Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[The Bulge]

Votecount 1.8

Etine

[4] - WindowsXP, DeathNote, Marky Mark, Nero Cain

T3

[4] - Etine, Andresvmb, Anya, Enchant

KittyTacky

[3] - T3, samantha97, Vasex

Vasex

[2] - Rathe, Save The Dragons

Cabd

[1] - deep-city-lights

NDMath

[1] - Kerset

Save The Dragons

[1] - Dunnstral

Kerset

[1] - NDMath

Not voting

- DrippingGoofball, Artemiana, KittyTacky, Cabd

With 21 players alive, it will take 11 votes to achieve an elimination.

The deadline for Day 1 is Thursday, May 6 at 3:00 am EDT/7 GMT. You have (expired on 2021-05-06 03:00:00).

Mod Note

deep-city-lights v/la until April 27

[T3]

Reads:
Hard town: Marky Mark, Rathe
Town: Nero Cain
Lean town: NDMath, WindowsXP, dcl, Anya, DeathNote
Null: Vasex, Kerset, samantha, STD, DGB, Dunnstral, Arte, Andres
Lean scum: Enchant, Cabd
Scum: KittyTacky, Etine

Most of my null reads are basically people who haven't donr anything.

[Dunnstral]

You should check your null reads.

[Dunnstral]

Or at least don't say I haven't done anything, I guess

[Dunnstral]

Also can you explain your lean scum tier?

[T3]

Cabd feels like a lot of noise but no content. Enchant is townreading one of my scumreads and I didn't like the framer interaction.

[Save The Dragons]

adding T3 to town

[Kerset]

marky town

Hard town: Marky Mark,

Is it because of his claim? The amount of TRs he gets looks concerning.

[Save The Dragons]

i liked his interaction with etine

[Kerset]

Nero would be a fine town leader, if he would have more then one read.

[KittyTacky]

Zzzzz. Let's hammer Kitty today.

VOTE: KittyTacky

It sounds even less convincing that your RVS. Cmon we are on 15th page.

I have no strong reasons against him, but I have feeling that he plays here much like a bad actor. Maybe because of the lack of experience.
For example this post #22 : "Nope. I remember you tho. From my first game. I played like a headless chicken. Kinda embarrassing." Especially about remembering me, ugh...
I'm (softly) triggered on almost every of these sentances, and on his other posts too... "nervous" about large game, because this is a first big game for him, huh... Vasex is definitely tr for him from the very beginning, how?...

I tried to read the others, but this is my best bet for now.

I said you're not a TR for me. You didn't read my posts, did you?

In fact this weird pushing makes me think you are scum trying to mislynch me. VOTE: Vasex

[KittyTacky]

That is just my style of talking as town. C'mon, you were in that game. You can also read Newbie 2058 (concluded).

[Anya]

VOTE: Etine

going off my previous reasoning i think he's likely town so i'd like to verify that and then go from there if i can see i'm on the right path for solving

[Anya]

T3's hurdle jumps are a little more graceful and improved

[Vasex]

Some overreaction from you, Kitty. Btw I has hanged you one time (we were both townies), and even in that situation there were no problems for you to find me townie. What has changed?

Etine, what do you think about Rathe?

I think, that except Kitty at least one mafia is here: STD/Rathe/Andresvmb. The guys that have already threw smth at me (if i dont miss smb). I consider smb of them can do that because of my attack to Kitty.

[DeathNote]

Etine if you start attacking T3, people will townread you

Bad post. It's almost like Kerset had nothing good to say here so <insert town joke here> but didn't even realize the joke would fall flat. (Etine having already pushed T3). Unless the joke is somehow that he got in trouble for attacking T3 already? Point being, feels like scum trying to be sarcastic town.

to be clear I'm not voting Etine for contradicting himself I'm voting Etine b/c his response to the Q doesn't seem like a town response. I'd expect something more along the lines of "I don't have 6 scum reads yet"

Nero provides solid reasoning. I had this thought and didn't realize it until I read this post as to why I didn't like Etine's response.

Hardly believe Etine is mafia.

Mafia have better plans than going badly accusing someone day 1, and then provocate everyone by screams.

Ehh I don't think that's true? Mafia know how to scum hunt and be active, it's even very easy to try and take charge. Etine could have easily thought he was pushing a reasonable vote.

[KittyTacky]

Some overreaction from you, Kitty. Btw I has hanged you one time (we were both townies), and even in that situation there were no problems for you to find me townie. What has changed?

Last time you had different reasoning.

[Vasex]

Who is scummy if im townie, Kitty?

[Kerset]

Etine if you start attacking T3, people will townread you

Bad post. It's almost like Kerset had nothing good to say here so <insert town joke here> but didn't even realize the joke would fall flat. (Etine having already pushed T3). Unless the joke is somehow that he got in trouble for attacking T3 already? Point being, feels like scum trying to be sarcastic town.

You didn't get it. Etine was being suspected, because instead of attacking his main SR (T3) he focused entirely on self-defense. You can't get town points, if you keep talking about yourself - people give you them for investigation. The fact how much was he self-aware about it, was quite relevant there.

[Vasex]

Kerset, why do you advise him to get townie points? Is Etine more townie or scummy for you now?

[Kerset]

To see whenever he is self-aware about his situation. I don't find him scummy - he is just awkward.

[T3]

To see whenever he is self-aware about his situation. I don't find him scummy - he is just awkward.

Not liking how Kitty is overly focused on the Vasex interaction.

[T3]

To see whenever he is self-aware about his situation. I don't find him scummy - he is just awkward.

Not liking how Kitty is overly focused on the Vasex interaction.

Not sure why that quoted.

[Vasex]

You dont find Etine scummy, you help him openly, but "Nero would be a fine town leader, if he would have more then one read.". Nero is attacking Etine. So it is rather contradictory.

[Marky Mark]

(My underlines below)

In fact this weird pushing makes me think you are scum

trying to mislynch me.

This feels awkward and over-thought. If they are scum and they are pushing you then it is inherently implicit that they are trying to miselim you. The quoted sentence reads much more naturally without the underlined bit.