Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[Marky Mark]

And, with the pagetop stolen, I will bid you all a good night. Take care all

[Vasex]

Townies.
Vote Anastasia. While Mark sleeps.

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: Anastasia

[T3]

I shouldn't have fakeclaimed. At this point I would want Enchant so I will leave my vote there. I would loike to hear more from Anya at this point.

[Anastasia]

VOTE: Anastasia

Do you find Vasex's case against me compelling?

[Anastasia]

It's fucking Day 1, I could be wrong.

You are wrong about me.

I'm happy to discuss things with you to help correct this.

I'd like you to be right about me.

Help me help you.

[Etine]

I very much disagree with voting Anastasia, and her slot previously was not on my radar either..

[Anastasia]

Thanks Etine, you are so sweet.

[Etine]

Jogging my own memory it seems the argument for Anastasia/Artermaria is not knowing her password? Which is a pretty bumkus reason to sr someone in the first place. Arte might've been wrong about me as well in their hero solve, but the hero solve alone is a choice response. Was Arte even being wagoned at that time? It seems like she just wanted to get her word in before repping out for reasons that didn't seem gamestate related.

[Etine]

Thanks Etine, you are so sweet.

No you! I thought your rep-in posts were good. NDMath though? Even in my own absence I feel just so bleh about the direction of the thread right now..

[Etine]

My mind feels much more refreshed now that the place has quieted a down a bit. I'm still a bit physically impacted by the covid shot but I'll manage.

Time to put these reading glasses to use and actually ISO some people..

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: Anastasia

Do you find Vasex's case against me compelling?

not really i just find voting for your slot compelling

[Save The Dragons]

have you read the game?

[Save The Dragons]

the replace out is not game related im assuming

my biggest problem with arte was a lack of content before then. my biggest problem with anastasia is her defense it is coming off scummy, it's too casual. kind of a gut read. but i'm interested to hear what she has to say about the game.

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: Andresvmb

I get that you're sick but this seems night and day from brutality

[Anastasia]

VOTE: Anastasia

Do you find Vasex's case against me compelling?

not really i just find voting for your slot compelling

because?

[Save The Dragons]

did you see my other posts

[Anastasia]

my biggest problem with anastasia is her defense it is coming off scummy, it's too casual. kind of a gut read.

So you are scumreading the delivery and not the content?


I've laid out a few townreads and a scumread. Do you disagree with my thought process or conclusions?

[Etine]

21 players is a lot! I'm gonna just try to talk about the peeps who stand out to me. If I don't mention you or whatever I guess I don't have a read or anything worthwhile to say. My thoughts on players are written as I go along, but I didn't want to just clutter the thread some more. I'll try to be neat as possible, spick and span..

So! Right now I feel a good majority of the people leading are um fine. Usually scum only care to take control if it's given to them or necessary. I don't really see the need for Vasex to be prattling on in the way he has as mafia. Do I agree with all of his reads? Well not really. I think he's genuine even if a bit blunt. Who else am I okay with?

Ana, Enchant, samantha97

(slightly). Other people I don't wanna lim today but maybe don't TR are

DGB, Dunnstral, and Marky

. Marky because he's claimed miller mostly. That isn't the strongest batch of townreads and I wish I had more but boy am I finding a lot of the opinions made sorta blending in with each other. T3 getting wagoned was great and all but I see he's claimed one-shot cop? And there's another PR who's claimed as well? I was not trying to start a movement guys. I was just really stressed out and wasn't thinking and I'm sorry. Sidenote: I was townreading WindowsXP earlier but don't know anymore.

[Anastasia]

have you read the game?

I have read a few ISOs and skimmed the first 30 pages or so.

Is there anything that happened you would like to discuss in particular?

[Etine]

I'm multi-posting because this site seems to like that more? Please read my thoughts!


Starting off with

Anders

. My vote on Anders is not really one I've thought too deeply about, but I like it because all of his substance so far seems overly direct. He has posts like 263, 268, Yet to contrast that? he has posts like 463, 687, 1300. No, being inactive and claiming you'll catch up is not completely telling, but if you combine how sure of himself he is, why does he need to catch up? Or why does he keep making excuses. I know myself am very due for something like this but from my perspective it's much different. None of his reads feel earned or used in a way that would provide to other townies. It all reads like commentary and feels a bit selfish in design, and not in a good way.

Scummy

[Etine]

So..to my surprise

Cabd

is getting wagoned! I was pinged by him early but I find myself in a conundrum right now. I still think he's scummy, but the disparity between Anders and Cabd are much different. Anders assumes to know all the answers and Cabd sort of just keeps to himself. I think he's wrong on Ana but I don't know if it comes from opportunity. While the lack of activity and reads unsettle me, over time I might've just driven too much expectation onto the guy. His early posts just seemed so vibrant and reading to kick some tail but then nothing happened. And then he made this weird readlist on everyone that felt so hurried! Pure gut pings and maybe lots of tone. ISO'ing his behavior seems like there isn't any effort to change the way he's been playing, so he's either settled into his own scum death or he's a townie who knows they can get themselves out of this situation.

I am willing to give him a chance.

[Save The Dragons]

If you look at ND's posting iso, there is little substance and few posts.

i agree few posts, but i'm not sure if there's little substance, can you clarify why his posts seem to have little substance? this is an argument that can be made about your slot.

Most importantly he does not seem to engage with the action that's happened already today in the major wagons.

it was weird how he called out Enchant and Kitty as scum and then votes Samantha for also being scum, instead of jumping on a wagon that would prove useful he avoids them to vote for some randowagon.

He barely says anything about Etine's alignment - this type of hands off approach is often used by scum who do not want their fingerprints on an early town-wagon.

i'm not sure that everyone commented on etine's alignment, are you scumreading other people for this?

His read on kitty switched from town to scum fairly quickly and I don't really see the justification for the progression.

i dunno, i think a lot of game happened in between the two posts.

[Save The Dragons]

I think Kitty/T3 are both good police officers who want to keep our beautiful town safe.

I would trust both of them.

does this mean you're TRing both cop claims

[Anastasia]

i agree few posts, but i'm not sure if there's little substance, can you clarify why his posts seem to have little substance? this is an argument that can be made about your slot.

I've posted more than he has and I've been here for 1/6th of the time, I don't think you can make the same argument for my slot presently.

I think the way he avoids commenting on Etine's alignment is scummy, in the way that when a scum sees a wagon take off on a townie early, the scum does not want to derail the wagon but also does not want to leave his fingerprints on it by pushing it. The words he said about Etine feel like the comments of a scum who does not want to push one way or the other.