Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[DrippingGoofball]

I hesitate to vote STD because scummy is how he always plays, but I have to reckon he he being scummier than usual.

[Kerset]

I think that samatha is either a genius or village idiot, so we should let a50 live until we figure it out.

[Kerset]

Vasex its time to shine, figure it out for me.

[Vasex]

we need just to kill std
to see he is a scum
then remember how andre and windows tried to elim nero instead of std
and they also were protecting t3
how many scums were found by them? none
case closed

the traitor can be somewhere here among them or not far from them in the range of scums.
i think they just dont have room for any plans and maneuvers in this situation, so they just take the defensive positions and just give up with no serious scum searching now

[Vasex]

im not sure samantha is right about a50, but i believe he is not the best choice for today

[Kerset]

Last time you were so convinced, you wanted us to kill kitty. Try to improve from that and be more open minded.

[Kerset]

ok

[Kerset]

154.


What i miss?

We are trying to someone, who townreads STD. No progress so far.

[Kerset]

*We are trying to find

[Vasex]

this is usual thing for me and for many experienced players to consider a man with a cop role like one of the scums because of his strange behaviour
i even told about that before kitty's claim because i do this mistake oftenly and i need to recheck it many times
though i didnt understand who of them is true fast, this mistake is worse, but i did it in the end of the day (and when t3 betrayed me very strangely), so it doesnt count)
though there is still a little chance that i was right about kitty too. or it is too weird cop for me

[Vasex]

kerset considered std town according to my notes

[Kerset]

Ok this one is for people townreading STD
Look at those

Spoiler: STD about T3 and Kitty

how i feel about kitty

a play in three acts

By the way this is my first large. It's more than twice as big as a newbie and almost twice than a mini so I'm nervous.

i feel scum!kitty says this in their scum PT only.

In our previous game he has the list of scummies rather early. Is he seeking them now? I dont think so

i feel like expecting someone to solve a large game so early is a bit much to ask.

intermission please buy some damn popcorn it keeps the theatre alive

(My underlines below)

In fact this weird pushing makes me think you are scum

trying to mislynch me.

This feels awkward and over-thought. If they are scum and they are pushing you then it is inherently implicit that they are trying to miselim you. The quoted sentence reads much more naturally without the underlined bit.

Good point but explain how that is alignment-indicative.

i feel like this is just potential newbiebait rather than scumbait

*bows*

encore
i feel that vasex does get some townie cred for recent posts but his interaction with kitty is still giving me some heebie jeebies

OMG I HAVE A CAKE NEXT TO MY NAME

WORSHIP ME

by unvoting kitty and going after the real scum here, Cabd

Did you miss the part when Enchant scumslipped?

yes i don't get it

but i read his post as not particularly serious

do you think PR doesn't explain the differences in kitty's play between what you've seen before and this game?

who is not voting kitty today go back to newbie games

sick burn

im not sure how i feel about enchant but so far i dislike every case against them

they didn't scumslip and they weren't the first to talk about T3 being a traitor

if anything i'm more suspicious of T3 but i think i need to reread a bit

DGB why are you voting kitty

And tell me that this is a POV of an

active

player (not lurker), who has no idea what are the alignments of Kitty and T3. This all that he said/asked about those. Simultaneously he was pushing cabd this entire time and retained some curiosity about enchant.

He completely didn't care about alignment of the most controversial players of this game, especially T3. This is not how town player should look like. Even if you happen to be tunneled, you are still curious about things around you unless you are informed.

VOTE: Save The Dragons

then use ISO & ctrl+f instead of them

[Vasex]

what about ndmath's case about a50(deathnote) = traitor?
dunn likes it very much
what do you think?

[Kerset]

only 174 makes sense as traitor crumb and it is not sufficient for me to elim a50 over actual scumread

[Vasex]

i agree. there are no problems to hang him in searching for the last one.

[Vasex]

and if he is a traitor, if i understand it right, the elimination of all his partners - this is victory for townies even without elimination of the traitor

[Kerset]

yes

[samantha97]

I think that samantha is a genius

[Save The Dragons]

i tr me

[Save The Dragons]

154.


What i miss?

We are trying to someone, who townreads STD. No progress so far.

what is that telling you

[Save The Dragons]

Ana, why is your vote on me?

[Marky Mark]

Hey all, just finished work for the weekend. Thursdays are always pretty hectic for me, so I now have 30ish pages to try and digest since daystart.

Gut feels prior to reading up properly are that Vasex/Ana may well both be scum. Vasex's defending T3 for most of D1 while trying to give off vibes that he was ok with limming him (eg that post where he asks about double-limming kitty and t3) looks even scummier than before after the T3 flip and Ana's posts ref Kitty/T3 both being town now also look like scum trying to protect T3 while realising that if they push kitty and kitty flips green then they will have incriminated their own buddy.

I reckon there was decent momentum behind the T3 wagon once DGB and I had moved our votes there, so I would not be surpised to see 1+ scum bussing on the later votes

[Nero Cain]

I don't feel like DN backing off the miller claim is a traitor crumb or really a scum play. It just seems dumb and useless.

[Vasex]

Mark, how many games have you already played? few? dozens? hundreds? please tell me

[Marky Mark]

About 10 or so. I played a handful in 2014 and then came back late 2020 when the pandemic limited my lesiure time options