Silent Star 3: Royalty

[Flea The Magician]

Pooky were you the D1?

yup

so contractually Hectic is not allowed to make me play red again, there is an unspoken site rule about making someone play red twice in a row.

Pooky conftown. (◕ᴥ◕)

[team rocket queen]

I didn't see that bit you quoted, so then I would assume that vanilla in terms of power means there's no outward abilities, such as cops or docs but potentially linked abilities or something that trades something for something else. for example the bodyguard role which dies when the target is killed.

I don't feel there's any way for a mechanical guilty to happen at all having seen that.

i think it means that there is no player given the role 'cop' but there is still plenty of ways for there to be a mechanical guilty. there were mechanical innocents in that game i really don't see how you are ruling out the possibility of mechanical guilties here.

[Hopkirk]

What's a quick rundown of your reads list? We know your townlist, but little else.

town: gypyx, infinity, hopkirk
townlean: ydrasse, gloria, morning tweet, pooky
nulltown: jessie, isis
nullscum: flea
scumlean: dunn
scum: skitter

What townie has obvtown Flea as “nullscum”?

They also hasn’t explained any of reads save Gypyx or why they think Skitter isn’t playing to her town meta or whatever?

I think it’s interesting to note that both TGP and Hopkirk switched from Dunn to Skitter. So @Hopkirk, what is your current read on TGP?

i know they've flipped now but i was reading them as town but town-in-a-POE-that's-small-enough-i-wouldn't-oppose-a-flip-on-them

As of where i am like idk p56 or something the obvtown are (Flea/Pooky/Infinity/Morning/Isis) and people i'm townreading based on sheeping reads are (Gloria/Ydrasse)

[Flea The Magician]

I didn't see that bit you quoted, so then I would assume that vanilla in terms of power means there's no outward abilities, such as cops or docs but potentially linked abilities or something that trades something for something else. for example the bodyguard role which dies when the target is killed.

I don't feel there's any way for a mechanical guilty to happen at all having seen that.

i think it means that there is no player given the role 'cop' but there is still plenty of ways for there to be a mechanical guilty. there were mechanical innocents in that game i really don't see how you are ruling out the possibility of mechanical guilties here.

Vanilla in terms of power.

treestump is conf but cant vote.
Lover pairs, what was the configuration for that? TT, SS or was ST an option? Either way, it balanced.

Meanwhile this is all town have a vanilla PM.

[Flea The Magician]

Only other thing that comes to mind is the "all pts have daytalk"

Multiple groups of baddies? How would numbers work there? 2/2/7?

[team rocket queen]

Vanilla in terms of power.

treestump is conf but cant vote.
Lover pairs, what was the configuration for that? TT, SS or was ST an option? Either way, it balanced.

Meanwhile this is all town have a vanilla PM.

right so why can't there be a triggered event like in silent star ii? or why can't there be a vote to public cop like in whichever mystery box that was? i feel like you're continuing to interpret what i am saying as 'someone has the role pm cop' when i am not.

[Ydrasse]

um idk if i should like, say this just bc i don’t see the use in talking about setup spec/etc right now but dwelling on it feels a little like. out of place when we have other things to be analyzing :<

[team rocket queen]

Only other thing that comes to mind is the "all pts have daytalk"

Multiple groups of baddies? How would numbers work there? 2/2/7?

probably. this seems kinda unlikely to me because we talked so much about it in lunacy due to dunnstral no killing and me misinterpreting that

[Ydrasse]

maybe it’s just because my thought process is the last game went wild and this one most likely will too and like, in the absence of knowing how it makes more sense just to scumhunt??

[team rocket queen]

um idk if i should like, say this just bc i don’t see the use in talking about setup spec/etc right now but dwelling on it feels a little like. out of place when we have other things to be analyzing :<

okay talk to me about those things. what would you like me to analyze?

[Hopkirk]

@Flea if TGP does flip scum, why are you so sure Hopkirk can’t be a buddy? I’m still not convinced on Dunn though. I still think he could be scum here but imo, TGP!scum definitely increases the likelihood of suspicion on the Skitter wagon, with of course the exception of Isis.

*swats and sulks*

Admittedly my love for hoppy has fallen with his inactivity and I'm considering questioning my town read having read the ISOs I have

</3

Oh and @Flea, I don’t necessarily I think Dunn calling you a tr here is a pocket unless you want to define that term very broadly. Calling a consensus tr “town” isn’t much of a pocket imo.

Swing and a miss ^_^ Was more before it was the first time I saw me mentioned

this is very sad and makes me even more upset with myself for not being around. bad hopkirk

hopkirk i am contemplating voting for u, btw when u get back

and?
like what's the point of this post even

And the resistance was in fact to tgp

no

[Flea The Magician]

Not familiar with mystery box.

What was the triggered event in SS2?

What I'm challenging is the previous games had room for shenanigans. This one doesn't seem to.

I cannot work with information I don't have, quite simply. I can work with information I do have.

[team rocket queen]

hopkirk i am contemplating voting for u, btw when u get back

and?
like what's the point of this post even

you drawing attention to this makes me kinda want to unnote it

[Flea The Magician]

maybe it’s just because my thought process is the last game went wild and this one most likely will too and like, in the absence of knowing how it makes more sense just to scumhunt??

This is kinda what I'm worried about. Jessie seems more keen on setup spec than on anything else :/

[team rocket queen]

you drawing attention to this makes me kinda want to unnote it

at least in the way which i had noted it, which was, hmmmmm more strangeness between these slots

[Hopkirk]

i mean i read the last what 20 pages again there and nothing changed for me tbh. Dunn/Skitter30 are way below everyone else

i lost a quote from Skitter30 earlier there where i was gonna say something like they felt like they were really positioning themselves for post flip when they did some shading of Isis pre flip - which did get followed up with an isis vote- but i lost that somewhere and who cares if i quote it or not tbh you get the point

VOTE: Dunn I don't really care between Dunn/Skitter30 right now, my current POE is small

[team rocket queen]

maybe it’s just because my thought process is the last game went wild and this one most likely will too and like, in the absence of knowing how it makes more sense just to scumhunt??

This is kinda what I'm worried about. Jessie seems more keen on setup spec than on anything else :/

it just feels kinda agenda based when you are saying 'dunno why they thought this was a possibility' after they flip even though you also have reason to suspect it might be possible

like either to enforce the 'oh i was so sure of that too' or to enforce the 'i think we are playing vanilla doubleday' perception

[Hopkirk]

i'm kind of tired or in a slightly different headspace rigt now and i don't really follow you jessie can you rephrase that or something

[Flea The Magician]

╭( ͝ಠل͜ಠ)つ
Hoppys back <3

[Hopkirk]

and ready to go! or like fall over on the table works too i guess idk
what are you thinking at the moment Flea?

[Ydrasse]

you see the next part is figuring out where to start because lord knows where i want to uhhh

probably the votes on tgp? all i remember is pooky letting me hammer OTL the setup stuff jsut feels... a bit useless without further context for me

[team rocket queen]

i'm kind of tired or in a slightly different headspace rigt now and i don't really follow you jessie can you rephrase that or something

like it felt like another example of communication between you and skitter which felt out of place to me, but you saying, 'and what of it? why are you making this post' seems more along the lines of how i was thinking about it

[Flea The Magician]

maybe it’s just because my thought process is the last game went wild and this one most likely will too and like, in the absence of knowing how it makes more sense just to scumhunt??

This is kinda what I'm worried about. Jessie seems more keen on setup spec than on anything else :/

it just feels kinda agenda based when you are saying 'dunno why they thought this was a possibility' after they flip even though you also have reason to suspect it might be possible

like either to enforce the 'oh i was so sure of that too' or to enforce the 'i think we are playing vanilla doubleday' perception

Oh my bad, you're hunting based on setup spec interactions where I'm reading the setup post as "All town are vanilla" when you're reading "All town are vanilla until they're not" using "All town are vanilla in power" from a previous game as justification.
へ‿(ツ)‿ㄏ

[Ydrasse]

like i think uh. asking why someone is focused on setup spec and stuff though etc is a different beast than just flat out setup spec i should not play with four hours of sleep

[Flea The Magician]

and ready to go! or like fall over on the table works too i guess idk
what are you thinking at the moment Flea?

Honestly, I'm getting a bad vibe from Jessie but i'm not sure if its just spec gone wild at this point, like feels like she knows something we dont?