Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[DrippingGoofball]

1 shot cop is easy scum claim to make, you make 1 result, you just clear 1 player or your scumbuddy, and then you have an excuse as to why you never die.


t3 claims a specific modifier that would be out of character for a new player - granted he has a scum team behind him as scum, but i think he was reading from his role pm here rather than a scumbuddy feeding him a claim, because in that case he would not have claimed BP in the first place there.

Another posts that makes me want to eliminate WindowsXP.

[Dunnstral]

I will admit I do find it kind of odd that the Scum didn’t shoot at the 1-Shot Cop. I think I would have strongly considered that. I don’t even think Anya was obvious Town at all.

Etine claimed lazy babysitter, maybe they didn't want to gamble. But then it makes you think about why Etine wasn't shot.

[Dunnstral]

I will admit I do find it kind of odd that the Scum didn’t shoot at the 1-Shot Cop. I think I would have strongly considered that. I don’t even think Anya was obvious Town at all.

probably because a 1 shot cop isn't that likely to hit mafia

Not a good argument, because clearing town is also something that scum wants to avoid

[Andresvmb]

I will admit I do find it kind of odd that the Scum didn’t shoot at the 1-Shot Cop. I think I would have strongly considered that. I don’t even think Anya was obvious Town at all.

Etine claimed lazy babysitter, maybe they didn't want to gamble. But then it makes you think about why Etine wasn't shot.

It’s possible the Scum weren’t sure which of the outted shots was going to get protected and went for a different Townie, not to take any chances.

[Dunnstral]

I think the real answer is that kitty is still elimmable

[Andresvmb]

outted shots

*Outted slots

[Kerset]

Kitty is not just a 1-shot cop. She is also a person openly attacked by T3, keep in mind why did T3 claim in the first place.

[Dunnstral]

Do we think miller would exist with only a mafia cop in the game?

[bloodhail]

I will admit I do find it kind of odd that the Scum didn’t shoot at the 1-Shot Cop. I think I would have strongly considered that. I don’t even think Anya was obvious Town at all.

probably because a 1 shot cop isn't that likely to hit mafia

Not a good argument, because clearing town is also something that scum wants to avoid

a single clear in a large game isnt that powerful, im not that surprised they didnt shoot him tbh

[Andresvmb]

i forgot to put you there because your content is nonexistant but you're still scum

fuck off i'm not towncasing myself

Good.. good.

VOTE: bloodhail

Maybe someone else will care to town case you for me then.

Bloodhail is Town btw and this needs to get blown up at some point.

[bloodhail]

Do we think miller would exist with only a mafia cop in the game?

possibly a traitor red herring for the mafia cop (and the 1-shot still exists)

marky mark was the pivot vote onto T3 and was scumreading him all day, i dont think hes traitor

if he is then scum probably nightkill him anyway lmfao

[Dunnstral]

Willing to full clear Mark off the mafia cop.

...but mafia knew they had a cop

So saying a miller claim is clear because of what a mafia member flipped is using bad reasoning

[Andresvmb]

I’ll wait around to see what Kitty has to say, until then, I don’t see any need to execute anybody except for Nero Cain. I’ll start putting in more effort once that’s done.

[samantha97]

when I saw mafia cop I thought that confirmed a serial killer

[Dunnstral]

Do we think miller would exist with only a mafia cop in the game?

possibly a traitor red herring for the mafia cop (and the 1-shot still exists)

marky mark was the pivot vote onto T3 and was scumreading him all day, i dont think hes traitor

if he is then scum probably nightkill him anyway lmfao

I do like the idea of traitor red herring, though

[bloodhail]

most of my scumreads are trying to push vasex and it makes me want to just bury them right now

[Almost50]

i forgot to put you there because your content is nonexistant but you're still scum

fuck off i'm not towncasing myself

Good.. good.

VOTE: bloodhail

Maybe someone else will care to town case you for me then.

Bloodhail is Town btw and this needs to get blown up at some point.

Convince me or fight me

[Save The Dragons]

bury me

[bloodhail]

VOTE: T3

This is where I think we need to go now. I'd prefer Vasex or NDMath as the consequences are less bad if I'm wrong in terms of losing a PR, but I still think we have a good chance of hitting scum here and we have the votes to make it work.

T3 [6] - Rathe, KittyTacky, Etine, samantha97, DrippingGoofball, Marky Mark
Cabd [5] - Nero Cain, Save The Dragons, WindowsXP, Vasex, NDMath
Andresvmb [3] - Dunnstral, T3, Anya
Enchant [3] - Enchant, bloodhail, Kerset
Vasex [1] - Anastasia
Nero Cain [1] - Andresvmb
Anastasia [1] - Cabd

Not voting - Almost50

if marky mark were traitor this vote would be a hardcore throw

[Andresvmb]

i forgot to put you there because your content is nonexistant but you're still scum

fuck off i'm not towncasing myself

Good.. good.

VOTE: bloodhail

Maybe someone else will care to town case you for me then.

Bloodhail is Town btw and this needs to get blown up at some point.

Convince me or fight me

I’m not doing shit. If you’re Town all you need to do is read.

[Dunnstral]

when I saw mafia cop I thought that confirmed a serial killer

I didn't think that cops got a guilty on serial killers.

I checked the wiki and you're right: in normal games cops receive "Town" and "Not Town" results, and would get "Not Town" on a serial killer in normal games

[DrippingGoofball]

With T3 flipping mafia doc, and his cop claim turning out false, I now believe Kitty is town.

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: T3

This is where I think we need to go now. I'd prefer Vasex or NDMath as the consequences are less bad if I'm wrong in terms of losing a PR, but I still think we have a good chance of hitting scum here and we have the votes to make it work.

T3 [6] - Rathe, KittyTacky, Etine, samantha97, DrippingGoofball, Marky Mark
Cabd [5] - Nero Cain, Save The Dragons, WindowsXP, Vasex, NDMath
Andresvmb [3] - Dunnstral, T3, Anya
Enchant [3] - Enchant, bloodhail, Kerset
Vasex [1] - Anastasia
Nero Cain [1] - Andresvmb
Anastasia [1] - Cabd

Not voting - Almost50

if marky mark were traitor this vote would be a hardcore throw

This makes the assumption that Cabd is town, but sure

[Dunnstral]

when I saw mafia cop I thought that confirmed a serial killer

I didn't think that cops got a guilty on serial killers.

I checked the wiki and you're right: in normal games cops receive "Town" and "Not Town" results, and would get "Not Town" on a serial killer in normal games

Balance wise, I'm not sure why mafia would have the biggest tool to catch the serial killer, though

[bloodhail]

STD has made zero impression on me at all.
I'll look at his ISO.

VOTE: T3

This is where I think we need to go now. I'd prefer Vasex or NDMath as the consequences are less bad if I'm wrong in terms of losing a PR, but I still think we have a good chance of hitting scum here and we have the votes to make it work.

T3 [6] - Rathe, KittyTacky, Etine, samantha97, DrippingGoofball, Marky Mark
Cabd [5] - Nero Cain, Save The Dragons, WindowsXP, Vasex, NDMath
Andresvmb [3] - Dunnstral, T3, Anya
Enchant [3] - Enchant, bloodhail, Kerset
Vasex [1] - Anastasia
Nero Cain [1] - Andresvmb
Anastasia [1] - Cabd

Not voting - Almost50

if marky mark were traitor this vote would be a hardcore throw

This makes the assumption that Cabd is town, but sure

well ok if it's s/s that complicates things but i am assuming cabd town based on the reaction to what he thought was hammer and how T3 talked about him

the only way i see that happenening is if cabd is a better mafia role than T3 but if so why would he nope out of the game and claim VT