Mini Normal 2200 | Game Over

[PenguinPower]

Boop

[Chara]

i see. i guess it's moot, since the important point would be Day's impression of your scum meta and whether or not it's applicable here. do you think you've been out of your range?

pedit: validation! also, i'm sorry to hear that.

[Chara]

If the team is exactly chara-lucy-farkran I probably have the same level of fun here I guess but like that kind of thing is what it'd take.

i'd cry, please.

[skitter30]

maybe i was wrong on lucy

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Pooky thats a scum trait for me how?

I think town!you cares less.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Like yes I have trouble engaging in day 1s as of recently. Most day 1s I’m low participation

but we had so much fun in SFA D1 <3

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

That's the only time you've played with me when I'm scum so why are you saying I like to play scum?

I modded a game where you were scum

My impression of your scum play mostly comes from Your Nightmare.

I think you would be extremely happy to be scum with people that you like.

And many people here are your friends.

I'd find it hard to say who you would not enjoy being scum with in this PL.

[Chara]

maybe i was wrong on lucy

what's changing your mind?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

also SS3 was really not very balanced well for the scum team at all and I could see why a player would not enjoy playing scum in that setup - so I don't really think it's fair to apply how you treated that game to say a normal mafia game.

[skitter30]

maybe i was wrong on lucy

what's changing your mind?

her every post doesn't feel like 'ugh i utterly hate posting' now that she's posting like in a 'normal' way for her
she has this vibe that she hates posting when she's scum

also SS3 was really not very balanced well for the scum team at all and I could see why a player would not enjoy playing scum in that setup - so I don't really think it's fair to apply how you treated that game to say a normal mafia game.

this is true

[Alisae]

Pooky thats a scum trait for me how?

I think town!you cares less.

BASED OFF OF WHAT POOKY

[Alisae]

Like yes I have trouble engaging in day 1s as of recently. Most day 1s I’m low participation

but we had so much fun in SFA D1 <3

this is about the same participation as SFA and Among Us man :/

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

nah in SFA you were much more present and your readslist was fire.


like town players have less pressure than mafia players because they can just blurt out any bullshit they want and its not like they're worried about getting caught

scum have to actually think and stuff.

i dunno i just think scum!you thinks a lot more about what you say than town!you I guess?

[skitter30]

i kinda think ali is town too tbh
this is more of a gutread than anything substantive i can particularly point to

~
pooky i'm lowky starting to become paranoid of you
i'm not sure i really want the thread to become about that per se rn but i'm making note of it

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

awww

we were doing so well together darling <3

I think it was inevitable you'd eventually get paranoid pings.

I blame that first dance we had.

[Chara]

my thing is i don't really think Lucy has been having

that

much fun, she had her gimmick and obviously did enjoy using it, but i don't know if that would have anything to do with her alignment as opposed to just using a gimmick she planned to do with the alt, anyway. as for post-reveal Lucy, she seems fine and that she is having a nice enough time. but i do only have that nightmare game to compare her to, and i haven't seen town Isis, so i don't have a good baseline. i'm just assuming that scum Isis is probably able to also have a fairly nice time even if she's very upset in the scum thread, or what have you.

i went back over 2135, and i'd have to say i also townread Luca very strongly, not sure if it was around the time of that post but it was an earlier read i'm still happy with.

some clarification:
"instinctively I wanted to be transparent about how my thought process compared and contrasted with Luca's. If Luca suddenly dropped support, I'd have more to explain on my own progression, skitter doesn't."
what does this have to do with skitter? it's not my impression that you two have very similar playstyles.

[Chara]

her every post doesn't feel like 'ugh i utterly hate posting' now that she's posting like in a 'normal' way for her
she has this vibe that she hates posting when she's scum

i'll have to take your word for it.

[Chara]

do you have a read on me yet, Pooky?

[skitter30]

yeah sorry i don't fully know how to divorce the meta from things that are happening in a particular game

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

do you have a read on me yet, Pooky?

not yet!

I haven't really been paying attention to you at all sorry

[Chara]

it's fine, i don't think it can be avoided.

pedit: it's okay <3 i said as much to you earlier. how about a read on Norwee?

[LegoLucy]

my thing is i don't really think Lucy has been having

that

much fun, she had her gimmick and obviously did enjoy using it, but i don't know if that would have anything to do with her alignment as opposed to just using a gimmick she planned to do with the alt, anyway. as for post-reveal Lucy, she seems fine and that she is having a nice enough time. but i do only have that nightmare game to compare her to, and i haven't seen town Isis, so i don't have a good baseline. i'm just assuming that scum Isis is probably able to also have a fairly nice time even if she's very upset in the scum thread, or what have you.

i went back over 2135, and i'd have to say i also townread Luca very strongly, not sure if it was around the time of that post but it was an earlier read i'm still happy with.

some clarification:
"instinctively I wanted to be transparent about how my thought process compared and contrasted with Luca's. If Luca suddenly dropped support, I'd have more to explain on my own progression, skitter doesn't."
what does this have to do with skitter? it's not my impression that you two have very similar playstyles.

Regardless of whether her playstyle matches enough to add reasoning to her votes (which is just like, playing good) I explained how there's a scum motivated benefit there potentially.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

it's fine, i don't think it can be avoided.

pedit: it's okay <3 i said as much to you earlier. how about a read on Norwee?

I have norwee at obvtown :3

[PenguinPower]

Norwee is probably the towniest person i don’t

want

to be town. Yes.

[Chara]

Regardless of whether her playstyle matches enough to add reasoning to her votes (which is just like, playing good) I explained how there's a scum motivated benefit there potentially.

that's regarding the hedginess, open-ended interactions, etc.?