Musician Mafia: Guitarists GAME OVER

[BrightEyedFish]

To eat is human; to digest, divine.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

[pisskop]

lol nerds

[pisskop]

coordinated bah posts

[The Baker]

Vote Count 8.04

Shout out to the dude that elbowed me in the face the one time I tried hardcore dancing.

Almost50 (2): Bambi Jay, pisskop
Gamma Emerald (2): TiphaineDeath, Almost50

Not Voting (3): Lavender, Gamma Emerald, Grendel

With 7 players alive, it takes 4 votes to shred someone.
Day Eight ends on Tuesday December 8th 2020 at 9:00pm EST in (expired on 2020-12-08 21:00:00)

[TiphaineDeath]

Hey guys, do you think it's reasonable to assume there are two scum left in this game?

[Almost50]

Shout out to the dude that elbowed me in the face the one time I tried hardcore dancing.

[Almost50]

Hey guys, do you think it's reasonable to assume there are two scum left in this game?

0 chance of that IMHO. Like, 2 Scum + 2 Cult + 1 3P + 2 Town = Town is screwed any way you slice it. (and if Bambi's action actually skips a whole night Scum might as well be celebrating already. All they need to do is shoot both pisskop & Gamma and hope Cult target at least one of them to keep them from regaining full strength.)

[pisskop]

We kill 50

He's got all the answers, just relax, he's got this. You wont feel but a slight pinch

[Almost50]

We kill 50

Be a sportsman and DO IT!

[Grendel]

I think tipain is more likely to flip scum here. VOTE: Tipaindeath

I'm not opposed to getting A50 flipped today though. If he is a 3rd party night jester then he could be a problem down the road. For instance mylo scum negotiations , or king maker situations. Otherwise he is bluffing scum, but I find that less likely then 3rd party.

I feel obligated to mention that is mechanically impossible for bambi to be Solo scum bc scum don't have mutitasking. She couldn't use her powers and preform the nk.

Lav also unlikely Solo scum for reasons I previously mentioned in another post

[Grendel]

@lavender/b]

If cult is flipped today you should cover last cult member tonight. If anybody else is flipped you should target into me to redirect the protect onto yourself.

[Lavender]

Got it Grendal!~
Been kinda busy, kinda half-skimming half-reading
My opinion thus hasn’t changed much since last time
I found the Dead Posting to be particularly adorable however~

[Almost50]

I think tipain is more likely to flip scum here. VOTE: Tipaindeath

I'm not opposed to getting A50 flipped today though. If he is a 3rd party night jester then he could be a problem down the road. For instance mylo scum negotiations , or king maker situations. Otherwise he is bluffing scum, but I find that less likely then 3rd party.

I feel obligated to mention that is mechanically impossible for bambi to be Solo scum bc scum don't have mutitasking. She couldn't use her powers and preform the nk.

Lav also unlikely Solo scum for reasons I previously mentioned in another post

GDI, man! It's not about what's

likely

anymore. It's about "what if

the unlikely is true

?". You're adamant to take the risk of handing the game to the Cult.

I get that you suspect TD, and I get that you also suspect me to a lesser degree. Fine. I accept that. Now THINK:

What if <whomever we shred> flips NOT SCUM

? And what if Cult DO recruit a third member tonight? That would be GAME BLOODY OVER! With six alive (even disregarding the Scum NK) Cult will already have achieved their win con. The problem is if Scum DO kill outside of the bloody Cult. THAT is YOUR problem.

Now let me tell you about mine:

Assuming TD is not currently culted and we shred him, scum canNOT afford to shoot me lest the Cult DO succeed in recruiting a third. This means I am NOT going to get shot tonight either.

The

only

way you keep

everyone

happy today is by shredding a

bloody cultist

. That way you are guaranteed

there is a tomorrow

in this game.

I don't have the slightest idea why you want to take that leap of faith and try to shred Scum today instead. If you succeed, that's GOOD, and it may even end the game in your favour (and I still lose). If you fail (to shred scum) though, you are forfeiting the game yourself (and I bloody still lose).

So, let me ask you this question: Are you willing to end the game today/tonight regardless of the outcome? Or are you trying to end it with a TOWN win?

[Almost50]

@lavender/b]

If cult is flipped today you should cover last cult member tonight. If anybody else is flipped you should target into me to redirect the protect onto yourself.

That's also shortsighted IMHO, but it's not MY problem. The right play is for Lav to be on you at all times. If she is Town and you are (and I certainly think you are because it's the only way to explain why Drew was NK'd) then TWO TOWNIES are unkillable. What do you care if Scum kill Cult? If Lav protects them she us the NK for bloody sure.

[pisskop]

50 is again pushing the narrative that the cult, who claimed despite having an overwhelming position, and who mod confirmed has a town compatible wincon, is out to fuck over town because he doesnt want to die.

[pisskop]

Keep in mind, that 50 has played list garbage this game, has prodged, has claimed a role that his play hasnt conformed to, and is now pushing a clearly an agenda that has a 0% chance of hitting scum tonight.

[pisskop]

Stop fiddling around with secondary lynches and vote for the monkey!

[TiphaineDeath]

Whatever, cult deserves this win

VOTE: A50

[Grendel]

@pisskop

A50 is probably an indie, why not consolidate onto Tipain who looks like real scum rn?

I'd rather A50 be your recruit choice. That way A50 still can win with the "town/cult coelution" if the game continues.

plus im wary that if we let tipain!scum live at this juncture he will game throw by not shooting cult tonight. Based off his recent A50 vote.

[Grendel]

I think tipain is more likely to flip scum here. VOTE: Tipaindeath

I'm not opposed to getting A50 flipped today though. If he is a 3rd party night jester then he could be a problem down the road. For instance mylo scum negotiations , or king maker situations. Otherwise he is bluffing scum, but I find that less likely then 3rd party.

I feel obligated to mention that is mechanically impossible for bambi to be Solo scum bc scum don't have mutitasking. She couldn't use her powers and preform the nk.

Lav also unlikely Solo scum for reasons I previously mentioned in another post

GDI, man! It's not about what's

likely

anymore. It's about "what if

the unlikely is true

?". You're adamant to take the risk of handing the game to the Cult.

I get that you suspect TD, and I get that you also suspect me to a lesser degree. Fine. I accept that. Now THINK:

What if <whomever we shred> flips NOT SCUM

? And what if Cult DO recruit a third member tonight? That would be GAME BLOODY OVER! With six alive (even disregarding the Scum NK) Cult will already have achieved their win con. The problem is if Scum DO kill outside of the bloody Cult. THAT is YOUR problem.

Now let me tell you about mine:

Assuming TD is not currently culted and we shred him, scum canNOT afford to shoot me lest the Cult DO succeed in recruiting a third. This means I am NOT going to get shot tonight either.

The

only

way you keep

everyone

happy today is by shredding a

bloody cultist

. That way you are guaranteed

there is a tomorrow

in this game.

I don't have the slightest idea why you want to take that leap of faith and try to shred Scum today instead. If you succeed, that's GOOD, and it may even end the game in your favour (and I still lose). If you fail (to shred scum) though, you are forfeiting the game yourself (and I bloody still lose).

So, let me ask you this question: Are you willing to end the game today/tonight regardless of the outcome? Or are you trying to end it with a TOWN win?

its not a forfeit unless the game moves into night phsae instead of ending, and scum decide to not shoot cult tonight.

I guess that wanting to hit scum right this minute is risky since If im wrong then scum can king maker tonight and let cult win. But idk why mafia would do that outside of spitefulness.

[Grendel]

*@pisskop and Gamma*

Actully now that i think about it, why did you guys choose to try and recruit me last night? I thought you agreed to use your powers like a cop shot?

you also said that either of you can recruit right? you dont require the leader?

[Grendel]

I doubt the mod is going to clarify but if

@Baker

feels like confirming for us that the cult win-condition does not create a loss for town, I am willing and happy to hear it.

I think it's OBVIOUS that if they are alive at ENDGAME it means someone else won, and thy win WITH that "someone else".

NOPM role pm, and this post by baker clearly means that town and cult can win together. I felt the need to double check.

-/-/-/

Trying to recruit the most town read player on the roster after saying you;d try and recruit scum the day prior seems really underhanded to me. I dont like what they implies about cult's original plan for today.

UNVOTE:

[Grendel]

Maybe the best path for today is flip a cultist / have lav cover remaining cultist tonight / cult recruits A50 tonight.

unless is the recruit takes priority over, or executes simultaneously as, killing shots. if thats the case then lav can cover me tonight and not worry about protecting cult b/c last cult can recruit even if they also die that night.

@The Baker

If mafia shoot a player attempting to recruit at night, does the recruiting ablity still go through?

[Grendel]

out of the two cultists I'd probably flip pisskop today b/c I feel like he's less willing to work with town then Gamma is.

Heck, Gamma was the one who wanted to out and townside in the first place.