Xenoblade 2 Mafia: Game Over

[ManWithNoName]

Ok? Sorta dodging my point that it's weird that you think catching scum me is as simple as me not giving reads(my scum game is bad but not to that extent).
Also, what reads do you even have this game? You talked about Cakez looking like he was more interested in finding out why he was scum rather than scumhunting. I don't find that to be too scummy and it seems like a natural town reaction.

BM, Reagan, Gamma and Cabd are all probably town.

Cabd is a solid town read who is good at the game and is pushing Cakez, so that combined with his issues is enough to vote him.

I am on record of trying to town hunt more than scum hunt. And I don't see why, as a town member, I would care whether someone is scum reading me or not, I'm not going on my own wagon and if people want to remove me that's their problem after I'm gone, really.

I don't need to be advertising who I'm scumreading and give a road map to scum of who to kill. That's why reads lists are stupid.

Even though I respect Cabd, I called out that reads list as stupid before.

[ManWithNoName]

Will catch up later maybe (Nachomamma8/zMuffinMan)

Oh!

[Cobra Kai]

I have a tentative townread on the catch-up hydra.

[Cabd]

Cake... reads of these four slots in particular, humor me....


Midwaybears
Nachomuffin (Catch up)
Fermis Flames
Firebringer

Other people are welcome to opine on this list plus cakes.

[ManWithNoName]

I'm just shocked no one has commented on the Catch-up's revelation of a true injustice.

YOU CAN'T PUT BUSY IN A USERNAME? WHAT?

Rise up! When are these usernames gonna RISE UP?

[Cobra Kai]

I agree about the hot hydra being town (I like Tammy trying to navigate the setup through Nacho based off an old setup, I don’t think that’s where her mind would go as scum).

I have no opinion on Firebringer.

I can’t talk about bear for ~reasons~.

[midwaybear]

He also does little as scum
When he does do stuff though, I think him actually showing the level of engagement he is is actually a town tell

good to know, that takes away some of my reservation there

Not sure why both of you seem to be overlooking that Dunnstral can just be engaged scum?

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 1.7

[8] SirCakez (Cabd, Fermis Flames, ManWithNoName, MariaR, Bell, Battle Mage, Dunnstral, Gamma Emerald)
[3] Gamma Emerald (Brian Skies, Lady Lambdadelta, noraa)
[2] Battle Mage (SirCakez, beeboy)
[1] beeboy (l4pe)
[1] Brian Skies (unwnd)
[1] Cobra Kai (REAGAN BUSH 84)
[1] unwund (Flavor Leaf)
[1] Lady Lambdadelta (Firebringer)

[4] Not Voting (Cobra Kai, Guillotina, Will catch up later maybe, midwaybear)

With 22 alive, it is 12 to eliminate.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2020-11-30 13:00:00)

[unwnd]

Cake... reads of these four slots in particular, humor me....


Midwaybears
Nachomuffin (Catch up)
Fermis Flames
Firebringer

Townie (I've been convinced)
Null lean town
Lean town
Scummy

[Cabd]

What if I told you there's exactly one scum in that list of five?

[Cobra Kai]

Why?

[ManWithNoName]

What if I told you there's exactly one scum in that list of five?

I'd say there's only four people on the list.

[Cabd]

What if I told you there's exactly one scum in that list of five?

I'd say there's only four people on the list.

Those four plus cakes. Your shitpost coupon only lasts until the 24 hour after game launch mark.

[unwnd]

What if I told you there's exactly one scum in that list of five?

I'd probably agree

[SirCakez]

But what's the scum motivation for that
Just ignore it

There doesn't always have to be a clear cut scum motivation for scum to do things.

MWNN, first of all, I did give reads earlier in that newbie. Second of all, I find it hard to believe that you think me not giving reads as scum is ever a strategy that I would keep.

well yeah ofc
but why does it make more sense for it to be scum than town here?

[REAGAN BUSH 84]

oh i found the post

l4pe is scum btw

Hottake!

What don’t you like about them?

lot of neutral commentary filler type posts when i went bck over the iso and i didn't like the stuff about asking for people to sort, 1288 is pretty empty. i may wake up in the morning and hate this read though who knows

i mean fair enough i havent played a game of mafia seriously in a literal year

so

im not used to actually trying as either alignment

should this make me town? nah

im just laying out what you should expect, and that is overall lots of shitposting

maybe i will put in a notable amount of effort later

interesting

[ManWithNoName]

Fair warning, you'll be gravely disappointed with hour 25, then.

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah, but it's not hard to imagine scum!Gamma similarly getting irked and then blowing up at BM.

But what's the scum motivation for that
Just ignore it

If it was a barrier to getting a foothold in the game yeah it would be something I might push as scum. That's what I did in MBoS 10

[SirCakez]

MWNN why do you actually SR me other than sheeping Cabd?

[SirCakez]

Yeah, but it's not hard to imagine scum!Gamma similarly getting irked and then blowing up at BM.

But what's the scum motivation for that
Just ignore it

If it was a barrier to getting a foothold in the game yeah it would be something I might push as scum. That's what I did in MBoS 10

I think this is a moot point now

[SirCakez]

Cake... reads of these four slots in particular, humor me....


Midwaybears
Nachomuffin (Catch up)
Fermis Flames
Firebringer

I mean I don't understand why you're asking me this since you seem hell bent on ending me today

[SirCakez]

I wouldn't elim any of them today as it stands
Midway is mildly scummy because he won't take a stance on my wagon he just keeps posturing around it
Fire I can't ever read correctly early game
The other two are fine

[Gamma Emerald]

He also does little as scum
When he does do stuff though, I think him actually showing the level of engagement he is is actually a town tell

good to know, that takes away some of my reservation there

Not sure why both of you seem to be overlooking that Dunnstral can just be engaged scum?

it's not that he's unegaged as scum
his scum play just has the slick and easy vibe where it doesn't feel like he's really analyzing to his full capacity (I might be wrong, it's been a while since I've really tried to show my Dunn reading chops)

[REAGAN BUSH 84]

i get the impression flavor leaf isn't easy to sort so i don't know how you're expecting to do it on day 1

town read, and like...exactly that, that mindset they're trying to push, or paranoia around me they're trying to create. why do they have paranoia? are they an alt? i don't know who they are.

This is a discredit attempt. Unwnd is scum. Bet.[

/quote]

BTW this is why his ego is dangerous

I'm just an avid game reader and I have second-hand experience u could say

"dangerous ego" would imply he's town here, though, no?

[ManWithNoName]

MWNN why do you actually SR me other than sheeping Cabd?

I hate repeating myself, but it's this weird thing with you being obsessed with the scum reads on you.

Also, Masons and Monks, you just did this thing where you said scum response without reasoning, and I checked it out last night because you did a few posts like that, here.