Newbie 2043: Cherfnul - Game Over

[Trendall]

But isn't rockhopper more suspicious?I mean now it seems

Yeah dw I think virtually everyone thinks so other than me.

[LoneMarkhor]

As if he was scum trying to seem town by being too agressive?

[LoneMarkhor]

Voting without good reasons.

[Trendall]

As if he was scum trying to seem town by being too agressive?

That's what LavarManos's argument was essentially, yeah. And as far as I could work out everybody else's basis for it was essentially 'he is acting odd so he is mafia'.

[LoneMarkhor]

You think he is acting odd so he is town?

[Lunar Martian]

I see rock's posts as townie. I think it's a bit melodramatic for clidd to get so frustrated and claim, and for rock to say "just kill me"... I don't think either of them was the most voted person at the time they did that.

[Trendall]

You think he is acting odd so he is town?

I think that people act odd all over the internet and in real life all of the time. But in the vast majority of cases these people acting odd aren't even playing a game of mafia in the first place, so 'odd behaviour' can't exactly be an indicator of any particular alignment.

Just for clarification as well I don't think Rockhopper was even acting odd at all, that just seemed to be the perception from other people.

[LoneMarkhor]

How many days to deadline?

[LoneMarkhor]

How many days to deadline?

Only four days.Excluding rock I have no other strong suspect.Yes I agree trendall but that was more than just odd behaviour.But that could just as easily have been a townie.

[clidd]

I like the fact that my pool of elimination is 4, but there may still be a person off the radar, who is not playing scummy and knows how to behave properly.

[LoneMarkhor]

Are we even going to eliminate someone day 1 because I can think of no one likely to be scum!

[clidd]

I see rock's posts as townie. I think it's a bit melodramatic for clidd to get so frustrated and claim, and for rock to say "just kill me"... I don't think either of them was the most voted person at the time they did that.

Not sure where your head is.

[clidd]

Are we even going to eliminate someone day 1 because I can think of no one likely to be scum!

Like I said, scum can be just people who're scummy (that we see as newbietown) or someone who is playing towny as scum.

[clidd]

But I believe that the simplistic solution is to eliminate by order of "who is more scummy", so if the game goes to a sensitive state of ELO, we would not have to worry about dealing with such a slot.

[clidd]

And note that I am using "we" in a suppository tone within an imaginary scenario, not necessarily referring to my staying in the game after D1.

[clidd]

You think he is acting odd so he is town?

I think that people act odd all over the internet and in real life all of the time. But in the vast majority of cases these people acting odd aren't even playing a game of mafia in the first place, so 'odd behaviour' can't exactly be an indicator of any particular alignment.

Just for clarification as well I don't think Rockhopper was even acting odd at all, that just seemed to be the perception from other people.

Do you think we are biased to see Rock saying odd things?

I'm pretty sure he's playing in a "eliminate me pls" mode.

[clidd]

Actually, I'm kind of liking the idea of a BM eli too, it's very likely that he's going to coast and do nothing. At least these new slots are trying.

[clidd]

We could also accept the fact that I'm clear, btw.

I haven't seen any ccs so far, why wait more?

[clidd]

Well, if my current vote isn't sparking, it's time to change:

VOTE: Battle Mage

[clidd]

lol

Hey Lavar, I don't particularly suspect you, but this comment after my claim followed by total silence was a ping. Just for the record.

[LoneMarkhor]

Can the doctor protect himself?

[clidd]

Yes, I can.

[clidd]

But let's just not talk about that, ok?

[LoneMarkhor]

VOTE: BattleMage

Perhaps he will take this game more seriously.

[clidd]

If he towntells in some way, I can change my mind.

Let's see.