Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[The Bulge]

Votecount 1.25

Cabd

[8] - deep-city-lights, Nero Cain, Rathe, samantha97, Anastasia, NDMath, KittyTacky, Save The Dragons

Enchant

[3] - T3, Kerset, Vasex

Anastasia

[2] - Anya, Cabd

Andresvmb

[2] - Dunnstral, Etine

T3

[1] - Andresvmb

NDMath

[1] - Marky Mark

Etine

[1] - WindowsXP

deep-city-lights

[1] - DrippingGoofball

Not voting

- Almost50, Enchant

With 21 players alive, it will take 11 votes to achieve an elimination.

The deadline for Day 1 is Thursday, May 6 at 3:00 am EDT/7 GMT. You have (expired on 2021-05-06 03:00:00).

Mod Note

Cabd and Etine v/la

[Anastasia]

I think locking the thread to steal a page top is borderline mod power abuse.

[Save The Dragons]

I think locking the thread to steal a page top is borderline mod power abuse.

lol it scared the shit out of me

[Cabd]

Way to give me a heart attack, Bulge.

[Cabd]

I thought maybe he'd counter wrong the first lock and I was actually dead, and I was gonna be mad I didn't get to finish afternoon tea with STD. Well, that and second regrets i didn't get to post my general insults I almost posted the first time it locked.

[The Bulge]

Apologies. There was a visual bug that made it appear as though somebody had deleted a post.

...I don't need power abuse to snipe these pagetops

[Anastasia]

What would you even be insulting the town for?

failing to sheep you on a bad meta-read on a green player when you refuse to take the time to properly come up with an actual scum case on someone?

[Anastasia]

I am still waiting for an example of a game where you self-hammered as scum on D1.

[The Bulge]

deep-city-lights has requested replacement.

[Cabd]

Still not gonna negotiate with terrorists, xenocakes.

[Anastasia]

Anastasia - Marangal (the original owner of the slot via her alt Artemis) and I go extremely way back. As in "Mara was the IC of my first or second newbie game in 2013" back. As in "Literally went to IRL meetups at anime cons" far back. Town-Mara, cognizant of and seeing my "Help I need a friendly face to help me engage into this game" signals being thrown into the ether? She fucking steps up and uses me as her leverage to get both of us back into the game, and HARD. If, for some crazy reason she cannot? She encourages me to keep it up and tries to find that person for me instead. Know what town-mara never fucking does? The crickets form this game.

You continue to insist that this is a valid meta-tell worthy of d1 elimination.

I'm going to put aside the fact that I know for a fact this is wrong since I can see my own role PM and try to work through this with you from a neutral POV to show you how absurd your expectations for Mara's meta are.

Let's look at what's available as

public information

Artemiana signed up for this large game here:

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p12633137

March 3rd. That's nearly 2 months ago.

This game took quite a while to fill up since then.

Is it possible that she had real life situation/activity issues that she could not for-see coming up 2 months ago?

Maybe she even forgot she signed up for it.

Her first post was an ego post as soon as the thread opened.

Her only relevant activity in the

entirety of the game

was a ~4 hour stretch where she posted mostly one-liners, threw out some reads, talked to Vasex.

She then flaked out of the game.

From any reasonable neutral observation of this slot, her actions are NAI, most likely just signed up for a game she forgot about, lost interest in, did not have time for, and then she flaked out.

Instead you've decided to read scum-motivation into it as some nonsense where she would be expected to read your pleas, pull you into the game and get invested with you on solving the game.

A game that it doesn't look like she was even all that interested in playing in the first place.

This is an

incredible

stretch on your part to assume all sorts of bad intention on her end when the most obvious answer here is that she simply flaked out.

[Anastasia]

Still not gonna negotiate with terrorists, xenocakes.

It's not a negotiation.

You claim you would self-hammer as scum on D1 to shut up town discussion. I asked for an example of you doing it in the past.

If you're going to self-meta you should at least be able to produce some evidence.

[Save The Dragons]

Except he did it as soon as he repped in, BEFORE the mod even formally announced him. You think he had time to discuss such a plan in a scum PT? Would bet dollars to doughnuts that he didn't, and he doesn't do that without blessings.

I don't see it outside the realm of possibility but i don't particularly think he's scum

Do you disagree?

it wouldn't hurt to look at them but i still think scum!mark could have claimed miller with only a few nonposters and felt pretty safe.

either way my point here is that it looks like you're driving content in the beginning but i don't know that you actually are with your post.

I mean while technically true, generally speaking scumteams don't talk me in and out of things, I talk THEM in and out of things. Now that I see A50 is replaced into the game, ask him what being scum with me in Tenet was like? Or ask The Ceph-Rawr lol we were a fucking hydra playing every single town with puppet strings.

i would love to ask Ceph about you but i don't think that's kosher

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p12206211
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p12210949

Bell was scum there btw.

paraphrase?

i've just seen too many people latch onto my weirdness as a "you suck" as scum for it not to at least raise my hackles.

Without discussing other ongoing games.... She didn't fucking sitequit lol. I checked. She woulda said something when leaving if she had. This is like nearly decade old IRL meta here.

i think we're arguing semantics, she was here for a fleeting moment and she left, if she didn't sitequit good for her but she clearly wasn't invested in this game. i respect you have a meta read on the player but i feel some circumstance is different here that isn't alignment indicative otherwise she would have reached out to you. but i don't think enough of her was here to even attempt that.

My title is literally because when I'm ever feeling unsure, i revert back to THE BINDER which is a document I keep of people's meta tells that have yet to be burned. And in some cases, that have been burned but are still valid. Example: Mara only ever discusses a certain game form her past as scum because it's too traumatic for town-her to cite. (This is one that was burned many moons ago but she never broke)

my title's a joke about STDs and doctor protection

my point is that i don't think the meta applies. i want something else, something i can sink my teeth into.

Was probably too sharp and I apologize.

lol i don't care i asked a shitty question

I hate how many people on this site think ATE is inherently scummy. Sometimes one just wants to put their feels out there man. ATE can be towny too, see literally everything that Sakura Hana posted, ever.

it can be, but coupled with other pings it looks like it could be scum trying to influence people into townreading them.

See earlier comment. I wish I could post discord logs because I have an entire speech about this in the Tenet scum discord channel. Day one trading a sunken mafia member to wipe out 7 days of IRL time is almost certainly worth it. Tenet had the fucking treestump mechanic which made things a little more complex, but in a traditional setup, it's fine.

and i still don't care about meta because it's easy to play against it

what if this game is the ONE TIME you go against what you would normally do? no. i'm gonna pass.

[WindowsXP]

How are ppl scumreading anastasia here again?

[WindowsXP]

vasex etine windows(?????) T4 Cabd is my new city list

my most wanted are kitty anastasia

and the bandit stragglers are monkeyman Nero Dunnstral

Pls

[WindowsXP]

Driving home probably for the best that the thread got locked and I walked away because I was about to say some very spite.

But apparently we're so incompetent we can't even kill me correctly which is a hoot. I'm sure there's tons of reactions to me rage quitting and they may or may not end up with me dying for real today but whatever the case may be I will read that stuff when I get home I'm still alive by then have a good weekend everyone safe travels

Start with a reads list probably for one. A case would be nice. Show you're not just anti spewing.

[WindowsXP]

Less self defense and more taking stances.

[WindowsXP]

This was something i fought you to fake as scum in our scum pt so i know you struggle with it as scum

[Anastasia]

his readslist is in 1537

[WindowsXP]

Wait i literally replied to it LMAO

[WindowsXP]

I was pretty damn drunk last night so my memory was super hazy tbh LOL

[WindowsXP]

VOTE: CabD

[WindowsXP]

i forgot how little I liked that reads list esp wrt anastasia

[DrippingGoofball]

deep-city-lights can't take the heat of my one vote.

[Anastasia]

deep-city-lights can't take the heat of my one vote.

This is really funny.

I love you goofballs <3