Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[Rathe]

weak to be easy cheated by mafia in one of the commonest situations when the scum is going to be dead

weak also means being stubborn n not thinking u could be wrong

[Rathe]

if kitty is 1 shot cop it is best to let him use his shot not kill him before he can

[Nero Cain]

but cabd isn't a claimed cop so...

but you didn't really answer my question. Is it or is it not the correct play to let a claimed 1x cop live for a night phase?

[Rathe]

even if he gets nightkilled it is better than hanging a potential town pr

[Vasex]

ok, look at this if kitty is mafia:
enchant unvoted when there were 10 votes! making 9 votes
enchant still wanted to elim kitty, but started to call someone to make 10th vote to give opportunity to enchant to hammer kitty with 11th vote
why did he unvote and still asking people to make 10th vote? he was trying to sit on two chairs with the same butt

[Vasex]

Is it or is it not the correct play to let a claimed 1x cop live for a night phase?

This is correct only in the situations when the situation is too difficult and there is a big chance to make a mistake.
But Kitty is a mafia scum.
For me it is obvious.

[Vasex]

he was trying to sit on two chairs with the same butt

to make distancing with kitty by saying that
and
to save his life by unvoting, giving time to claim

[Vasex]

the townies, voting for kitty, decided to kill him today as the most possible scum for them
so if smb is unvoting first it means that this man is probably saving his partner

IF ENCHANT UNVOTED TO SAVE A COP, HE WOULDNT ASKING SMB TO VOTE TO HAMMER THIS COP AT THE SAME TIME

Enchant made big mistakes today

[Vasex]

and after discussing all of these both enchant and kitty even dont consider t3 and me scummies, just defending themselves

[Save The Dragons]

if only there was some indication that Enchant likes to make jokes and isn't 100% serious with everything he says!

Spoiler:

VOTE: WindowsXP

Old.

What leader? Everyone knows i should be one.

I townread you lots so I agree

We have simular mind, i townread self too.

One dog for family.

No.

Dayvig Anya.

who is not voting kitty today go back to newbie games

I played 5 already. Can't now.

[Vasex]

it is stupid to quote the jokes from the very beginning of the game to prove that a player jokes always.

[Save The Dragons]

i didn't just quote jokes from the beginning of the game, so...

[Vasex]

Ok, here is not a joke (i did ask is he serious and the answer is yes).

Aren't it makes more sense to go check Babysiter claim? Checked protective kinda op.

are you serious here?

Yes?

Yes?

that's bad

Hardly believe Etine is mafia.

Mafia have better plans than going badly accusing someone day 1, and then provocate everyone by screams.

This question probably for me. Just noticed so...

I still think Etina is townie because of his behavior and PR claim which i discussed in this post is more or less solid. You would't want to claim Babysitter as mafia. It's... Just bad. Unless of course, Etine is bad at game which i can't believe with 5 years of expireince. Of course Etine looking not ideal paragon, but looking decent for allowing live for now.

[Save The Dragons]

my point is that the post that looks like a joke comes from a player who jokes, not that he jokes 100% of the time

[Vasex]

if kitty and enchant are scummies - std is a mafia scum with them.
if cabd and etine are townies - std is a mafia scum (it means he found zero scums, talking that he has three).

[Save The Dragons]

i stopped thinking etine was mafia a long time ago

[Anya]

is it bad that i wanna say i wanna sheep vasex today and like basically make them town leader like i fucking trust this dude to be town 100% and they are putting in effort i am unable to really put into a large game like i hate sorting 20 other people LOL

this is mafia bookmark this post

agree

[Save The Dragons]

i'm also not arguing that enchant isn't scum, that i'm not sure of yet. i just don't think kitty is scum and i don't see the "scumslip"

[Nero Cain]

For me it is obvious.

not for me its not.

let's say I'm wrong and kitty is scum. Worst-case scenario is he's a scum pr and he gets 1 night of action. And if he's a goon then? nothing happens. FMPOV the safest thing is to let him use his investigation (assuming he's telling the truth) and we can safely lynch him tomorrow if need be.

Who else would u do today?

[T3]

Anya, thoughts on the slip?

[Nero Cain]

but even if Kitty gets lynched today b/c its the EZ thing to do and most ppl just do the ez thing-ending the day with a lurking cabd, andre and arte seems like a bad waste of time. make them use their words.

[T3]

but even if Kitty gets lynched today b/c its the EZ thing to do and most ppl just do the ez thing-ending the day with a lurking cabd, andre and arte seems like a bad waste of time. make them use their words.

But if kitty is scum we get Enchant confirmed scum and STD likely scum, Cabd and Etine likely town.

[Vasex]

And if he's a goon then? nothing happens

Except we will elim townie instead of mafia

[Vasex]

VOTE: Cabd

[Vasex]

VOTE: Kitty

Ugh