Newbie 2047: Eggskalon - Game Over

[Not_Mafia]

GG scum, thanks mod for hosting

[borkjerfkin]

Town played a particularly good game, and I think there were several difference-making plays in no particular order:

1) donki and chumbo on day1 realizing they needed to opaquely go for a compromise elim that wasn't on donki was a huge reason that scum got elimed D1 and neither mason got NKed
2) catboi realizing this and protecting the two of them on D2 and D3 was also a huge play
3) marcistar just being utterly on point with reads this game was really impressive.

Nice job everyone!

[catboi]

GG >_>

[marcistar]

gg guys (can i post here now..?)

im so sorry catboi u got sused so much day 1 because of me im sorry
and sorry for everybody else for the problems i caused d1 LOL

also LOL is our game special or something? looking at all the other games, they have lots of posts??

thanks for hosting borkjerfkin!! it was fun tho forums are really confusing

[Chumbo]

You should play more Marci, you really did have good reads

[marcistar]

You should play more Marci, you really did have good reads

thank you, but i dont think my reads were that good tbh. i think i need to become more convincing with what i think.

i was so unused to this at first, but i hope that we'll be able to play again together one time in the future chumbo! i was cheering you on in the dead chat thingy!

[Ninetales]

Good game. Sorry I was completely off base!

[LoneMarkhor]

My first time as scum. GG everyone.

[catboi]

gg guys (can i post here now..?)

im so sorry catboi u got sused so much day 1 because of me im sorry
and sorry for everybody else for the problems i caused d1 LOL

also LOL is our game special or something? looking at all the other games, they have lots of posts??

thanks for hosting borkjerfkin!! it was fun tho forums are really confusing

Lollll, not your fault, I was pretty off the mark in a lot of ways, I could have dealt with things more constructively and not just been all over the place with my aggression. Things to learn for sure.

[LoneMarkhor]

Scumchat approval thing, OK.

[donkihott]

GG. We were trying to set up for the next day depending on who dies

[muh316]

I'm fine with releasing the scumcat

[muh316]

gg everyone. I had pretty much lost hope for the game after the D1 elim.

[Chumbo]

I'm fine with releasing the mason chat

[borkjerfkin]

gg everyone. I had pretty much lost hope for the game after the D1 elim.

i think this was extremely winnable for scum with some different kills, esp on N1. You'd be surprised what town is willing to be wrong about with the right pushes

[muh316]

Pretty erratic votes, but you didn't vote for Muh or Pickles, pickles scumread you and so did muh but muh's looked like a distancing rather than a real read. Muh was pushing for catboi and yet remained on your wagon which makes me think he wanted someone else to hammer catboi and being on your wagon would clear him (if catboi is town), ppl would've voted me on D2 and you on D3 and muh will win solo

It was at this point where I felt like Town had me and Lone figured out completely. I was very surprised to see Ninetails being a wagon on D2. I guess I was just too paranoid.

[donkihott]

Pretty erratic votes, but you didn't vote for Muh or Pickles, pickles scumread you and so did muh but muh's looked like a distancing rather than a real read. Muh was pushing for catboi and yet remained on your wagon which makes me think he wanted someone else to hammer catboi and being on your wagon would clear him (if catboi is town), ppl would've voted me on D2 and you on D3 and muh will win solo

It was at this point where I felt like Town had me and Lone figured out completely. I was very surprised to see Ninetails being a wagon on D2. I guess I was just too paranoid.

Nah, I knew nothing throughout the game haha

[donkihott]

I'm fine with releasing the mason chat

same

[catboi]

Pretty erratic votes, but you didn't vote for Muh or Pickles, pickles scumread you and so did muh but muh's looked like a distancing rather than a real read. Muh was pushing for catboi and yet remained on your wagon which makes me think he wanted someone else to hammer catboi and being on your wagon would clear him (if catboi is town), ppl would've voted me on D2 and you on D3 and muh will win solo

It was at this point where I felt like Town had me and Lone figured out completely. I was very surprised to see Ninetails being a wagon on D2. I guess I was just too paranoid.

You...probably should have hammered me when you had the chance? IDK why you didn't.

[borkjerfkin]

Mafia PT
Mason PT

[Pickles]

I’m sorry about not remembering to play.
But I’m glad I left my vote on Lone before getting booted for inactivity.
Personally I just don’t think the pace is fast enough here for me.
I truly wish I could play on this site but it never works out.
Anyways wanted to say GG everybody!!

[Battle Mage]

i was very sad i didnt get to play with Chumbo or Donki again.

Scum deserved to lose for being so mean to me.

[borkjerfkin]

I’m sorry about not remembering to play.
But I’m glad I left my vote on Lone before getting booted for inactivity.
Personally I just don’t think the pace is fast enough here for me.
I truly wish I could play on this site but it never works out.
Anyways wanted to say GG everybody!!

you can count this as a completed game if you'd like

[donkihott]

i was very sad i didnt get to play with Chumbo or Donki again.

Scum deserved to lose for being so mean to me.

I wanted to say hi.. :/

[catboi]

iN3krO

- This is a very slight read, but I actually like him saying he's not scumreading anyone in 208. Maybe I'm a sucker who's being baited by a sad face emoticon. I kind of think I don't want to vote him?

NorwegianboyEE

- I think him starting with wanting to policy N_M (27) but backing down in 67 and giving him credit for saying things is probably indicative of a town mindset. Although pushing for a vote on n_m is >rand scum from recent experience, coming out the gates with a policy vote is likely to be unpopular and nlikely to accomplish anything, and the fact that he was willing to re-evaluate suggests he's not pushing it just to push a mislim. I also like him talking about looking at Meuh's previous towngames in 160. His spirited defense of me in 194 is a bit surprising but I can buy it coming from someone with some prior experience with me. I'm all right with calling him a townread at this point.

Pearofclubs

- I will agree toward the general townreads on them, their general approach does feel problem-solvey. Reaction to my early RVS sass was okay, approach looks fine, I can't necessarily point to anything in particular but I like their overall analysis and it doesn't look like newbie scum thoughts.

Of course, I am historically terrible at at reading people who push me, don't take that read to the bank if i die.

Toriiiiiiiiiiii

- largely stand by what I said earlier about not liking their tone in respons to questioning, slight scum read

Not_Mafia

- truth be told, I've not been thrilled by what he's done so far - I know he's typically a player that doesn't do much as either alignment, but the way he outed this reads felt a bit showy, like he wanted to have the appearance of analyzing, but they haven't really moved much and the read on Sama was weak. I think there's a decent chance he could be scum here.

Samawoodo

- His start was slow and I wasn't a fan of how he seemed to be doing a lot of talking without much substance in the way of reads. I like the questioning of Toriii in 112 combined with him stating he was waiting for a followup in 141 though, shows he wasn't asking the question as busywork. The list in 202 doesn't do a ton for me, but the marcistar read is nice, there's a bit of depth to it in how he goes about the analysis - not just looking at simple things, talking about marcistar reacting to a null erad. I think that's enough to call him a town lean right now.

Meuh

- I wasn't a fan of that post asking everyone qusetions and in general I feel like there's a vibe of hanging back to her posts, stuff like 116 118 123 I don't see as advancing the game but more like talking just to talk. The bit about Sama in 162 is interesting although I'm not sure what she means by "positioning". Vote on Tori in 210 is kind of weak, don't townread Torii but this is just using purely gamestate reasoning and nothing in particular about Tori's posts which I don't like - why her over another inactive player?

marcistar

- My first game with her, had her as a fairly strong townread easily but that was because she came under pressure early, here it's a very different game and so my read isn't as strong. I do think 101 is a fairly solve-y post and the way she's tried to prod people to get the game moving is +town but nothing I'd hang my hat on.


Town

Pear
Norwee
Samawoodo

marcistar
in3kro

meuh
toriii
N_M

Scum

None of my scumreads are super strong suspicions, I'd vote any of them but would be least likely to vote Meuh simply because...she's actually posting, and given how slow the game has been I'd rather not vote out someone active on Day 1.