You may be a top 2 SR, but there is no need to claim when your wagon is still E-3 and there is still a larger and more motivated wagon than yours.In post 497, clidd wrote:Maybe being top 2 SR?In post 495, Trendall wrote:I can't work out the town motivation for claiming so early?
? Who has a big case against you again? Everyone has small shards of scummy behavior but no one has a massive case against you.clidd wrote:Maybe a big case against me?
I was going to say setup is down to double goons or any setup with Doc, but I suppose if clidd's partner is competent enough maybe he wanted to sack himself to out a pr. Although, that's not a great strat to use...In post 499, Trendall wrote:Yeah so as mafia you sacrifice yourself to out a pr.
Aren't PoE's way more effective after flips?In post 503, clidd wrote:And I kind of let the wave move, to see how far it would go.
I'm "ok" with claiming, if that means that we will have a decent PoE.
Mafia can do that without claiming.In post 499, Trendall wrote:Yeah so as mafia you sacrifice yourself to out a pr.
How would you do it?In post 505, clidd wrote:Mafia can do that without claiming.
But yeah, I understand what you're saying.
Rolefishing.In post 507, Trendall wrote:How would you do it?In post 505, clidd wrote:Mafia can do that without claiming.
But yeah, I understand what you're saying.
With a Rock flip, it would.In post 504, ben dover123 wrote:Aren't PoE's way more effective after flips?In post 503, clidd wrote:And I kind of let the wave move, to see how far it would go.
I'm "ok" with claiming, if that means that we will have a decent PoE.
Based on what?In post 383, Trendall wrote:I mean Chumbo could easily be the mafia.
I really don't think ben is scum. I did before, but with his meta analysis and other newer posts, it doesn't seem like he is anymore. I don't see scum intentions.In post 406, Lunar Martian wrote:Hello! I had some issues with permissions and couldn't post. I haven't read the whole thread yet, but to answer Mr. Dover, this is my first game so I'm not really sure about any of that. I played a few games of irl mafia with some friends, but haven't played online so I'm really not sure what to expect. So far the people I'm most suspicious of are clidd who seems a bit off and artificial, and ben dover who looks like he's trying to look like hes being helpful without doing much to actually help or solve. On this page for example, Ben attacks Lavar for voting for Rockhopper, while he himself is also voting for Rockhopper and is pushing for more votes there.
VOTE: ben dover123
I'm not really a fan of this answer, would you at least wait for a claim?In post 409, Battle Mage wrote:A great question. It depends - I am generally a "hammer first, ask questions later" sorta guy.
Why? You have said nothing about me.
Why would you do this?
I highly doubt this. I still think this was a bad thing to do, but I don't see why mafia would sacrifice themself when they only have 2 votes on them.In post 499, Trendall wrote:Yeah so as mafia you sacrifice yourself to out a pr.
In post 506, LoneMarkhor wrote:Oops I was going vote you Clidd.The flattery bit just didnt seem town.Probably I shall wait for a counterclaim.
:thonk: I'm not going for a Rock flip if this is how you are advocating it. Plus, I need to see how this claim unfolds before we do anything about Rock.In post 510, clidd wrote:With a Rock flip, it would.In post 504, ben dover123 wrote:Aren't PoE's way more effective after flips?In post 503, clidd wrote:And I kind of let the wave move, to see how far it would go.
I'm "ok" with claiming, if that means that we will have a decent PoE.
Yeah...honestly it could be seen as a panic claim ngl.Trendall wrote:I don't see why town would claim when they only have two votes on them, that's the problem I'm having.
I think I already contextualized the scenario.In post 512, Trendall wrote:I don't see why town would claim when they only have two votes on them, that's the problem I'm having.
Wdym? He could have been hanged today...In post 514, Trendall wrote:Also he's never getting eliminated is he so he doesn't even has to sacrifice himself at all necessarily.
This isn't true imo, but ok.In post 514, Trendall wrote:Also he's never getting eliminated is he so he doesn't even has to sacrifice himself at all necessarily.
Then why didn't you wait a bit till you were at E-1 to claim then? I'm still not quite understanding the whole scenario...In post 519, clidd wrote:Wait, actually, it is. I would claim I get to E-1
I mean if I were you I would have made up something about it being near the deadline and wanting to avoid a no elimination or whatever.In post 516, clidd wrote:I think I already contextualized the scenario.
As soon as somebody wants to eliminate you, ben dover123 will pop up and sayIn post 518, clidd wrote:This isn't true imo, but ok.
Yeah I meant like, you're never getting eliminated after having claimed doctor. Before I'm not sure about.In post 519, clidd wrote:Wait, actually, it is. I would claim I get to E-1