In post 232, ItalianoVD wrote:Post
98 could be viewed as you trying to defend me fmpov or at the very least interfering with a player trying to sort a slot, which is just as bad. The same can be said for
138 since it piggybacked from
98. Then
141, then in
143 you said
“Italiano himself later explained there is no correlation in post
108 which to me read like you were defending me again, using my posts to help your argument. You mentioned me again in
166, again to help solidify your argument. Then again in
167 to justify your push onto Green. For someone not defending someone it sure seems like you are.
In post 201, Duchess wrote:I'm surprised that even from your point of view
you are clinging to GC's false characterization of my push as a defense.
Why would you be surprised at someone else’s point of view? The (bolded) here is just wrong and not at all what I’m doing.
In post 201, Duchess wrote:Your vantage point should make it abundantly clear that I have done absolutely nothing to defend your words or justify your actions.
See above.
In post 201, Duchess wrote:So I'm curious about precisely where you are getting the feeling that I am stepping up to bat for you rather than attacking a scumread.
See above.
In post 201, Duchess wrote:This early in the game, I know nothing. Nobody knows anything, except for scum.
I don’t know, you seemed pretty confident in your read, you even said so at the end of this post.
In post 201, Duchess wrote:So if X looks to be setting up a scumpush against Y, I don't think for a damn second about what my read of Y is, because I have no reason to be so sure of anything that I would let those first impressions and assumptions of Y dictate my assessment of situation X.
My question is if I was a FoS, why would you be against a scum push onto me. Green would have been bussing me from your perspective, so what would it matter? For me it seems like you would’ve only done what you did if I was a townlean, otherwise you would have called out the theatre, (which would’ve been weak), but at least it’d be consistent.
In post 201, Duchess wrote: In post 169, ItalianoVD wrote:I gotta say I'm not at all comfortable being in the middle of this Duchess/Green Crayons thing, lol. Like yikes, I don't like what I say to be a basis to read someone else off when it wasn't my intention to do so. If this is theatre please choose something else to fight over and leave me out of it and if you're town then just drop it, it's not that serious.
Can you elaborate on how exactly it makes you uncomfortable and why?
Why is it either theatre or town vs town?
I’ve explained why it makes me feel uncomfortable both in
169 and this post. And the thought crossed my mind that it was theatre because I didn’t feel like it was a real argument and had no real footing, but then I thought that maybe the communication is just that bad between you too, either way I wanted both of you to stop talking about it. And since it involved me I had the audacity to say so.
In post 201, Duchess wrote:
So what? I'm not pushing GC for your benefit and I don't need your blessings or permission.
Well as I said since it involves me so I have the right to nip it in the bud.
In post 201, Duchess wrote:
This is a very strange question. I'm pushing a scumread, which is what you do in the game of mafia. I'll be either right or wrong in the end, but for now I'm quite confident.
Im asking under the mindset that you are defending me and I’m saying you’re push is not a good one because it’s being pushed under a false pretense.