PookyTheMagicalBear v Flavor Leaf (Game Over)

[Double the Trouble]

Why does everyone think there is a Supersaint? I am almost definite it is a red herring. (I will note that this opinion is not backed by facts, but my intuition here.)

this is what I thought at first, but solstice’s justification for their claim is weird.

Either way, I’m going to play around it like it does exist and I don’t see any reason not to.

[Double the Trouble]

Given that I am actually town everything I have done has been inherently town

Like I don't know what you want me to say to that?

I get that I've had pretty atrocious reads all things and If you're BoP scum-reading me that's I can understand that but I'd request that you engage with me beyond "why haven't you been town?" which is all your slot has been saying for the past two game Days

And plenty of people that have played with me before are town reading me currently, maybe it'd be worthwhile to have them go into detail about their read on me instead of just writing me off as scum without any consideration that you're wrong

sure I can give you this cuz I don’t think Norwee knows how to let me catch up first.

[Double the Trouble]

I don't think there are very many people scumreading you. So to say you are "fighting for your life" is a bit of an stretch.
How about instead of defending yourself when it's clearly not much you can do to convince me in that apartment, you case someone else for why they are much more likely scum?

The most vocal mason is scum reading me and this Dunn/DEB situation is at least delays my death one day (maybe two of shit goes awry)

So I feel my representation of my position in this game is very accurate tyvm

I’ll give you this
ONE of us is right and if its not me it’s probably you lol

[Double the Trouble]

If I were scum I would have reasons ready to go on why I'm scum reading Ydrasse and Toogeloo btw!

And I don't care how much you try to write this off as WIFOM because it's true and anyone who's played a game with scum!Spiffeh should attest to that!

this seems believable and honestly
U r starting to look a bit better

[Double the Trouble]

I read 1 line of toogeloo’s noraa case
I saw the word fluff
And that alone was enough to just skip over that entire case LOL

[Ircher]

Yeah also I don't get why they are trying to do a post-by-post analysis of that slot anyway. It makes no sense due to the noise ratio.

[Double the Trouble]

Alright well that’s my catch up I wanna engage with Spiffeh a bit so I’ll wait for him to come back.

[Double the Trouble]

Yeah also I don't get why they are trying to do a post-by-post analysis of that slot anyway. It makes no sense due to the noise ratio.

was there anything even remotely good in that post?

[Ircher]

I read the fluff thing and skipped over it as well, so I don't know.

[Toogeloo]

Well, if no one's going to read it, it'll save me from finishing it.

I'll just opt for always being a hammer vote for SSfear.

[Double the Trouble]

Dw toogeloo,
I got you when it comes to scum!Polar bears cuz i dunno why people are townreading that slot myself tbh

[Double the Trouble]

If you want to help out with it comes to that tho, the most evidence I’m seeing for Polar Bears being town is that Gloria’s posting today is super goated

[Double the Trouble]

So if ur town and wanna prove scum!polar bears, I would start with that

[Spiffeh]

hi Alisae

[Ircher]

Alright, I looked at Toog's post again. Here's my summary of Toog's points:

1.) Fluff
2.) More fluff
3.) OMGUS
4.) Fluff
5.) Scum theatre
6.) More OMGUS
7.) Fluff
8.) Fluff from Gloria
9.) Fluff
10.) OMGUS
11.) Fluff
12.) Scum theatre
13.) More fluff

So basically--no, there aren't any significant points in Toog's post.

[Double the Trouble]

hi Alisae

hi ok
Why are you townreading polar bears
I’m having trouble reading that slot atm

[Ircher]

Well, if no one's going to read it, it'll save me from finishing it.

I'll just opt for always being a hammer vote for SSfear.

Yeah, forget the PbP analysis. Give us the summary and major points instead. That'll be more useful and less likely to be glazed over.

[Double the Trouble]

[Sigh didn't think of that, should have just thought of it it like an informed townie, claimed it immediately, and leashed every hammer to the scummiest player, probably. Didn't think about it enough clearly]

Also Spiffeh, I feel like I'm the only player that thinks this is a red flag.

[Ircher]

I mean, Supersaint isn't common, and if I were in Solstice's shoes, I probably wouldn't consider the implications of a scum Supersaint dither. I don't see why that's a major red flag for you.

[Spiffeh]

I am town reading Polar Bears purely because I just played a game with scum!noraa where she was very guarded, inactive, and unmotivated and after that game there's no way scum!noraa:

1. Can translate her enthusiasm/desire to be town in the signup thread to the game thread in a believable way if she actually rolled scum here
2. Was chosen by Flavor Leaf in the first place after her less than stellar performance in Xenoblade 2, which Flavor Leaf played in and is well aware of

I will admit that at times in this game I have certainly written them off because of this and haven't really focused on reading them after first coming to my conclusion, but I think it is so unlikely that my two points above are wrong that I don't think it's worth the effort

[Spiffeh]

[Sigh didn't think of that, should have just thought of it it like an informed townie, claimed it immediately, and leashed every hammer to the scummiest player, probably. Didn't think about it enough clearly]

Also Spiffeh, I feel like I'm the only player that thinks this is a red flag.

I am not super aware of either head's experience as a player to really think one way or another

I understand that it's a little weird but do you think they pull THIS claim out of their ass as scum?

[Double the Trouble]

like I have a huge conspiracy theory on solstice
its a conspiracy theory so I'm trying not to give it to much value.

But basically I have this huge conspiracy theory that scum wanted solstice wagoned d1 so they could town it up in response to the wagon, go somewhere else, then on D2 have them bus bell the way that they did.
Dunn's scum flip is evidence of this.

I suggested this to Pooky and Pooky was like "bro why doesn't she just claim VT"
and first I was like "Ya that's a good question"
but now im like "idunno, having town think there's a supersaint in the game could be good for scum, maybe its possible that scum could do something with that."

cuz like the justification for the claim to me comes across as super messy but it probably is just a red harring or something.

[Double the Trouble]

I am town reading Polar Bears purely because I just played a game with scum!noraa where she was very guarded, inactive, and unmotivated and after that game there's no way scum!noraa:

1. Can translate her enthusiasm/desire to be town in the signup thread to the game thread in a believable way if she actually rolled scum here
2. Was chosen by Flavor Leaf in the first place after her less than stellar performance in Xenoblade 2, which Flavor Leaf played in and is well aware of

I will admit that at times in this game I have certainly written them off because of this and haven't really focused on reading them after first coming to my conclusion, but I think it is so unlikely that my two points above are wrong that I don't think it's worth the effort

Can you elaborate on point 1?

[Gloria Cleary]

[I thought it was really jokey. If Ydrasses' scumteam killed Hectic, I think she'd be practically obligated to do that bit. It's not like it was her choice to kill him]

you mean she wasn't really shaking ?!

I bet money that it I were to say that you wouldn’t believe me right?

[Double the Trouble]

Gloria is ur solve still {DEB, Dunn, Toogeloo}