BooneyToonz XIV: A Little Boonie Told Me [END]

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

gamma's flip does make role madness a hard sell. he'd have to be deathVT

hmm what would be the difference between a deathVT and a VT

[Gypyx]

It technically could yeah, but we have at least 2/3 real VT's, so...

Pedit : deathVT? That would be variant

[Happy Birthday Boonskiies]

Klick! I have a couple of questions for you:

1) How excited are you to be here on a scale of 1 to 10?
2) How upset would you be if we launched you on a scale of 1 to 10?

My post must have been lost in your junk mail, Klick...

[Happy Birthday Boonskiies]

Klick! I have a couple of questions for you:

1) How excited are you to be here on a scale of 1 to 10?
2) How upset would you be if we launched you on a scale of 1 to 10?

1) About a... 6! This game looks fun. Dunno if I'll be reading literally everything or just enough to get a good grasp on reads I'm comfy with.
2) 5. I'd get it, but for reals, this slot is town and if you remove yourself and look at the last few pages objectively, you should see that this wagon is misexecute central

Ah, YOUR post got lost in MY junk mail... how embarrassing.

What gave you the impression HBB was approaching your wagon from a town mindset?

[Klick]

It'd be pretty anticlimactic if that was the solve. Personally, I'm rooting for that not be the case and for at least 1 of the remaining scum to be trying to deepwolf and not just float by.

TGP is dangerous to scumread for his playstyle, because he has a certain

tendency

to be low hanging fruit as town and low effort games, and then eventually get mislaunched in them. Ari however can really obvtown as town, and his low motivation is somewhat scum-indicative.

VOTE: Ari for now

Something about this post looked towny to me a second ago

...aaaand it's gone. Your ISO for today actually looks pretty bad from my perspective

[Klick]

Just read HBB's claim early today. Completely buy it, I'm fine working on the assumption that that's just true. Enough of Shoshin's behaviour suggests that it's true that I'm satisfied.

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

Klick read from here -- https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p12310643

and given that both GX and Shelly (endless terror at that time) claimed ascetic at first and then changed their claim to commuters, do you believe that one is very likely town, both are very likely town, or neither?

[Klick]

I think both Samantha and Ydrasse's roles almost certainly need to be accurate if this setup is gonna be fair to scum. On top of that, Ydrasse's role feels really icky as a scum role so I kinda wanna town-bin her as well

PEdit: will do. Might have to get around to finishing it in the next few hours, the little one will demand a walk soon.
Just based on that description I'd say there's definitely something fishy going on with the Gypyx/shelly situation and I'm surprised that isn't talked about much today.

[Klick]

It's very likely that at least one of them is town though, seems odd for both scum to claim commuter that way

[Klick]

Tsunami Slayer's fake townslip is hilarious, love that. ET calling it out says pretty good things about shellyc

[Gypyx]

I think both Samantha and Ydrasse's roles almost certainly need to be accurate if this setup is gonna be fair to scum. On top of that, Ydrasse's role feels really icky as a scum role so I kinda wanna town-bin her as well

PEdit: will do. Might have to get around to finishing it in the next few hours, the little one will demand a walk soon.
Just based on that description I'd say there's definitely something fishy going on with the Gypyx/shelly situation and I'm surprised that isn't talked about much today.

I get it for Ydrasse but why samantha?

[samantha97]

I dunno what their logic is, but I softclaimed in my first post in the thread when everyone else was claiming, for the record

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

it fits with the theme

this was a soft?

[samantha97]

I actually don't know for sure what soft means but I assume I used it right, yeah

commuting = universes

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

i'm gonna be real that experience did not do much to attach itself to my brain let alone towntells

Here's a lesson: Be aware of your surroundings even as scum.

One 72 towntell is that he often does the +townpoints, +scumpoints thing where he assigns these points to people. He also likes jumping in and pressuring, something which hasn't happened.
-S

Klick does this post impact your read of shelly at all?

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

Iunno, it's just...there's posts that are making be really think a Bell/ShellET/Tsunami Vaxxer scumteam is possible.
I guess I know where Imma be looking next!

damn this post from Ari is either TMI or pretty solid in retrospect

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

Reads as I read through but with no reasoning attached:

Gamma

- Town
HBB - Nullscum?

HUB

- Nulltown?
Shelly/EndlessTerror - Scummy
Sam - Towny
Ydrasse - Towny

Bell

- Scummy

BEF

- Towny

look at that f'n readslist lmao

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

Okay, so first things of note for Bell

I like their intro to the game. They feel light and their interactions with neither Tsunami nor Terror seem like buddy interactions.

Looking at it in Iso their Tsunami vote actually makes a lot of sense and alleviates a lot of my worries about the slot.

I also really like their pushes on Vax.
And the slot feels n awful lot like they did in Geriatric Trio II which I modded.

I think it's safe to tuck this slot away as town for now.

Inb4 "That was too fast"
Yeah I know, it's based on vote positioning and post composition.
I get a townread.
I'm moving on.

so close yet so far

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

The Bell read doesn't super feel like s/s tbh

lmao it's okay ari I suck too apparently

[Klick]

I think both Samantha and Ydrasse's roles almost certainly need to be accurate if this setup is gonna be fair to scum. On top of that, Ydrasse's role feels really icky as a scum role so I kinda wanna town-bin her as well

PEdit: will do. Might have to get around to finishing it in the next few hours, the little one will demand a walk soon.
Just based on that description I'd say there's definitely something fishy going on with the Gypyx/shelly situation and I'm surprised that isn't talked about much today.

I get it for Ydrasse but why samantha?

Whoops, I wrote that for Ydrasse first and then added Samantha in after. I think Samantha's claim is real but not for scum balance reasons like with Ydrasse.

i'm gonna be real that experience did not do much to attach itself to my brain let alone towntells

Here's a lesson: Be aware of your surroundings even as scum.

One 72 towntell is that he often does the +townpoints, +scumpoints thing where he assigns these points to people. He also likes jumping in and pressuring, something which hasn't happened.
-S

Klick does this post impact your read of shelly at all?

Not really, why? Am I missing context that I'll get more when I get there? I've never played with shelly either I don't think if it's something about her meta.

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

You'd said Shelly catching the fake townspew was townie so I was just looking for a counter-point to help you flesh out your read of her a bit more by finding a point she kinda defended the 72/noraa scumhydra

[Happy Unbirthday Boon]

tbh I'm mostly just trying to remember what even happened in this game now

[Klick]

Is there a reason this can't be 11-3-1?

[Gypyx]

Third Party? Withholding

And no real evidence of 3p

[Klick]

Ah I saw the two N1 deaths but forgot the 'Hider' bit for a sec, mb

I think something worth looking into is whether there's any evidence of either of the flipped scum having prior knowledge of Gypyx/shelly's real roles before they were claimed in full. If they seem genuinely convinced about the Ascetic claims, then that bodes well for Gypyx/shelly town, but if they're generally disinterested or it's unclear, that could mean they already knew something was up. Something I'll be looking out for as I read