revO emaG - TENET

[Something_Smart]

My biggest scumread would be S_S

Why?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

superbowl is ++ town - 4388-4400 are pretty townie thoughts, he was also enthusiastically participating in the FL-wagon which I don't expect from scum.

skitter is ++town - She's changed her mind on FL right before he was about to be lol-hammered, which I don't see why she would do if she was scum since I'd imagine she could simply pretend to be afk and laugh as the guy pushing her all day gets yeeted out of the game. she's also displayed a lot of thought in terms of actually sorting/figuring out my alignment and changed her mind more than once in a way that I would expect from town!skitter. Her frustration with the game-state feels very much like how she felt in Betrayal when she was getting run up by the dumbest case in the world.

SS is +town - I don't think he brings up a meta-counterargument to me being a baddie immediately from the only game experience he has with me where I play in a similarly self-destructive and insane fashion if he's scum. He can much more easily fit in with the herd by not bringing up such an argument.

Peta is nullish - I don't like the dissonance between his stated fear of Power!Wolf Pooky taking over the game while keeping his vote on FL - His first post attacking me out of the gate feels very much like what he did recently in a scum game vs me where he opened strong to push. His complete lack of caring feels like it's quite bleh, might actually be town!indicative because I'd think scum!him knows this is a greenflip so he has to at least make this shit look good. Could be wifom but I think he's a better player than that?

MidwayBear is scummy - His hop-on -> Ghost/Out feels like how he would play it as opportunistic scum in the FL wagon. His reasoning for voting me is silly "Firebringer seems genuine in his frustration against Pooky" like what?
A bunch of his other posts in his ISO pinged like it's very weak and waffley feeling, I don't think he believes I'm actually scum here. Whereas Peta is more like "Die Pooky Die Die Die" Midway is more of a gentle soul? It feels different than midwaytown in Antechamber - there is a lack of steel here.

[skitter30]

catching up, around for a bit

[Almost50]

UNVOTE: pisskop

Just following my heart

Also, y'all wanna wait till the other thread hammers? Cuz I seem to see more discussion about what's going over there than what happening over here (it's a semi-serious question)

[skitter30]

You're more than welcome to ask my opinion on anything you like, if your problem is that you don't know where I stand on some important things.

i did ask you for your reads last night, which i believe you ignored

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

what are you even voting pisskop for dude

he's literally non-existent.

[skitter30]

ss do you think you ought to be townread rn by, like, the masses?

[skitter30]

Will you at least accept the meta claim that he has randomly capitalized words in past games and it has (to my knowledge) never been for crumbing purposes?

fwiw i think agree with this r.e. randomly capitalized words

[pisskop]

Just following my heart

hmmmm?

And after your ringing endorsement of my play last game!

[skitter30]

Ah ok. I confirm that Titus & I are neighbors who become lovers if we are in the same timestream. I don't agree with her that this implies doc. I think the IC NK implies strongman, which implies doc.

I think she's probably town from setup spec; it doesn't make an awful lot of sense for this role to be T/S.

i need to read the other thread for this but uh

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

@ Other Thread
Bsky, tell this to Titus.

Your case on me being the only scum relies on three things:

A) I have a turnstile that I can use to send people to the other timeline
B) I'd use this to send my entire team to the other timeline in order to play solo here.
C) I also have a strongman ability that I used to shoot the IC through doc protection.

It's pretty unlikely that scum have a Turnstiling Strongman because like wtf

Pooky got your back Homie.

[skitter30]

i'm so fucking lost

like tbh all these claims are so confusing, i'll just ignore them while things aren't clear

does anyone still disagree with town!bell rn?

hey ceph now I have a scumread. are you proud of me?

no, because i'm reasonably confident that he's town

[skitter30]

Her frustration with the game-state feels very much like how she felt in Betrayal when she was getting run up by the dumbest case in the world.

indeed

[Something_Smart]

i did ask you for your reads last night, which i believe you ignored

My bad.

They're something along the lines of

(Town) Dandelion, peta
Pooky, GFITAC, Fire, LLD
Skitter, Deacon
pisskop, midwaybear, sb9, A50 (Null)

[skitter30]

the whole bottom row is null, not scum, right?
why is sb9 so low?
and why are you townreading peta and fire and gamma?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

sb9 is very very town

[skitter30]

i know, that's why i'm puzzled they're on the bottom tier

I do get skitter's annie read in either scenario since annie's iso looks extremely slimy in the other early timeline

no shit

[Deacon Blues]

Yup, i’m Gunna think about this.

Personally I don’t think this changes the arithmetic for cabd or FF in regards to me. But they should see at least...

Well actually will they even acknowledge the weirdness here?

I see it.

[skitter30]

still desperately want to flip hp, etc etc etc

[skitter30]

still kinda think titus is townie tbh

[Deacon Blues]

And I think Titus is town.

what a pedit

[skitter30]

i can see all of {brian, titus, bell} being town (on play, ignoring mechspec) unfortunately

[Deacon Blues]

Cabd isn't going to be happy with me but I think Bell has exceeded his scum range. possibly considerably. It goes way beyond my bucket thoughts about what parts of his town game he could be able to import in a quantum improvement of his scum game.

[skitter30]

Being a lover, suggests a doc exists. 2 kpn suggests a doc exists.

Bell is fucking town.

i don't get the logic linking 'lover' and 'doc existing'

[Something_Smart]

the whole bottom row is null, not scum, right?

yes

why is sb9 so low?

off the top of my head I can't really remember anything they've done. I could be easily sold on sb town if you point to a few posts you like.

and why are you townreading peta

old read. I thought his early game was incisive and conducive to solving and he's maintained that throughout the game. He doesn't seem to care much about burning bridges either.

and fire

Honestly because (a) Fire is doing stuff and (b) it seems to be useful stuff. His interactions with me were in line with how they usually are when he's town and I don't think he would feel the need to be defending me so strongly as scum.

and gamma?

BG claim. At the very least, worth tabling for a while.