've been around on the site since 05, so I've witnessed both of your entrances and respective flourishing as players on the site. You of course are widely known for being the instigator of theIn post 297, The Pelican Brief wrote:How experienced would you say you are with Titus and I as players in mafia?
True, insert counterpoint I'm too lazy to outline right now.In post 302, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:Complaining that my reads haven't dramatically changed over like 5 pages does sound pretty much exactly like what a scumbutt being scumread would scumplain aboutIn post 297, The Pelican Brief wrote:It irks me that HUB has the same reads in 87 as he does in 289 despite his presence.
I hope you're having a very merry unbirthday taly!
I know, theIn post 303, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote:Taking these slowly because I'm posting in between Among Us rounds
I've been around on the site since 05, so I've witnessed both of your entrances and respective flourishing as players on the site. You of course are widely known for being the instigator of theIn post 297, The Pelican Brief wrote:How experienced would you say you are with Titus and I as players in mafia?Pelican Plaguein 2019, hundreds died, but
Titus was the first mafiascum player to step foot on the moon. Utmost respect for her.
So, very experienced with you both, but more experienced with Titus. I've never seen you roll scum actually.
I feel a bit more confident in my alt read and alignment read on you.
does that work on this forumIn post 294, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote:@Ircher
I get bad vibes from that slot. I don't get why she thinks all of the ascetic claims are town in 251 setup-spec-wiseIn post 297, The Pelican Brief wrote:I thought Sam would respond more to the counterwagon on her when the one she placed on BEF fell apart, I'm leaning on Titus' gut with this slot.
nope! but I still want Ircher to notice meIn post 305, samantha97 wrote:does that work on this forum
re:votes: 1 mafia 1 inquisitive/fisher 1 sheep 1 randomIn post 306, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote:@samantha: whatdya think, thoughts on counterwagon/votes on you? and why ascetic claims all town
lolwat?In post 297, The Pelican Brief wrote:I thought Sam would respond more to the counterwagon on her when theone she placed on BEF fell apart, I'm leaning on Titus' gut with this slot.
I don't doubt that they're true either, but why can't 1 be a true mafia ascetic claim?In post 309, samantha97 wrote:I think the claims are town just because a) what they claimed fits with the theme, and b) they did it pretty quickly without any pressure to do so. Like I said, it doesn't really matter if they are town or not right now. Whether you genuinely wanted to lynch them, or wanted to pressure them with votes to roleclaim, the end result is still you voting nonsensically against our day 1 interests.
Ydrasse will be a soul read. TGP will be a regular read. Endless Terror will be a heavy meta read.
they could all be mafia claims, I just don't think any areIn post 312, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote: I don't doubt that they're true either, but why can't 1 be a true mafia ascetic claim?
Samantha and I voted BEF for doing nothing/making excuses for not engaging in the thread. Everyone else decided to counterwagon Samantha. That covers like the last 5 pages.In post 315, Tsunami Slayer wrote:Hello! It's been a while. Someone summarize the last like ten pages that way I can just skim it.
-Nornornornor
Tbh a negative utility massclaim might be advisable (basically just saying whether you are or are not a miller, ascetic, PGO, etc.)In post 155, Aristophanes wrote:For the record, we are NOT massclaiming D1.In post 154, samantha97 wrote:aw I feel bad if that prompted him to do that cause it was rhetorical
unless we're doing a roundabout massclaim, what is the purpose of voting them instead of literally anyone else
VOTE: BrightEyedFish
Oh, I was asked about my thoughts on claims. One sec I'll take a look at them.
My own Ydrasse experience tells me TGP is probably on the right track but maybe my recall is failing meIn post 174, Endless Terror wrote:im telling you, you cant read someone with meta if you've only seen one alignmentIn post 164, TheGoldenParadox wrote:i haven't played with town ydrasse, so take this with an obvious grain of salt, but her opening posts in that game felt more to me like fluff posting with an attempt to appear town, but her posts were game related (see 121 in that game), where she's literally like "okay, real content" whereas her posts in this game are less serious. feels more like town to me here
i've skimmed the game pretty lightly. insane we're already at page 7. i'll try to catch up more tomorrow if we're not at three times that number by then.
-S
Yeah I also feel this, TPB’s claim definitely feels like a town one, but I don’t feel 100% okay diving into the nitty gritty of why.In post 175, Endless Terror wrote:the vague claim is slight town!AI since scum!TPB has no need to claim a vague neg utility role as vague roles don't give cred and it limits future fakeclaiming choices
My recollection is town!Ydrasse is fine being fluffy but Imight need to check myself on that (or Bell can remind me, since my point of reference is the Forest Fire game where I’m remembering Ydrasse as town-aligned in rn)In post 193, Endless Terror wrote:i kind of think these recent posts by ydra are pretty good but at the same time i have an impression of town!ydrasse not fluffing in rvs somehow.
-S
honestly I’m somewhat with Ari about how GPX’s claim feels, the flavor addition feels a bit excessive + I don’t think Boon likes to have flavored roles if they do nothing different? Although, if ET can corroborate that they also are a flavored ascetic I’ll leave it alone as NAI.In post 198, Endless Terror wrote:this is some strange shade to be throwing. claiming ascetic day 1 is correct even if its boring, but i also dunno why the flavor was included. pingIn post 103, Aristophanes wrote:Claiming ascetic D1 is boring and I'm not sure why the flavour was included tbh
-tay
I was anticipating this. I’ll leave it to the two claims to figure out their status as conftown or not, beyond that I think the claims are NAI at worst.In post 209, Endless Terror wrote:shelly and i have been debating how we should treat claiming. we have decided to claim a bit more: we are also a parallel universe. there is one small portion of the role that gyp left out. if gyp is town that should confirm us as town too, we think. initially i wanted to locktown gyp for having our role, but theres nothing saying that scum cant have an ascetic. and it seems a little strange that there would be two townies with the same exact named role.
-tay
I'm gonna need you to let off on my buddy Samantha. Otherwise, you are doing great!In post 308, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote:Am I doing good, Ircher? I only play to seek your approval.
Not that I can find off unfortunately, but I still think it is worth pushing there. I don't really understand the counterwagon.