Open 807 | Town Win

[Salsabil Faria]

ok the plot of this game is now too hard for me to write up because it's wandered outside the boundaries of the believable but I'm gonna try anyway

If you're a town, then I request you to not do any elimination today. Let's see what the scum will do on the night.

[Something_Smart]

Salsa, what makes you think that A50 is main scum, rather than traitor?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

why does it even matter

[Something_Smart]

Well, because that seems like a rather weird opinion to have, and understanding why might shed some light on the veracity of it.

[Scipio1]

i think it's pooky/salsa in some order

[Scipio1]

what were the dumbtells that cleared salsa d2 again, i forgot

[Salsabil Faria]

Salsa, what makes you think that A50 is main scum, rather than traitor?

I way he is building his case against me + if the scum team didn't take any PR role, which means the traitor isn't recruited, and I have a feeling that the traitor is hiding purposely ( ) + gut feeling is saying he isn't the traitor.

[Salsabil Faria]

Well, because that seems like a rather weird opinion to have, and understanding why might shed some light on the veracity of it.

Why it is weird?

[Scipio1]

a50 is probably just town; he's spewed non w/w with both pooky and salsa and he was on the implo wagon for a good chunk of d2. I suppose he could be paired with s_s but I don't think he pulls this crap in MYLO as scum anyways so yeah

[Salsabil Faria]

i think it's pooky/salsa in some order

[Scipio1]

wtf do you mean by "the traitor is hiding purposely" isn't that like... the point of the game???

[Scipio1]

s_s who do you think is scum

[Something_Smart]

Why it is weird?

It's weird because the traitor is the only one who knows the full scumteam so it makes sense that the traitor would try to push harder than the regular mafia since the traitor knows they aren't pushing on their partner.

Why do you think the traitor is hiding purposely? What does your gut say would be different if he were the traitor?

[Something_Smart]

s_s who do you think is scum

Neither Salsa nor A50 are making a lot of sense to me right now. I think I would favor Salsa being scum because A50 is known not to make sense as town, and he was on the Artemiana wagon besides.

[Salsabil Faria]

wtf do you mean by "the traitor is hiding purposely" isn't that like... the point of the game???

I request you to read my posts twice if you're town!

Why it is weird?

It's weird because the traitor is the only one who knows the full scumteam so it makes sense that the traitor would try to push harder than the regular mafia since the traitor knows they aren't pushing on their partner.

Why do you think the traitor is hiding purposely? What does your gut say would be different if he were the traitor?

Okay.... this theory didn't occur to my head. I have to think again then, but it'll not change my read on

Almost50

, if he is the traitor then the scum is in {

Scipio1, implosion

} mostly.

[Scipio1]

salsa why do you townread s_s and pooky

[Salsabil Faria]

salsa why do you townread s_s and pooky

I'm sheeping

PookytheMagicalBear

here, also I played with them in another game where they were a town, their playstyle seems the same.

Something_Smart

's posts don't give me any scum/negative vibe yet, seems town to me.

[implosion]

gosh i wish we could just policy a50.

[Almost50]

^^This is but another scum indicative post by implo. He also knows me well enough to think I'd do what I did as Scum. Like, only Scipio and Salsabil here are not familiar with my play. Everyone else has played several times with me before (and some most recently) and implo even modded me a good number of times (S_S did too, but I think I played more implo-modded games)

[implosion]

I still definitely want to no-lim. I don't think there's anyone whose death doesn't give us at least something additional to work with. And there's always the off chance of scum shooting their traitor by mistake.

I really don't see salsabil scum atm.

[implosion]

^^This is but another scum indicative post by implo. He also knows me well enough to think I'd do what I did as Scum. Like, only Scipio and Salsabil here are not familiar with my play. Everyone else has played several times with me before (and some most recently) and implo even modded me a good number of times (S_S did too, but I think I played more implo-modded games)

my post is an indication of annoyance toward what you did. nothing more.

[Almost50]

But you do acknowledge that it's Town-indicative of me. Right? If yes, then why would you wish you could policy a town slot in MyEo?? And why wouldn't you even state that you do (think it's town-indicative) along with your wish?

Put another way: "He's Town alright, but I wish I could policy him just the same" doesn't equal "I wish I could policy him". Does it?

[implosion]

Town indicative, possibly. I don't feel solid on it, you could absolutely do something like this as scum. You do know what "policy" means, right? It means it's behavior that should be discouraged that isn't necessarily alignment-indicative.

[implosion]

At this moment if I had to name a scumteam it'd be scipio + something_smart. But I certainly don't feel especially good about either of those. And I don't really want to get into too many details about reads if we're no-limming.

I do kind of think A50 is town on the whole; it's just that I'm going to be really annoyed at myself if I believe the reasons that I see for that and they're wrong. I certainly think his play here makes a hell of a lot more sense as traitor than as main scum; doing some kind of wild fakeclaim gambit bullshit is a much more traitor thing to do than main scum. Salsabil I feel has emanated town in general, not just from the weird dumbtell stuff. I think if I'm wrong somewhere it's most likely pooky replacing one of the two.

[Salsabil Faria]

V/LA till 16th April due to health issue.