Here is my read-list, ordered from towniest to scummiest. I realized that it doesn't matter if Mafia kills me if I can get my thoughts out through you guys. Feel free to use them and pls cite them for town-cred if I die tonight.
TOWN:
Bugspray:
- Cook's tmi and slip about Bug being town at Post#88
Esoa/Tris:
- From Cook's Post#199, it looks like Esoa vs dk is really TvT (since he's asking Andres how does Andres know it's TvT). Also the way Cook was encouraging that fight really looked like he was trying to get towns to bash each other's heads in.
- From Cook's Unvote in Post#303, it sounds like Cook was reverting his scum-read to "not rock the boat" and try to sound friendly.
- I liked the progression of how Tris was questioning Cook on Post#357, 539. A scum partner would not reiterate contrived questioning. Also, I don't believe Cook was talking to his scum partner all day here.
- Post#1025 looks like she's trying to draw the NK away from me by suggesting I could be bussing. If she expresses that sentiment tomorrow, she's likely town.
Andres:
- Cook participated in flashwagoning of him in Post#696. Also Andres was the counter wagon to Cook at that moment.
- His vote on Post#921 was decisive to getting cook lynched.
Lotus:
- Post#381, Post#528 defense of Jim is quite good, considering Cook is on Jim's wagon.
- Also really liked his analysis from an uninformed perspective. His place on the Cook wagon is well-developed and justified.
Flea:
- Cook's Post#530 generating conspiracy theory likely on a town slot.
- Stream of thought is somewhat towny. But should check on whether this person has done something like that before as scum.
Facebones:
- Cook's Post#651 shading Facebones
SCUM:
Egix:
- Haven't done much.
- a little bit scummy for being on vanity wagon.
Geraint:
- Haven't done much at all. I have him down here because of Andres.
dkkoba:
- Cook unvote of dkkoba on Post#59 after a slight shade, it's rather textbook distancing behavior.
- Post#382, derailing Cook's wagon to start a flash wagon on an inactive slot. My interpretation is dk tried to take advantage of Lotus replacing in and trying to sort out his read.
- Post#388 spinning up a conspiracy theory of Jim when Cook is being wagoned. This could be what I was talking about when I said there is consider resistance to Cook's wagon despite his scumminess.
- Contrived "I liked his reply" when Cook's reply to dk's question was a hanging "one second" on Post#352.
- Consistent defense of Cook as limbait in Post#835, Post#842, Post#876, then chainsawing me like maddog when the Cook wagon was stale at that particular moment. This shows hyper-awareness of the possibility of a buddy getting the ropes.
- Complete ficticious reasoning to get Andres to vote me as I outlined Post#918.
- There is possible reason for dk-town though. From Cook's Post#199, it looks like Esoa vs dk is really TvT (since he's asking Andres how does Andres know it's TvT).
------------------------------------------------------
So my solve is Cook + dk + (Geraint/Egix). I'm pretty confident this is right.
