Silent Star 3: Royalty

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think it's weird that Dunn would respond to my conspiracy theory argument that he/tgp are red/red scum theater with "ok flip TGP first" if he thought TGP was red.

because TGP flipping red doesn't exactly help him rebutt that argument,

the way "flip TGP first" would make sense as a response to me is if Red!Dunn was annoyed at being caught for wrong reasons and wanted to prove red/red scumtheater theory is stupid by flipping TGP!Green.

[Infinity 324]

It doesn’t help him disprove that theory, but it does help him flip scum, which is a town thing to want.

[Infinity 324]

VOTE: pooky I’ll talk about this a bit later, but I saw some scum!pooky aggression with their push on dunn before the elim. I also am not sure why they weren’t more concerned about a TGP elim given the above theory since it implies that TGP is town.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

oooooookkkk

[Flea The Magician]

VOTE: pooky I’ll talk about this a bit later, but I saw some scum!pooky aggression with their push on dunn before the elim. I also am not sure why they weren’t more concerned about a TGP elim given the above theory since it implies that TGP is town.

oooo I look forward to this :3

[Infinity 324]

VOTE: tgp ok

Why did you vote a slot you hard, hard townread? I'll try to remember to delete this if it gets answered later in my catchup.
No, it's pretty mysterious. Why? Do you have skitter as locktown? It's still hard to follow with how strong you represented the TGP townread.
This bugs me no matter what TGP flips here

I never expected the dunn wagon to go through. The dunn vote was mostly to see how much resistance it got. If it got a couple votes, then people moved to hammer TGP, that would make dunn more likely to be scum. But the fact that a bunch of people all got onto dunn, including hopkirk who hasn't been around, and pooky who started to remind me of their scumgame, it weirded me the hell out and I start to doubt myself. The most likely scenario in my head was still that both wagons were town, but I definitely had a had time seeing scum!dunn and town!tgp. TGP was also a super high reward wagon if it flipped scum, since that would imply skitter!town and dunn!town and potentially pooky!scum.

[Infinity 324]

Spoiler: pooky quotes

I'm town though, and everyone hopping off of tgp here looks quite bad?

We have two elims today.

artificial reaction

sounds like you know what TGP will flip

sounds like you know what TGP will flip

I have my reasons for voting him, they're in my iso

Lol why are you changing topic buddy?

When you use this argument, you invalidate your previous one

as long as you flip red i could care less which argument was right

mb tgp is green and dunn is caught for the wrong reasons scum

his reaction right now is terrible

and he called isis sweaty

lets just send him packing

I didn't actually have too much else to say about pooky. But here were the places where I think they were oddly aggressive and reminded me of scum!them. I just want pooky to explain their thought process behind the tgp/dunn thing, where they started to think TGP might be town, and what a red flip from TGP would imply.

[Morning Tweet]

@Hectic V/LA until Wednesday please

i really need to prioritize a bunch of other things right now (ノ﹏ヽ) im very sorry

[Gloria Cleary]

He isn’t solvey and sorting players like he usually does as town

sorry is this about dunn or hopkirk? cuz i thought dunn at first and i would in no way agree with this assessment of dunn at all ^

I don’t know why, every towngame I ‘ve read of his, he has done more than he is here. He’s only given one townread so far: Flea and two maybe three scumreads: TGP, and now Pooky. And even that post he made about launching players due to their post count. he can’t bother to make actual reads or what?

At any rate Isis is a terrible vote. I strongly tr her pre-flip and it’s actually even stronger post-flip.

[Infinity 324]

I actually think I’ve seen dunn do more in scumganes than town games generally. I don’t think lurking is scummy at all for him.

[Gloria Cleary]

People think Dunn is townier than Pooky.

[Gloria Cleary]

I actually think I’ve seen dunn do more in scumganes than town games generally. I don’t think lurking is scummy at all for him.

Who said I sr him for lurking, because I’m dam sure I never said anything of the kind.

[Infinity 324]

You SR him for not doing enough. Close enough.

[Gloria Cleary]

You SR him for not doing enough. Close enough.

No but hey thanks for telling me what I’m NOT thinking. It’s WHAT he’s doing when he’s posting that I’m scumreading him for.

[Infinity 324]

I thought you implied it in 1633 but fair enough.

[Gloria Cleary]

I thought you implied it in 1633 but fair enough.

Maybe I’m just not doing a terrific job of articulating it well. It’s the content of his posts I dislike. He really isn’t saying much of anything of substance plus his tone seems kind of off. Town!Dunn may lurk and not post a lot that is true but when he does it’s useful content and solvey, no matter how much or how little. It’s not the number of posts, it’s what he’s saying in them.

[Infinity 324]

Hmm ok. Can you quote some examples of not-solvy posts?

I felt some earnestness from his response to pooky’s push, and I have a hard time believing the dunn wagons forms as fast as it did if he’s scum and TGP is town.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Hmm ok. Can you quote some examples of not-solvy posts?

I felt some earnestness from his response to pooky’s push, and I have a hard time believing the dunn wagons forms as fast as it did if he’s scum and TGP is town.

why would a CW even form if he's same alignment as tgp

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I have a hard time believing the dunn wagons forms as fast as it did if he’s scum and TGP is town.

what does this even mean?

[Infinity 324]

It’s more that scum would almost never vote dunn in that situation, and statistically there’s very likely at least one scum on that wagon (of 5 at its height, I believe)

[Infinity 324]

I just want pooky to explain their thought process behind the tgp/dunn thing, where they started to think TGP might be town, and what a red flip from TGP would imply.

[Gloria Cleary]

It’s more that scum would almost never vote dunn in that situation, and statistically there’s very likely at least one scum on that wagon (of 5 at its height, I believe)

Statistically, scum is far more likely to be on TOWN!TGP wagon, since there was heavy resistance to Dunn. Why would scum try to derail a wagon on TGP? That makes absolutely no sense.

[Dunnstral]

there was heavy resistance to Dunn.

There really wasn't

I hopped up to e-2 instantly and then some people switched

[Dunnstral]

And the resistance was in fact to tgp

[Infinity 324]

It’s more that scum would almost never vote dunn in that situation, and statistically there’s very likely at least one scum on that wagon (of 5 at its height, I believe)

Statistically, scum is far more likely to be on TOWN!TGP wagon, since there was heavy resistance to Dunn. Why would scum try to derail a wagon on TGP? That makes absolutely no sense.

The probability of a given set of 4 people currently alive having at least 1 scum (assuming 3 scum total) is about 75%. If dunn is scum, scum are just as likely to vote dunn or TGP since it doesn’t matter to them who gets limmed. If dunn is scum, scum would almost never vote dunn. Since 4 people excluding myself voted dunn, that group is likely to have at least 1 scum, so dunn is likely town.

Also yeah, there was almost no resistance to dunn.