Newbie 2043: Cherfnul - Game Over

[Rockhopper]

pagetop

[Chumbo]

I agree with that Rockhopper

[Trendall]

Wouldn't have thought it makes a difference because it sounds to me as though that's just a wild stab in the dark.

[Chumbo]

Wouldn't have thought it makes a difference because it sounds to me as though that's just a wild stab in the dark.

Yeah I guess, I'd kind of like to see what BM has to say before we get too far into it though. He is the most experienced player here.

[Rockhopper]

Ruling out {Bend, clidd} and {Lone, Trendall} as the scum teams

[LoneMarkhor]

Random thoughts.Dont pay too much attention.

[Chumbo]

Ruling out {Bend, clidd} and {Lone, Trendall} as the scum teams

If lone and trendall was a scum team, this is a genius move.

[ben dover123]

Ah, I had a nice nap and thought over it.

So, Chumbo also notices where I am coming from against Rock here. Well, I feel reassured now.

Hm. I'm probably going to wait for BM before posting anything else. I already spilled my thoughts on Rock, still going to do a meta analysis today but I need to read over his games again.

I know I said I wasn't going to move my vote from clidd but Rock yesterday was having some wacky thought lines that I don't think come from town. Let's see what BM has got for clidd here

[Trendall]

So, Chumbo also notices where I am coming from against Rock here. Well, I feel reassured now.

I mean Chumbo could easily be the mafia.

[ben dover123]

So, Chumbo also notices where I am coming from against Rock here. Well, I feel reassured now.

I mean Chumbo could easily be the mafia.

:thonk:

tbh I got newbie town vibes from Chumbo, I think he is likely town just below you.

What do you think of Rock's posts?

[ben dover123]

cliddd n' LoneMarkhor top mafia suspects.

Wait I saw this post. You don't think Rock's posts are likely scum? Also, why LoneMarkhor?

[Trendall]

You don't think Rock's posts are likely scum?

No why would I?

[ben dover123]

You don't think Rock's posts are likely scum?

No why would I?

Uhhhhhhhhhh...

Did you not see this?

Hm. Maybe I did but...

I'm almost convinced Rock is the other scum alongside clidd now, Rock SR'ed me for TMI, an absurdly strong tell, a tell way stronger than anything Rock had against Lavar, and yet all he says is:

Interesting. You are now a scum lean.

No vote, no nothing. His scumlean came nearly

7 hours

before he explained the reasoning, which I assume either he constructed a case against me in those 7 hours because he needed to push me, or his reasoning for the scumlean was already set as TMI. If he constructed a case on the go, that just screams scum trying to progress the push of my miselimination and if he already had his scumlean set as "I had TMI", then him not voting there is indecisive scum who doesn't want to push me here.

He literally admitted to purposely creating a f***** up readlist, which is beyond sub-optimal play for town.

He says "bad reads =/= scummy" in a vacuum? He should know this is blatantly false (from plain experience), as bad reads are not a direct scumtell.

He is using burden of proof to deflect the fact that he is making bad reads.

(burden of proof is a logical fallacy, when used to deflect the person that is using this fallacy is trying to divert attention from one aspect of their argument)

Hm. Is it me or is it just so coincidental that when I start using emotions to pressure him, he leaves the chat? I must say....

VOTE: Rockhopper

clidd's meta case is a good case but this is just actually terrible coming from Rock.

[Trendall]

Yeah I saw that post, but in terms of Rockhopper I haven't really seen much reason to think that he's mafia at the moment.

[Trendall]

Lel. Heavy town pings from LoneMarkhor for saying that.

Oh yeah I agree with this btw

[ben dover123]

Yeah I saw that post, but in terms of Rockhopper I haven't really seen much reason to think that he's mafia at the moment.

Hmph. I'm reluctant to unvote Rock for those posts, I just hate how it looks for Rock. tbh I may go back to clidd depending on what BM's case is, but I want Rock to do something about those posts, like at least give a bare minimum explanation.

Lel. Heavy town pings from LoneMarkhor for saying that.

Oh yeah I agree with this btw

Wait, so if clidd is your only SR, then who do you think is his partner?

[Trendall]

At what point did I say that 'clidd is my only scumread'? I don't have 'scumreads', I said already that the mafia is between clidd, Chumbo and Battle Mage cause everyone else seems town.

[ben dover123]

At what point did I say that 'clidd is my only scumread'? I don't have 'scumreads', I said already that the mafia is between clidd, Chumbo and Battle Mage cause everyone else seems town.

Wait, when did BM and Chumbo enter the mix? I thought you said LoneMarkhor and clidd were your highest SR's, so I wondered who you thought clidd's partner would be if LoneMarkhor was giving you town pings now.

[Trendall]

In post #277, then LoneMarkhor looked more suspicious, then he looked more towny again so it went back to those three.

[ben dover123]

In post #277, then LoneMarkhor looked more suspicious, then he looked more towny again so it went back to those three.

I feel like Chumbo is just giving me plain newbie town vibes, especially when he was attacking me a couple pages back for the wrong reasons, as it seemed the attack and reactions were genuine.

BM is another case completely. So inactive and so little to judge him on....

I could metadive him, but I'm not because there is literally nothing to judge him by his meta.

The thing that could determine his alignment is his take on clidd, which we are all waiting today.

Well, here comes the waiting.

[borkjerfkin]

NotAJumbleOfNumbers has requested replacement.

Battle Mage's V/LA expires today and has 24 hours from this message to post or will be in prod range.

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 1.5

[3] Rockhopper (clidd, ben dover123, Chumbo)
[2] ben dover123 (Battle Mage, Rockhopper)
[1] clidd (Trendall)

[3] Not Voting (LoneMarkhor, NotAJumbleOfNumbers, LavarManos)

With 9 alive, it is 5 to eliminate.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2020-12-12 08:30:00)

[ben dover123]

Good grief, everyone is getting replaced.

4 days left until deadline, I hope we can sort this situation out. We need BM to talk soon, otherwise D2 will leave us with so many unknowns.

I'm still trying to figure out what kind of interaction lies within {clidd, Rockhopper}. If I can figure this puzzle, I think we will be in the clear going into D2.

[borkjerfkin]

Lunar Martian replaces NotAJumbleOfNumbers!

[ben dover123]

Hi there!
Lemme just grab my RQS for you to answer...