Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[Alisae]

I think this just goes to show that these things really do need to be hashed out during the review process.

This I agree with.

I was a bit lax having not modded much and was a bit anal over the wrong things.

So again that falls on me as backup mod.

Sorry.

Don't think its anyone's fault in particular. I think people in general has just gotten a bit more lazier when it comes to these things.

[Alisae]

ah well, people saw!

gg everyone!

Were you Morty or Rick?

Ya Ydra was Morty and Rick

[Pyro]

Knew it

[Ydrasse]

caught red handed...

[Titus]

We should have won this game if not for the toxic townfirms. We lost two elims in Koba's slot and Pink Ball's slot. If we get those back, we win. That naturally demotivated my scumteam.

To the rest of the town and scum, gg.

I think the replacements were pretty bad and I think we need a better solution site wide.

Hands were tied due to site rules.

Do you have a suggestion?

I don't. I would have declared them tactical replaceouts but that would have wrecked the game in favor of scum too far. It was a lose-lose situation.

We got punished for me doing my job as scum and that sucks to my mates.

[Ydrasse]

are we allowed to join the mason discord to read it?

[Alisae]

are we allowed to join the mason discord to read it?

ah shit
mafia discord i upright deleted cuz nothing was there
but mason discord math has to post an invite link to I already left it and thought the one in the masonry already was permanent.

[MathBlade]

I will post it after work. I only have discord on my phone during work hours and I try to avoid using discord while working unless I get pinged a lot.

[Alisae]

I mean anyone who was in it can post an invite link idc who does it tbh

[MathBlade]

We should have won this game if not for the toxic townfirms. We lost two elims in Koba's slot and Pink Ball's slot. If we get those back, we win. That naturally demotivated my scumteam.

To the rest of the town and scum, gg.

I think the replacements were pretty bad and I think we need a better solution site wide.

Hands were tied due to site rules.

Do you have a suggestion?

I don't. I would have declared them tactical replaceouts but that would have wrecked the game in favor of scum too far. It was a lose-lose situation.

We got punished for me doing my job as scum and that sucks to my mates.

I promise I will think of a suggestion for list mods at some point.

I agree with you that was a problem I couldn’t fix.

It’s why I tried being empathetic as I could within limits and phrased things.

I think towards the end some of your mech play kinda slipped but that’s probably due to reasons.

Dunn was pretty clutch at the end.

[clidd]

Nice hammer, Pb.

I'm glad we won and no paranoia about scum!Morning, scum!Pyro or scum!Pb scenario has come true.

Quite a pleasurable hemorrhagic experience, I would say.

I had to put a lot of effort to ignore what I felt was pocketing from you 'cause you made no sense as scum

I think that any kind of suspicion of my slot would be healthy considering the way I played this game.

But I’m glad you was flexible with me.

[clidd]

Spoiler:

oops

sorry guys, pyro especially.... i'm glad my clidd read was right though!

pleasure playing with you all and thanks to ali for modding <3

~mistuha

I would be a corpse if it weren't for your read, thanks. I owe you one.

[Ydrasse]

sorry for the push clidd, my paranoia was s t r o n g.

[clidd]

sorry for the push clidd, my paranoia was s t r o n g.

It's fine, as I said, those suspicions were conceptually justified by the approach I took here.

I would probably do the same.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Yay we won woohoo

Thanks for being awesome fam! ~.~


Thanks for Modding Ali! <3

[Aristophanes]

Ydrasse, I'm pretty sure we figured out who you were like early in your posting anyway XD

Not that I saw any slip, but I knew you were here

[Nancy Drew 39]

Actions
--
D1
Fey Skips the night
--
N2
Dunn Busdrives War and Peace and Rick and Morty
Kidamn Rolestops Rick and Morty
MT Messages Starcrossed
Mafia shoots War and Peace
Nancy shoots Sherlock and Watson
Koba checks War and Peace
War and Peace checks Red Eye Knights
--
N3
Dun busdrives Red Eye Knights and Toogeloo
MT messages someone I forget who KEKW
Mafia shoot Toogeloo
Koba checks Red Eye Knights*
--
N4
Dunn busdrives Kidamn and Koba
KidAmn rolestops Dunnstral
MT messages Sara
Dunn shoots Kidamn
Koba checks Pink Ball
--
from N5 and onward it goes
MT Messages someone
Mafia shoots someone

Yep modding

Wow, so why didn’t Sarah respond to Tweetie’s message then?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Koba's result was based on Math giving War and Peace information on how to fakeclaim Gunsmith with their results and they included the name of the target in their post. I went with this since this sets precedent for Koba's result which is why they got Toogeloo specifically mentioned in their result.

I probably modded this poorly but luckily MathBlade is a based co-mod and this might have fallen apart if not for them, idunno.

I didn't read the game but I know that these setups shouldn't have masons anymore and I highly suggest that they shouldn't for anyone who wants to run this style of game. It makes gameplay awful.

But the masonry is hands down the best part of the game, it’s my favourite town role.

[MathBlade]

Random note thanks to Cabd who linked me to a discord exporter and I will be putting that here for longevity after work.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I was townreading you after your Dunn case, Pyro, but I needed to be sure in case it was clidd and I had to choose in LyLo. Good job not only becoming obvtown so close to LyLo, but also being right before even getting there.

Happpy for you Nancy, and for being able to contribute to this win!

You replacing an aggravating slot towntelling on their way out was the best part. <3

[SaraharaS]

good job town and especially Pyro for hard pushing like 3 of the scum! i don't agree that i'd have been TRing W&P during the earlier readslist, but my bussing without scumreading them first was uh... pretty dumb. like scumslip levels of dumb...

Titus suggested not responding to MT's thing so i followed that because i wasn't super paying attention to that stuff
The replace outs were annoying - especially Saudade's
That vig shoot was a good gamewinning shot. Nice decision.

sadly the masonary existing made me hate pretty much every minute of this game, just like i was expecting
i'm definitely not getting tricked into playing another one of these while there's masons around (whether or not they actually mattered, because i agree with everything i said about incentives/following the stump)
and ESPECIALLY not when there are super mean sadists like Titus forcing you to roll scum

[MathBlade]

good job town and especially Pyro for hard pushing like 3 of the scum! i don't agree that i'd have been TRing W&P during the earlier readslist, but my bussing without scumreading them first was uh... pretty dumb. like scumslip levels of dumb...

Titus suggested not responding to MT's thing so i followed that because i wasn't super paying attention to that stuff
The replace outs were annoying - especially Saudade's
That vig shoot was a good gamewinning shot. Nice decision.

sadly the masonary existing made me hate pretty much every minute of this game, just like i was expecting
i'm definitely not getting tricked into playing another one of these while there's masons around (whether or not they actually mattered, because i agree with everything i said about incentives/following the stump)
and ESPECIALLY not when there are super mean sadists like Titus forcing you to roll scum

Yeah I think masons in this setup isn’t viable
Quite honestly I would love to see it be draft and lurk stumps just join obs thread.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I love making powers subvert expectations.

There was a chance Nancy got a fake guilty if she woulda hit rolestopped town. That woulda been wowza.

How? I had a strongwilled disloyal vigshot? It bypasses everything including rolestopper and especially bus drivers. Strongwilled means nothing can bypass it no?

[Alisae]

Koba's result was based on Math giving War and Peace information on how to fakeclaim Gunsmith with their results and they included the name of the target in their post. I went with this since this sets precedent for Koba's result which is why they got Toogeloo specifically mentioned in their result.

I probably modded this poorly but luckily MathBlade is a based co-mod and this might have fallen apart if not for them, idunno.

I didn't read the game but I know that these setups shouldn't have masons anymore and I highly suggest that they shouldn't for anyone who wants to run this style of game. It makes gameplay awful.

But the masonry is hands down the best part of the game, it’s my favourite town role.

but what about for the people who aren't masons and are mafia

[Nancy Drew 39]

And this is truly the best readlist in the game (6975), lol.

even when i havent even replaced into the game yet i get mistakenly PoE'd .... I hate it here.

It wasn’t you, your predecessor played really scummy.