Newbie 2055: City Lights [game over!]

[Datisi]

Vote count 2.02

with 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to make a decision. day 2 ends in (expired on 2021-03-06 01:45:00).

elimination

KittyTacky [2]:

Battle Mage, Vasex

floo [1]:

KittyTacky

Not voting [4]:

floo, FBJim, Happy Unbirthday Boon, team rocket queen

mod notes

~ battle mage v/la until monday
~ don't drink too much coffee, kids

flavour

[Vasex]

Why floo became so townie? Because of the voice of Kitty and his suspicion to floo all the time? This is not a strong argument.

[Vasex]

HUB, TRQ - Scumleans (1 scum here)

I disagree with that. Pretty sure

[Vasex]

I am waiting the opportunity to hammer floo

[Battle Mage]

Why floo became so townie? Because of the voice of Kitty and his suspicion to floo all the time? This is not a strong argument.

yeah my gut is floo is town. i don't currently care what you think about my argument. At the moment my point is simple - I think Floo is town, and so I'm not voting Floo. You disagree, and that's fine too. My suggestion remains that we don't discount the possibility of Floo being scum, but elim someone more likely today.

I think:

Elim KittyTacky
If scum, we have 2 dayphases to get the last scum. also people will get NKed and narrow the pool. and we'll have more info on associations to inform our reads on the 2nd scum.
If town, like it was probably inevitable anyway, and we'll duke it out tomorrow on the contentious reads, still with more info than today.

[Battle Mage]

I am waiting the opportunity to hammer floo

i think this is folly. if you're town, can we actually work together on our consensus scumread today?

[team rocket queen]

i think you're working under the misconception that it's null because i have no opinion. in fact, i do have plenty of opinions but the pro's broadly balanced against the con's. I don't think you're covering yourself in glory so far today, although i value the engagement.

i wasn't working under any conception because there was no explanation previously beyond, 'null'

what are some of those pros and cons

still waiting on this

[Vasex]

We will listen everybody.
I'm going to sleep now.

[Vasex]

I mean my hammer can wait for some time)

[team rocket queen]

currently thinking both mafia in {battlemage, floo, kittytacky}

[Vasex]

I didn't like Kitty's posts today very much. Especially the last one, and I'm waiting the answer to my question to him.

[team rocket queen]

I didn't like Kitty's posts today very much. Especially the last one, and I'm waiting the answer to my question to him.

haven't liked kittytacky's posts today; haven't liked battlemage's view of the game, felt like possibly assigning battlemage's intentions with regards to shading to me,

[team rocket queen]

felt like possibly assigning battlemage's intentions with regards to shading to me,

like battlemage was doing this to me and preemptively said i was doing it

[Vasex]

Jessie, can HUB be mafia scum in this game?

[team rocket queen]

Jessie, can HUB be mafia scum in this game?

yes, like it depends how claims play out, and it is worth considering if we should mass claim right now,

but i'm still leaning town there

[team rocket queen]

battlemage's best posts to me were probably the one about openwolfing and the followup,

[Vasex]

He is too relaxed for mafia scum in my opinion, I have a good eye on such things. But the lack of experience in new format and with new people and in the new language can have some influence on my view... Right now TRQ is more townie for me than HUB just because she talked a lot after the night, but this is only the beginning, we have plenty of time

[Vasex]

He is too relaxed

HUB

[team rocket queen]

battlemage's view of the game

it also feels very like, concrete? not mobile? like it is now stated the same as at daystart and that does not feel like battlemage is considering what is happening?

[team rocket queen]

He is too relaxed for mafia scum in my opinion, I have a good eye on such things. But the lack of experience in new format and with new people and in the new language can have some influence on my view

happy unbirthday boon is a very experienced player, far beyond the games on that account alone, but the approach and everything it feels very similar to a game we played together when i was a newbie,

[Vasex]

it also feels very like, concrete? not mobile? like it is now stated the same as at daystart and that does not feel like battlemage is considering what is happening?

I have the same thoughts. But he could read everything before talking. But yeah some of his sureness is rather unreasonable and it is hard to understand or check. I feel that I need to read this guy in previous games, but I'm not sure that it will be very helpful.
But he tries to hang Kitty, who is rather bad, so he doesn't try to do that with HUB or you, and it suits me for now.

[Vasex]

My position right now:
TRQ and HUB townies.
FBJim and Battle Mag - maybe only 1 of them can be scum, but mostly townies.
Kitty and Floo - most probable scums for me for now.
Everything can change after good talking from any of them

[Vasex]

Though... If Kitty is mafia, HUB has some problems, because if I'm not mistaking he defended him the whole first day. He was ready to play fast with Russians, though in my opinion Kitty wasn't enough in the thread to judge him enough. And even tried to defend Kitty from FBJim in the end.
Something like that Battle Mag is now doing with Floo.

[Vasex]

But HUB gives roles (sides) to everybody much faster and easy, than anybody, and this is usually more townie, than mafia style. For experienced players

[Vasex]

So he tries to guess ASAP, to know the true first.

Mafia usually tries to save the opportunity to hang anybody in any circumstances, that's why it is harder for mafia to find many townies fast.

Ok ok I go sleeping.