For the record, my reads being literally 50/50 dead-on (nailing Ceph and herc; hard-missing on ABR and Xtoxm) is, objectively, not bad, but I still consider it to be a bit of a poor showing because hard-defending two scum is a worse offense than correctly identifying two scum.
Redemption time?
That would not have worked, as when I am town I am nearly impossible to eliminate and that game was VERY much my towngame.
(Also, hercule is town this game pretty sure.)
In post 15, hercule wrote:also shoutout mastina, you may have thought xtoxm vs. abr was town vs. town but your scumreads on me and Cephrir made you an absolute threat and contributed to my decision to scumcase and push you right before the game was ruined
Eh, see above. Being dead on the money in regards to the two suspected scum is all noble and good and all, but if it's at the cost of being dead-wrong on the other two scum: not worth.
After all, think of what would happen with the obvious: who would buy that I was right on you/Ceph when either ABR or Xtoxm flipped scum? My credibility would've been shot, so all the accuracy in the world on you/Ceph does me no good if nobody will listen, quite justifiably so, due to me being as wrong as can be on ABR and Xtoxm.
Being right on you and Ceph is enough to keep last game from being a complete failure (and me being able to be obvtown there for that matter), but I DO consider hard-defending TWO scum to be a failure. (Hard-defending one scum and pushing two scum is acceptable for D1, with future days refining the reads to hopefully correctly identify having been pocketed by the one scum. Hard-defending two scum is not acceptable on D1, not even if the other two scum are who I'm scumreading hardest.)
(For the record, with hercule being town here, yes, I am indeed theorycrafting searching for a new scumteam to see who's still town and who's still scum. Still working on it.)
In post 52, OkaPoka wrote:is it wrong that i just wanna vibe this game since my team already lost black flag
I mean, technically, yes, but honestly I get that the same given my team also lost in that game.
But, I justify continuing to effort on the grounds of, 1: I am a replacement who's glad to even be a part of TM 2021 at all, 2: I wanna play the game anyway, 3: I want the bragging rights, 4: I want the redemption, 5: I wanna look good to what amounts to a huge amount of the collective mafiascum community, 6: I feel obligated to try, and 7: losing one scumgame doesn't mean the team is out of the running anyway since unless a team goes 4-0, a 3-1 is still winnable.
In post 16, Hopkirk wrote:Albert B Rampage
- He did some highly questionable stuff in a game i played in recently. Don't really want to go through that again
Town.
Town?
ABR and Xtoxm are town.
(But actually, I'm not scumreading anyone who's posted as of the beginning of page 3. So I get where you're coming from.)
In post 85, innocentvillager wrote:can mastina pls solve the game already? that way we can quick-elim her scumreads and anyone she inexplicably hard townreads
The problem is, I'm townreading all of you, Hopkirk, and Oka, and you three are pretty much the only three to have posted aside from hercule who I also townread, since page one. (The only other poster, Ythan, is neither town nor scum to me yet, still trying to get a lock there.)
In post 90, hercule wrote:wheres DGB i'm rly excited to play with them this game they were cracking me up. i was legit so flustered trying to figure out if they were being serious or not with their reads on me
Hot shitposty take: the scumteam is Xtoxm, DGB, LLD, and then one of {Titus, Dann, tw, jjh, Dunn} due to none of them posting so soon yet all confirmations being in.
