BooneyToonz XIV: A Little Boonie Told Me [END]

[Endless Terror]

Lol do you even understand what happened

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

With Vax flipping goon, I'm say scum is full of stacked PRs remaining.

agreed

if there's a full town commuter, they either have strongman or informed or some other meaningful counter-play

Boon got too much shit for the game where there were two town bulletproofs for him to design another game with scum having insufficient counterplay

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

Lol do you even understand what happened

I don't think I need to, I'm town IC therefore if you fade me you're gamethrowing!

Aren't IC claims fun and interesting?

[Ydrasse]

shellyhead: what makes you so certain that gypyx’s claim is town? just the flavor, yeah?

[Endless Terror]

also those flips prove me/gypyx IC. you all should treat us as ICs, scum!

commuter

doesn't have motivation to hardclaim D1 as well.

this is where I fucking perspective slipped.

also those flips prove me/gypyx IC. you all should treat us as ICs, scum!commuter doesn't have motivation to hardclaim D1 as well.
-shelly

Oh uh ok you wanna out that? Well i'll

confirm

just to make sure everyone is aware

here is where gypyx responded to it.

-shelly.

[Endless Terror]

shellyhead: what makes you so certain that gypyx’s claim is town? just the flavor, yeah?

yes
and do you think scum ascetic informed: there is a commuter makes that much sense
-shelly

[Ydrasse]

i could be misunderstanding here but the crux of the issue is that there’s no reason either of you are cleared from roles. arguing that point right now doesn’t help anything.

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

I absolutely think scum being informed town have reflavored roles in a boon game makes sense since there was no setup information to that effect and if boon did NOT inform them of that then he would be putting them at an informational disadvantage. From a design perspective boon has a strong incentive to inform scum of reflavored town roles

[Endless Terror]

i could be misunderstanding here but the crux of the issue is that there’s no reason either of you are cleared from roles. arguing that point right now doesn’t help anything.

i don't care if im cleared or what
I care that HUB is misunderstanding everything and its making me impossible to sort him
-shelly

[Ydrasse]

...yes? why couldn’t there be informed somewhere in the scumteam, or just a straight up scum commuter?

[Ydrasse]

to be frank you both clogged up the past page or so with a fight that i don’t understand why it happened

[Ydrasse]

what do you make of the vote from hub onto you?

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

To that effect I think scum either being factionally informed or individually role-informed of town flavor is probably 75% plus, 100% if scum have reflavored roles as well that would allow them to infer that all power roles are reflavored (which I don't think they are?)

[Endless Terror]

the IC thing was also a gimmick to bait the nightkill earlier

now I seriously have to go

p-edit why are there so many wtf

[Ydrasse]

ircher’s role wasnt flavored

[Ydrasse]

also hub, what do you make of et’s vote?

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

I care that HUB is misunderstanding everything and its making me impossible to sort him

I'm misunderstanding very little, observing that you created a needless mechanical discussion that clogged the thread and pissed me off, and telling you to stop playing bad if you are town. If you are unfamiliar with boon game conventions why are you making so many assumptions about what scum flavor would be? It's not helpful

pedit:

ET's omgus could easily be town here, I'm having a hard time discerning whether they actually think scum informed is so implausible that they reached all these random AF conclusions. I can see scum arguing a scum role is implausible if they know it's real but I wouldn't say it's obviously coming from scum.

My reasons for voting them are much weaker now that I know they're just reflavored and not actually variant tho

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

VOTE: Aristophanes

Actually more I think of it, more likely this feels like town that was butthurt their stupid reasons for thinking they were IC were called out rather than an actual scum reaction, this is probably just obnoxious town

I did get a gutping from taylor as scum separately day 1 but that's not strong enough to vote over Ari atm and my feelings on ET overall are still pretty muddled

[Ydrasse]

that whole fight felt overblown to me tbh but that bit about nora + calling out the commuter is something, idk if she really is that bad and would be informed or not and just made a good guess.

[Ydrasse]

shelly was being a bit... obtuse (no offense) fmpov about it all and missing the point of why it wasn’t clearing her at all though which worries me slightly because like, from the outside this should’ve been such a nonissue and it became one for ???? some reason

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

What do you think about them arguing they should have been a top townread on day 1 before they did anything interesting?

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

interesting. ive sorted all three of your nulls, but dont even know who the fuck nico is. tgp is pretty null to me, as is ari. why are ydrasse and BEF above null? why isnt this hydra your top townread? we've declared ourselves to be an IC.

They've been on this IC line since day 1, it didn't just start now

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

Slot that has done nothing townie, makes a bunch of assumptions about scum flavor, and claims to be IC off bullshit mech is pretty high on my list of "slots I am okay seeing faded" regardless of what they end up flipping, but it's hard to say whether it's stupid enough that it is too stupid to come from town

[Ydrasse]

i think them declaring themselves as an ic on that post is more of a tongue in cheek sort of thing/just their personality (whichever head it was, i could imagine them both posting it)

[Ydrasse]

the ircher flip doesn’t say much about them imo but pelican was townreading them + had them in a townblock so it doesn’t seem likely they’d want to kill pelican?