Raw, Unfiltered, UPICK Game Over !

[Gamma Emerald]

Fidget is being replaced.

[Mistyx]

*@GrayICE*

you said you saw a town tell from 15's first post. What was it?

NK15 scumread Vax for role hunting without even mentioning a third party possibility. If NK15 was mafia-scum and Vax was not mafia-scum, that means he scumhunted Vax without mentioning the only actual possibility that Vax was scum - despite rolefishing being a good scum tell of both the mafia and third party variety. Very high likelihood of coming from town.

why do you think he can't have just lied about thinking vax was scum?

[Mistyx]

also, it's entirely possible that not known has tmi that there isn't a 3p

first one to figure out how gets some points

not town points, but i'll be impressed regardless :P

[Mistyx]

Lol, are you always this abrasive? :P

Oh god no. I'm super chill nowadays.

Wouldn't mind having a genuine discussion about things with you though, seeing your thought process.

PEdit:

Scum are trying to mimic basic scumhunting, yes? Also, scum tend to make posts as genuine and honest as possible to mimic their town selves, therefore most scum who attempt to post scumhunting are engaging in scumhunting - something they have far more experience with than playing as town. As you said, rolefishing is a really scummy thing for town to do. Now if NK15 is mafia, he'd know if Vax was mafia. Lets say NK is mafia, and Vax is not-mafia, and he notes that Vax is rolefishing, which is something scum do. How could Vax be scum and yet not be mafia?

why do you think he can't have been jumping on something from someone who isn't mafia that he thought looked scummy?

or maybe if he was scum, he was making a legitimate scumread, and just didn't bring up the third party concept?

[MathBlade]

*@GrayICE*

you said you saw a town tell from 15's first post. What was it?

NK15 scumread Vax for role hunting without even mentioning a third party possibility. If NK15 was mafia-scum and Vax was not mafia-scum, that means he scumhunted Vax without mentioning the only actual possibility that Vax was scum - despite rolefishing being a good scum tell of both the mafia and third party variety. Very high likelihood of coming from town.

why do you think he can't have just lied about thinking vax was scum?

Town can rolehunt in some circumstances. I did it recently in Yellowstone. It depends.

And I don’t think group scum would be blatant here.

Grey ICE also put in a lot of assumptions. Combining that with GreyICE’s earlier posts and asking me if I am 3P makes the NK point blank and probably a TMI defense or a scum buddy one.

[Vaxkiller]

Mistx has ascended. Welcome to god-hood. You are now perma town.

[MathBlade]

Mistx has ascended. Welcome to god-hood. You are now perma town.

I can go with a you, Me, Mistyx block.

[Vaxkiller]

Mistx has ascended. Welcome to god-hood. You are now perma town.

I can go with a you, Me, Mistyx block.

Why are you town reading me?

[MathBlade]

Initially it’s because your flavor was outed in the OP.
Then you’ve been doing things that I think I know why for but is bad to say.

I don’t think scum open with their flavor revealed.

[Vaxkiller]

Why did you scum read me, and how did that change back?

[MathBlade]

I meant grey. I want his role.

Uhm again? No.

Mass claim on D1 is stupid and if you want his role scum case him and get a wagon going?

My townread of you is hitting the shitter

Because you weren’t listening to the tiny pieces of argument I was leaving.

Cookie?

[Grendel]

If i was scum and these were my buddies you think its likely was as a whole would join the same wagon on mark?

^^ This sentence doesn’t make grammatical sense. I don’t know what you’re asking here.

when you were catching up you were pushing a team of Uncrowned, Not 15, and I. It was weird b/c you were citing us all being on marky mark togather as reason for the team. Usally mafiaso's diversify their stances as much as possible. You disagree with that?

*@Math*

what reasons did you have for town reading Marky mark beyond wagons analysis? Is it gut?

im not sure what my read on him is currently

I have played with Marky Mark recently and this seems like his town game from Yellowstone. There is a bit of gut but more a meta read. I also dislike your “anyone who scumreads Mark I scumread” assertion. People can disagree with me and be town. That’s slimy.

I kinda think Jessee Grendel is a thing. I don’t like how people are just sheeping. Grey ICE seems town but others actions around him may make him scum. Kinda thinking Jessee Grendel Uncrowned and maybe Grey?

You can walk me though your meta read on Marky if you want.

Well who out of the players that have had a scum read mark are within your TRs then?

[Grendel]

I think that being possessive over the game state D1 like GreyICE has been is generally a townie trait.

Math is similar, tho i do do see potential ulterior motives for where they are going with things.

What's the difference between the two slots in this sense from your POV?

They way Math is handling my slot is weird. I feel like it could come from a pro-scum source.

Whereas i think the possiveivness from Gray seems unlikely to have an agenda rn. He looks like town doing his own thing.

What are your current thoughts on math?

[Vaxkiller]

I dont see the tiny pieces. I was only asking for greys role, not a mass claim.

You dont have a post restriction about pretending to be a dog.

I gotta think about all this.

[MathBlade]

Not much time, so just skimmed the thread. Grendel seems towny.

Kinda wondering if Grendel, Uncrowned, and Not Known know where all the bones are.

Just more of a gut vibe. The post seemed off and I was scum reading you and the only think 15 said was a pop in and you were Townie despite outing what you thought was a PR.

Sometimes scum clump up and sometimes they don’t. VCA is meant to be done in a “at least” manner not a “Max X” manner. I like to get vibes and put my ear to the ground and get vibes so to speak and see what pops at me.

[MathBlade]

If i was scum and these were my buddies you think its likely was as a whole would join the same wagon on mark?

^^ This sentence doesn’t make grammatical sense. I don’t know what you’re asking here.

when you were catching up you were pushing a team of Uncrowned, Not 15, and I. It was weird b/c you were citing us all being on marky mark togather as reason for the team. Usally mafiaso's diversify their stances as much as possible. You disagree with that?

*@Math*

what reasons did you have for town reading Marky mark beyond wagons analysis? Is it gut?

im not sure what my read on him is currently

I have played with Marky Mark recently and this seems like his town game from Yellowstone. There is a bit of gut but more a meta read. I also dislike your “anyone who scumreads Mark I scumread” assertion. People can disagree with me and be town. That’s slimy.

I kinda think Jessee Grendel is a thing. I don’t like how people are just sheeping. Grey ICE seems town but others actions around him may make him scum. Kinda thinking Jessee Grendel Uncrowned and maybe Grey?

You can walk me though your meta read on Marky if you want.

Well who out of the players that have had a scum read mark are within your TRs then?

I am horrible at explaining meta but I would refer you to Yellow stone and look for differences. I don’t see any.

And to answer your question about TRs none.

I am betting I am dead by D2 so just sort of trying to build a town block and make sure communication happens. Then people can go back and look at why I said I thought Grey ICE scum claimed and he can be D2 if no one believes me. I am not going to push a read more so just trying to ensure a good foundation after I am dead.

[chkflip]

sanctimonious fart sucking

Come on, man. That's maybe eh-too far, no?

I'm trying and failing to get into this game, I truly am, the restriction is fun, the player list is good (and got better with replacements!) but for me to sit here exhausted af and try to do something with what y'all are giving me... eh. I just don't have it in me at this current moment. I'm not talking about replacing out so don't shoot down a rabbit hole that doesn't need shooting. Idk, eet just isn't clicking today.

My bad, y'all.

[MathBlade]

sanctimonious fart sucking

Come on, man. That's maybe eh-too far, no?

I'm trying and failing to get into this game, I truly am, the restriction is fun, the player list is good (and got better with replacements!) but for me to sit here exhausted af and try to do something with what y'all are giving me... eh. I just don't have it in me at this current moment. I'm not talking about replacing out so don't shoot down a rabbit hole that doesn't need shooting. Idk, eet just isn't clicking today.

My bad, y'all.

**snuggles next to chkflip**

Meme? Would a meme make you happier?

Sometimes I feel like this:



Not sure if that’s today though or not

[Grendel]

@Math

Well if I can ill check out yellowstone.

Why did you use "slimy" as a descriptive of my play multiple times?

Yes i do have a reason for asking that

[Grendel]

Mistx has ascended. Welcome to god-hood. You are now perma town.

Mistx has ascended. Welcome to god-hood. You are now perma town.

I can go with a you, Me, Mistyx block.

Sorry if im missing something obvious, but why is Mistx town?

[MathBlade]

@Math

Well if I can ill check out yellowstone.

Why did you use "slimy" as a descriptive of my play multiple times?

Yes i do have a reason for asking that

That’s the word I could think of at the moment and I was watching a dog video where the dog had a chew toy in its mouth and was slobbering everywhere? Certain things seem slimy/scummy so I guess that?

[MathBlade]

Mistx has ascended. Welcome to god-hood. You are now perma town.

Mistx has ascended. Welcome to god-hood. You are now perma town.

I can go with a you, Me, Mistyx block.

Sorry if im missing something obvious, but why is Mistx town?

Those posts really pinged me as town that Misty went further than the introductory level.
I can’t speak for if Vax saw the same but I am pretty sure MistyX is town.

[Grendel]

@Math

Well if I can ill check out yellowstone.

Why did you use "slimy" as a descriptive of my play multiple times?

Yes i do have a reason for asking that

That’s the word I could think of at the moment and I was watching a dog video where the dog had a chew toy in its mouth and was slobbering everywhere? Certain things seem slimy/scummy so I guess that?

Ehh, maybe you're just town, and i am being paranoid.

I used to have an old scum tell relating to types of negative adjectives I saw scum using to spin their cases. I went to look at some of my old games, and i nearly died from the pretentiousness of 2016 me. I'll just assume I didnt know what i was talking about.

-/-/-/-

I read those posts and im not really feeling convinced on mistx's alignment yet.

[MathBlade]

Who would you town block if 3 people at least?
Same with a scum block?

Explanation or not up to you.

[Jesse Pierce]

Who would you town block if 3 people at least?
Same with a scum block?

Explanation or not up to you.

I want to