Silent Star 3: Royalty

[Hopkirk]

Until now MT has been in the same place in my readlists I had most of the scum in Death Curse (3/5 of them, light null townread that I can't explain in a way that makes me happy with it.

[Morning Tweet]

I don't get how MT sees a wagon with Skitter30/Dunn/Gyp on it after saying she doesn't like those three (plus a weak townread, Isis) and says to herself 'yes, i'd prefer to join that wagon than the one all of my townreads are pushing'. Like how can you claim to be a POE player then go for a wagon

every single one of your scumreads wants

...sudden and temporary bout of insanity?

[Hopkirk]

three/seven people who voted me are blaming their votes on insanity

[Gloria Cleary]

'the game stalled' as a thought really doesn't logically lead 'the person who got wagoned in part for inactivity is town'.
Either mafia are intentionally stalling (and not being here becomes a major sus) or mafia are happy with the gamestate (Skitter30/Hop being the two biggest wagons for a while) are the two most obvious ways to explain that gamestate. Not voting Gyp there kind of resembles her stance around Dunn/TGP in a weird way.

Yeah, I’m definitely paranoing on MT now. She pretty much comes in at the last minute to vote you, like she was maybe hoping she wouldn’t have to vote?

This is why my Ydrasse read has stayed constant. Her activity level hasn’t changed, where as MT’s has.

[Infinity 324]

But ydrasse has gotten less active? Especially in the middle there.

[Gloria Cleary]

three/seven people who voted me are blaming their votes on insanity

Like I actually believe Pooky misread you but MT’s answer seems to be coming out of nowhere.

[Morning Tweet]

three/seven people who voted me are blaming their votes on insanity :lol:

hey i tried (≧∀≦)

I do love you Hop

[Infinity 324]

Who’s scum tweet?

[Gloria Cleary]

But ydrasse has gotten less active? Especially in the middle there.

I think it’s timing and she was clearly opposed to Hopkirk wagon.

[Hopkirk]

I don't get TGP's defense of gypyx in 725, but I kind of liked TGP in it. Will be interesting to see why he's such a big wagon right now.

tgp looks like a gypyx partner

I didn't like any of Skitter30's posting on this page and am especially curious on this. I don't get pushing this association.

this is my interpretation of the TGP-gypyx interacton. I also agree that the TGP/Gypx partner idea doesn't make sense.

VC on this page.

(Dunn/Skitter30/Gypyx/Jessie) is the people I don't have good vibes on.
It's also to some extent concerning overlapping with people not approaching the game in a certain way.

TGP isn't really a

townread

but I initially got bad vibes from, there's a couple of things that seem weird from scum, and my POE hates them, so they get townpoints for that.

This is a really good list, except i townread jessie

Gloria and Jessie im strongest on. Infinity is close to them. and below them, hopkirk + Pooky + Isis + Flea i've all gotten townleans on.

leaving ydrasse, golden, skitts, dunn, and gypx. Ydrasse and Golden i have weak reasoning for. The other three i just don't have an opinion on. I think Gypx's behaviour is sort of weird for scum but ive seen scum do it too. Skitts (along with Isis) in their sort of 1v1 i just have been glossing over after initially disagreeing with what i saw. I'm not confident in my ability to read skitts without associative information. Dunn is playing like he did in forest fire and silent star 1.. which unfortunately i took to be as a scumtell in Forest fire and miselimed him (or tried to anyway). i think I know what to watch out for to learn his alignment

VC on this page.

if you're arguing that Dunn is a partner of Golden then why are you flipping Dunn first? i'm pretty sure that's what he's getting at and that's largely what is losing me here

I am just completely lost at how no one interpreted it that way which leads me to believe im missing something but i can't delve rn

it'd be cute if tweet/gloria could vote

(◕ω◕) ♡

VOTE: TGP

if you're arguing that Dunn is a partner of Golden then why are you flipping Dunn first? i'm pretty sure that's what he's getting at and that's largely what is losing me here

I am just completely lost at how no one interpreted it that way which leads me to believe im missing something but i can't delve rn

You don’t think it logical to prefer to flip the one you find scummier first, why?

that was more referring to Pooky and whoever else is arguing that Golden and Dunn are together, which i thought you were

As for you specifically, your point against Dunn seems to be his read progression on Pooky. you keep referencing 1461 but i'm totally missing where he townreads Pooky there

I think Dunn might still be scum outside of this but i fail to see what you're seeing (aside from calling Isis sweaty, which hurts my feelings vicariously). But like so many people are seeing it when im not so im worried im just not seeing right

[Hopkirk]

your progression on Dunn/TGP is almost (not quite but almost) as weird. You seem to be townreading TGP and scumreading Dunn up to the point you vote TGP

[Gloria Cleary]

Is it possible that other town knows something I dont? There is probably very few scum if my reads are right, and it would make sense with the way the thread generally feels

But everyone's VT.. -- does that restrict other information being given? is it a total coincidence the only thing Golden did was defend Gypyx and now the only person who gains votes is Gypyx? am I losing my mind here

I dont know, i suppose i would be really surprised if Gypyx is scum that gets a hard towncase from the flipped townie and has everything going for him, then ghosts out of the game completely for some reason. and then

he's the only one who amassed a real wagon

But that isn’t true. Hopkirk was the counterwagon.

[Hopkirk]

it'd be cute if tweet/gloria could vote

(◕ω◕) ♡

VOTE: TGP

nvm this was after deadline
but not being on Dunn was weird given that was the competing wagon and they had a clear stated preference for voting Dunn, were on a vanity wagon, and low key argued against a Dunn vote > a TGP vote in one of the posts i quoted above

[Gloria Cleary]

I don't get how MT sees a wagon with Skitter30/Dunn/Gyp on it after saying she doesn't like those three (plus a weak townread, Isis) and says to herself 'yes, i'd prefer to join that wagon than the one all of my townreads are pushing'. Like how can you claim to be a POE player then go for a wagon

every single one of your scumreads wants

...sudden and temporary bout of insanity?

three/seven people who voted me are blaming their votes on insanity

hey i tried (≧∀≦)

I do love you Hop

Is this your typical reaction when you think you’ve miselimed someone?

[Hopkirk]

MT's vote doesn't feel like someone who's been absent from the thread for several days, I assume has read up, and feels they're in danger of a nightkill that'll silence their chance to update people on their reads/POE.
Like if you haven't posted for a while, presumably have thoughts/an updated POE, do you just put down the vote then go offline until after deadline? Either MT didn't fully catch up (scum QT helped?), didn't have time to do it (the town MT scenario) or put down a vote without their reads changing which hardcore doesn't gel with their previous reads.

I can see either opportunistic scum, or scum who forgot they were supposed to have a TR on me, or scum trying to save a partner.

[Hopkirk]

^ puts vote down then doesn't return until after deadline that is.

[Hopkirk]

i should do other stuff now, so have fun and listen to Gloria.

[Gloria Cleary]

your progression on Dunn/TGP is almost (not quite but almost) as weird. You seem to be townreading TGP and scumreading Dunn up to the point you vote TGP

Her reaction to her voting you is hella strange. Like contrast it with Pooky’s who actually sounds like he’s regretting his vote. MT doesn’t seem to be particularly upset. I was very upset when I saw the TGP flip, so her reaction to you post-hammer is seriously weird coming from town.

[Hopkirk]

MT is probably my top pick for scum after this tbh.

[Gloria Cleary]

MT's vote doesn't feel like someone who's been absent from the thread for several days, I assume has read up, and feels they're in danger of a nightkill that'll silence their chance to update people on their reads/POE.
Like if you haven't posted for a while, presumably have thoughts/an updated POE, do you just put down the vote then go offline until after deadline? Either MT didn't fully catch up (scum QT helped?), didn't have time to do it (the town MT scenario) or put down a vote without their reads changing which hardcore doesn't gel with their previous reads.

I can see either opportunistic scum, or scum who forgot they were supposed to have a TR on me, or scum trying to save a partner.

^ puts vote down then doesn't return until after deadline that is.

Yeah, I’m currently leaning scum bat. But it definitely looks like she was trying to save Gypyx for whatever reason. Her reaction to you post-hammer isn’t townie.

[Gloria Cleary]

MT is probably my top pick for scum after this tbh.

Yes and my all VT theory is completely shot to bits now.

If I don’t get NK’d pretty sure that where I’ll be voting tomorrow.

[Morning Tweet]

i don't really have any excuse for this -- i was swamped with classwork, yes, but i still had opportunities to play that i just didn't take. I ended up seriously not enjoying this game. Which sucks considering i love everyone here

and of course, i love you Hop

sigh

[Morning Tweet]

this guy seriously keeps me going

Spoiler:

[Hopkirk]

I fake-soft claimed tracker before i realized this was all vanilla.
It definitely wasn't going to be all vanilla, but if it was something like 'the first two eliminated get to recruit scum and become aligned with scum' that'd be a fun setup tbh.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

*flops tweeties ears*

its ok if you're red hun you can just do that blinking thing