Silent Star 3: Royalty

[Hectic]

VC on this page.

if you're arguing that Dunn is a partner of Golden then why are you flipping Dunn first? i'm pretty sure that's what he's getting at and that's largely what is losing me here

I am just completely lost at how no one interpreted it that way which leads me to believe im missing something but i can't delve rn

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

If dunn is town and scumreads TGP, that seems like a pretty reasonable thing to want

he is responding to tgp-dunn red/red theory

if tgp flips red i will still come for him tomm, he needs a tgp green flip to deflect me.

[Flea The Magician]

I'm still lost about what was TMI （◞‸◟）

[Infinity 324]

Tinfoil: pooky is scum with TGP and wanted to tie TGP to a townie but now realizes they can elim dunn first instead. Hmm.

UNVOTE:

PEdit: I mean yeah, but dunn said he was gonna do some more solving in the second half.

@Flea TMI= too much information, when you say something you could only know if you are scum.

[Gloria Cleary]

if you're arguing that Dunn is a partner of Golden then why are you flipping Dunn first? i'm pretty sure that's what he's getting at and that's largely what is losing me here

I am just completely lost at how no one interpreted it that way which leads me to believe im missing something but i can't delve rn

You don’t think it logical to prefer to flip the one you find scummier first, why?

[Gloria Cleary]

I'm still lost about what was TMI （◞‸◟）

Too much information. The implication is Dunn could possibly be informed.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Tinfoil: pooky is scum with TGP and wanted to tie TGP to a townie but now realizes they can elim dunn first instead. Hmm.

UNVOTE:

PEdit: I mean yeah, but dunn said he was gonna do some more solving in the second half.

@Flea TMI= too much information, when you say something you could only know if you are scum.

so wrong

i never bus

[Gloria Cleary]

Tinfoil: pooky is scum with TGP and wanted to tie TGP to a townie but now realizes they can elim dunn first instead. Hmm.

UNVOTE:

PEdit: I mean yeah, but dunn said he was gonna do some more solving in the second half.

@Flea TMI= too much information, when you say something you could only know if you are scum.

So you think we should flip TGP first then? I’m not opposed, I just really hated Dunn’s recent posts.

[Gloria Cleary]

Tinfoil: pooky is scum with TGP and wanted to tie TGP to a townie but now realizes they can elim dunn first instead. Hmm.

UNVOTE:

PEdit: I mean yeah, but dunn said he was gonna do some more solving in the second half.

@Flea TMI= too much information, when you say something you could only know if you are scum.

so wrong

i never bus

Scum sometimes have to bus in order to play to their wincon but I don’t read your progression on either slot as distancing, so I don’t understand what Infinity is seeing?

[Morning Tweet]

if you're arguing that Dunn is a partner of Golden then why are you flipping Dunn first? i'm pretty sure that's what he's getting at and that's largely what is losing me here

I am just completely lost at how no one interpreted it that way which leads me to believe im missing something but i can't delve rn

You don’t think it logical to prefer to flip the one you find scummier first, why?

that was more referring to Pooky and whoever else is arguing that Golden and Dunn are together, which i thought you were

As for you specifically, your point against Dunn seems to be his read progression on Pooky. you keep referencing 1461 but i'm totally missing where he townreads Pooky there

I think Dunn might still be scum outside of this but i fail to see what you're seeing (aside from calling Isis sweaty, which hurts my feelings vicariously). But like so many people are seeing it when im not so im worried im just not seeing right

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Tweetie are we really going to let this scoundrel get away with calling your bride-to-be sweaty?

[Infinity 324]

Tinfoil: pooky is scum with TGP and wanted to tie TGP to a townie but now realizes they can elim dunn first instead. Hmm.

UNVOTE:

PEdit: I mean yeah, but dunn said he was gonna do some more solving in the second half.

@Flea TMI= too much information, when you say something you could only know if you are scum.

So you think we should flip TGP first then? I’m not opposed, I just really hated Dunn’s recent posts.

I’m thinking about it. I still feel like TGP is much townier on play, but both their counterwagons got quite a bit more traction that I expected. Given that the reasons for scumreading dunn here really felt like stretches, I’m officially weirded out. Hopkirk dropping the dunn vote and dipping out bothers me as well.

PEdit: MT I totally agree with you

[Flea The Magician]

I'm still lost about what was TMI （◞‸◟）

Too much information. The implication is Dunn could possibly be informed.

Hey I know what TMI is I don't see where Dunn is showing he's informed though? Like if he is that means I've really gotta go through the ISO with a fine tooth comb

[Gloria Cleary]

if you're arguing that Dunn is a partner of Golden then why are you flipping Dunn first? i'm pretty sure that's what he's getting at and that's largely what is losing me here

I am just completely lost at how no one interpreted it that way which leads me to believe im missing something but i can't delve rn

You don’t think it logical to prefer to flip the one you find scummier first, why?

that was more referring to Pooky and whoever else is arguing that Golden and Dunn are together, which i thought you were

As for you specifically, your point against Dunn seems to be his read progression on Pooky. you keep referencing 1461 but i'm totally missing where he townreads Pooky there

I think Dunn might still be scum outside of this but i fail to see what you're seeing (aside from calling Isis sweaty, which hurts my feelings vicariously). But like so many people are seeing it when im not so im worried im just not seeing right

Why can’t you think two players could possibly be linked and prefer to yeet the one you find scummier?

Because it read to me like he just suddenly dropped his suspicions on Pooky to push TGP and I don’t think there’s any reason to rule out survivalism as a reason.

[Flea The Magician]

It's almost like there's no Millenials on the internet....

Code: Select all

HAI 1.2
    VISIBLE "Hello, World!"
KTHXBYE

That is all

[Gloria Cleary]

I'm still lost about what was TMI （◞‸◟）

Too much information. The implication is Dunn could possibly be informed.

Hey I know what TMI is I don't see where Dunn is showing he's informed though? Like if he is that means I've really gotta go through the ISO with a fine tooth comb

I just found it weird that he was so suspicious of Pooky and suddenly dropped it. That’s the entire basis for my reasoning.

[Flea The Magician]

I was pulling that kinda thing in DC though if you remember. My reads were all over the place.

[Flea The Magician]

Right, I can't put this off until tomorrow. Meds have fogged me a little but lets do this.

Spoiler: duuuun duun DUUUUUUUUUUNNNNN! - cheesy song warning! lol

wow 38 posts... OK then. Oh wait.. taylor... 46... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Taylors entry is... taylor. "first!" weird vote, weird comment. votecount fix, random commentary of being weird, laughing at reads. Textbook taylor, nothing AI about this.

I'd expect scum Taylor to be very mean and town Taylor to just be mean, so being very mean makes her slightly scummier. Although maybe she's just having a mean day.

i love you hopkirk, im just cuter than you.

*reaches beyond the game to swat*

On to Dunn. Where the meat of this ISO shall be!

MT! Why are you and Infinity voting for my slot

I've defended this before, I like this entry. Jumping straight in, challenging the votes on the slot.

also jessie's energy so far reminds me of menagerie + her attempts to communicate/get things done despite the animal noise thing we had to deal with, it's not the same given that wasn't setup spec but... the feeling around it is similar

p-edit: for a tiny tiny bit yes

I also kind of like Jessie's posts.

Ydrasse how about you and Jessie pave the way to greatness with your votes?

I think Gloria called this out for being fence-sitty?
This is his 3rd post in the game and less than an hour after replacing in. He's trying to shove a couple slots who are quite absent from voting, I see nothing bad with this. Less then an hour in, I'm not going to expect much in the way of reads, but it seems he's taken the time to check the vote count provided by Jessie in #475. Closer look at that post shows Ydrasse and Jessie haven't voted or been voted so he's studied it to get an idea of the flow in the game at least at this point.
Add in he likes Jessies posts the implication is both Jessie and Ydrasse are town leans.

How the nuts am I able to work this out when I STILL can't work out Jessies reads o.o I ISO'd jessie in the morning when I was coffee fueled, and I'm doing this one late at night with brainfog... Maybe faer born with it, maybe its ADHD. I'm also yawning like every 30 seconds. what the hell brain o.o....

might go back through jessie tomorrow night when I'm shattered lol

Maybe I’m seeing the same things hopkirk is? I also think taylor is relatively likely to have engaged with me on game-relevant things as town

The aggressive anti-cute stuff felt evasive to some extent. I agree if that's what you mean.

I don't want to scumread Jessie

it's okay not to, i'm town.

Ew

uh oh

We're in trouble! someones come along and burst mah bubbble yeah-eh uh oh!

also jessie's energy so far reminds me of menagerie + her attempts to communicate/get things done despite the animal noise thing we had to deal with, it's not the same given that wasn't setup spec but... the feeling around it is similar

p-edit: for a tiny tiny bit yes

I also kind of like Jessie's posts.

Ydrasse how about you and Jessie pave the way to greatness with your votes?

Jessie -- yes. what is it that you like about Ydrasse?

Woah woah woah slow down there, I never said I liked Ydrasse, I'm just asking her to lead the way as my senior in this game since I noticed she isn't voting anybody

Thats legit, the implication is there though and a couple people have seemed to think it.

Thats probably how I worked out the read. Other people have said it and it came to mind. Whew. Still, what the nuts brain!

Double dippy hectic... silent stat 1... wut. idgi.

I fee like I should be townreading Gloria by now and I'm not. The Skitter30/Gloria interactions tasted a bit weird.

My town atm is (Isis/Pooky/Ydrasse/Infinity) with a maybe on MT. Everyone else I need more on than I've got.

This is the kind of post we come back to later if you flip scum

hm?

That is what it reminds me of When you list a bunch of town which are generally consensus reads, say you should be townreading someone but don't act on that, two people's interactions are weird etc.

Also that game

was

silent star

(I'm saying you're suspicious)

*swats*

I like #521. Kinda. I think the skitter suspicion is probably legit from what people have said. scummies be forever townlean. Not sure why but I'm sure I've seen this a few times around.

i think the entire concept of a d1 townbloc is flawed, although the relative naturalness of it makes me question it far less. gypyx and gloria look town, as do ydrasse and infinity. i'm really going back and forth on pooky, but settling in on a slight townlean on them. hopkirk is still town, and i'm much less confident in isis, so VOTE: dunnstral this slot has been fairly bad from the beginning and has not gotten better.

I don't think TGP is town and this post deserves pressure

I agree with this. and I picked the post in question apart elsewhere.

VOTE: dunstal

go away sweaty

So bold, so brave.... or stupid... not sure which.

I'm town though, and everyone hopping off of tgp here looks quite bad?

We have two elims today.

I'm so torn over this post. It's a legitimate concern on one hand, but there's something kinda off about it...

sounds like you know what TGP will flip

I have my reasons for voting him, they're in my iso

TLDR TGP has been making a terrible push on Dunn based on NAI tells and some terrible posting to try and make the votes look legitimate.

his reaction right now is terrible

What is a towny reaction then?

Reaction seems indifferent to me, but these are out of context. The bits I'm seeing here look like Pooks has just kinda latched on and is doing the pooky thing of prodding and poking.

While trying to make me look bad and dodging explanations

I think he’s town. I’m just trying to understand what he’s seeing. Do you have any other reads? I need a lot more info to sort you.

Like I said I've been half-following, I do remember that I found Flea town as well

HEY LOOK MA IT'S ME! (✪‿✪)

wait... GLORIA AM I BEING POCKETED AGAIN?

what are you implying with this post?

Pooky is saying I'm scum with you. The time to explore that should be after we elim you

OK apparently this is TMI... I don't get it...

[quote="In post 1512I just found it weird that he was so suspicious of Pooky and suddenly dropped it. That’s the entire basis for my reasoning.

I don't think the suspicion has been dropped looking at it. It just looks like TGP is the higher priority than pooky at the moment?

POOKY I FOUND A SHRUGGIE BEAR! ¯\_ȌᴥȌ_/¯

I'm kinda leaning town here if I'm honest... What are people seeing that I'm not? :/

[Flea The Magician]

I think the skitter suspicion is probably legit from what people have said. scummies be forever townlean. Not sure why but I'm sure I've seen this a few times around.

Am conflict. send halp.

[Flea The Magician]

why do I always break the tags?

like seriously... it's almost every significant post of mine I've broken in some form

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

POOKY I FOUND A SHRUGGIE BEAR! ¯\_ȌᴥȌ_/¯

tooo kawaiiiii (〃＾▽＾〃)

[Gypyx]

Ok so, i managed to fit in some time to read tgp's case without falling asleep

I think the timing is a bit late so maybe this is scum white knighting, but i highly doubt it tbh

And the content on it's own is also pretty good, like, the read makes sense

I see skitter is the other top wagon, why that?

[Hectic]

¶

Votecount 1.0.15

[4] TheGoldenParadox:

skitter30, Dunnstral, Ydrasse, Flea The Magician

[4] Dunnstral:

Isis, PookyTheMagicalBear, Hopkirk, TheGoldenParadox

[1] Gloria Cleary:

Gypyx

[4] Not Voting:

team rocket queen, Morning Tweet, Gloria Cleary, Infinity 324

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to launch. If there is no majority by the deadline, plurality will decide.

The deadline is in (expired on 2020-11-29 09:11:15).

Joint Mod ISO

[Gypyx]

Uh i meant duunstral obviously

[Infinity 324]

Honestly it was mostly PoE for me. But I got weirded out by everyone piling onto dunn for what I thought were weak reasons. Can you read the last couple pages and lmk what you think about people's dunn votes?