In post 3619, Batsunami wrote:Town:
Me and morning
Pink Ball
(Fey if she were not a paranoia null)
Dunnstral
Italiano
War and Peace
5uffering
Gamma
Null:
Fey(I admit this probably should be a TR but her last post telling me my reads were batshit basically made my paranoia levels skyrocket. tho I'd like to think she wouldn't say something like that as town, I am not certain)
Morty and Rick
SaraharaS
Scum:
Pyro
Starcrossed
Red Eye Knights
Toog
Clidd
I'm going to quickly go through the major changes.
I've moved Dunnstral up a noticeable amount mainly just because I am no longer SRing him. I'm not sure what was happening at the beginning of the game but after giving this some thought, it feels to me like what happened was a very very small play style clash. What it feels like is that I've "gotten used" to it now and it no longer feels scummy. Which this could just be an indicator that Dunn purposefully changed his play or I am just not familiar with it and found it scummy when there really was nothing there. Combined with Morning's TR on him since a long time ago, I have decided to let go of that SR and move him up.
Italiano is a pretty big MEH for me. I've played with him once and I found him to be the towniest person on the planet in that game but he was scum. In that game, I caught scum shelly on page 7 and then she repped out and Italiano repped in. I remember having such conflicting thoughts at the time because I have a very high accuracy rate on reading shelly. I've read her wrong once but because I thought I solved the game elsewhere so kind of just ignored her. But when Italiano repped in I was like FUCK HE'S SO TOWNY DID I READ SHELLY WRONG? Thankfully town pushed him through for me which probably means he didnt come off that towny to them but he came off very towny to me so I take the fact that I nullread him here as a sign that he is town.
Suffering is in my town reads almost completely because of the claim. I don't have a strong read on them anyway but I don't think that is the optimal lim today and I also think that nothing they have done pings scum that hard. Suffering has kinda just been a comfort SR since the moment they entered the thread. They seem so easy to SR for weak reasons and that makes me think they're town.
Gamma is weaker town than Suffering and if one of my TRs was wrong, it'd be this one I think. Idk why I'm putting gamma up here tbh he probably deserves a spot in null but eh. He's pretty eh and i have no idea how to read him so yay.
Moved Sarahara up just because she dipped from thread and so her SR faded a bit.
Pyro moved up because Morning keeps saying he's town so its whatever. I could be wrong.
Starcrossed just feels like a scumbag and idk what else to say. Morning seems to agree as well last I checked so that checks out. Scummy as hell but could be town anyways cuz fuck my reads. I'm not that strong on this read or the Pyro read(anymore ofc)
Aristo isn't doing anything and it's weird. I've played one game with him and I remember thinking him very scummy because it felt like he had an agenda. I think that Aristo does give off that kind of vibe that feels very scummy as town. It's not really scummy in the sense that he seems informed but he just constantly seems to be thinking and almost plotting. I think that comes from the fact that he is an old player
(mafia age) so he is constantly thinking and that comes out on my end as plotting. The thing is that I don't see that here. I don't really SR him surface level wise but he's missing that one puzzle piece and it doesn't feel right. The only way I can explain it is he might be a vt or scum. I mean he was a pr in that one game so that could also influence this feeling that he gives off. I know not much about Akarin but supposedly they are good at being town and love being town. But ... I've seen their shadow maybe two times this game and that's a bit concerning.
Toog and Clidds silent refusal to ever engage me about my SR on them is scum indicative all the way. These are two towny players that will take the reins of any game and lead town to victory. The way they do it is not be cowering in the corner and not replying to obvtown's SRs on them.
