Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[samantha97]

there are too many inconsistencies with what you did for me to believe you're town this game dkkoba

I've joked about you being wrong all the time and stuff but being wrong is a lot different than what you did this game

so yeah if you are town then mafia should totally bring both of us to lylo for an easy win

[Vasex]

I think this is just a blah blah blah about elimination of me

[WindowsXP]

there are too many inconsistencies with what you did for me to believe you're town this game dkkoba

I've joked about you being wrong all the time and stuff but being wrong is a lot different than what you did this game

so yeah if you are town then mafia should totally bring both of us to lylo for an easy win

Last game i was in with you i was wrong on 2 elims, whats different here samantha?

[WindowsXP]

Whats not consistent?

[samantha97]

iso me

[Andresvmb]

I feigned interest in a vasex wagon as to give the impression I would help push it through.

i wanted to see who would hop on.


2 of my scumreads, STD and Etine are on, and 1 scumlean, Marky Mark, as well as a Null scum in enchant. also the potential traitor T3 is there but since i know they are from Epicmafia I understand the logic they would use there wrt being cop - so theres town logic there I know they would have.

I do have to say, I’m horrified at this post. It’s totally backwards.

[WindowsXP]

I feigned interest in a vasex wagon as to give the impression I would help push it through.

i wanted to see who would hop on.


2 of my scumreads, STD and Etine are on, and 1 scumlean, Marky Mark, as well as a Null scum in enchant. also the potential traitor T3 is there but since i know they are from Epicmafia I understand the logic they would use there wrt being cop - so theres town logic there I know they would have.

I do have to say, I’m horrified at this post. It’s totally backwards.

It's my genuine reasoning? You see my unvote right as i came back to a wagon

[Vasex]

Vote std
Dont listen to scums, who are looking for another target instead of std (not talking about that directly)
I have 2 a.m., bye bye

[Andresvmb]

I feigned interest in a vasex wagon as to give the impression I would help push it through.

i wanted to see who would hop on.


2 of my scumreads, STD and Etine are on, and 1 scumlean, Marky Mark, as well as a Null scum in enchant. also the potential traitor T3 is there but since i know they are from Epicmafia I understand the logic they would use there wrt being cop - so theres town logic there I know they would have.

I do have to say, I’m horrified at this post. It’s totally backwards.

It's my genuine reasoning? You see my unvote right as i came back to a wagon

The general positioning you’re expressing in that page is directly opposite to how I’ve felt reading back this game. You SR Mark (who is very Town), Etine (probably Town, though harder to figure out admittedly because it’s mostly based on their emotional reactions and not their pushes), and you had Enchant as Null Scum (spewed Town at this stage). You did TR T3 and defended them using a bad meta argument. And you were also defending Nero (wanting to give them breathing room) when I strongly SR there. I don’t recall a game where we’ve both been Town and we were so far apart in our reads. Maybe you want to tell me now how you see these slots? Or just point to the post?

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: WindowsXP

[Andresvmb]

Also the theater that T3 and Vasex engaged in when they were both being run up and looked like either could go through as the execution is so obvious. Vasex will need to get executed in this game at some point. That much I’m fairly certain of.

[Andresvmb]

yeah Anastasia's reads depend heavily on how they're viewing her

she seems competent and smart so it's less likely she's town who just thinks anyone who suspects her is suspicious and more like wolf making calculated plays that are beneficial to her group project

This has crossed my mind. I find Anastasia to be a highly skilled player. Anastasia’s case in 1623 and 1624 against Cabd for example is, despite it being hard to prove (and I actually slightly TR Cabd to be totally transparent), very compelling. The fact that T3 also called Cabd hard Town actually also makes me question Cabd’s alignment in the back of my mind.

If Anastasia is Scum, it’s going to be challenging to figure it out.

[Vasex]

Anyway we should elim STD today.

Andre, I agree with you. At last.

[Anastasia]

Does anyone actually have good reasons to Townread STD?

[Andresvmb]

Anyway we should elim STD today.

Andre, I agree with you. At last.

Did you just manipulate a post of mine to say something I didn’t say? This is honestly horrible.

[Andresvmb]

Okay @Rathe, I’ve read closer. I understand your skepticism. I think there’s good reasons to SR XP here. I might have been wrong there.

[DrippingGoofball]

Okay @Rathe, I’ve read closer. I understand your skepticism. I think there’s good reasons to SR XP here. I might have been wrong there.

Vote!

[Andresvmb]

Okay @Rathe, I’ve read closer. I understand your skepticism. I think there’s good reasons to SR XP here. I might have been wrong there.

Vote!

I think there’s Scummier players this game. Like Nero.

[Andresvmb]

Cabd [3] - Nero Cain, samantha97, Save The Dragons
Andresvmb [3] - Dunnstral, NDMath, T3
Enchant [3] - Vasex, WindowsXP, Enchant

I also think all of the Scum this game are here.

[Andresvmb]

With the exception of maybe Anastasia, who could be Scum.

Oh and I don’t SR Samantha. Their vote for T3 was key. My mind is completely changed there.

[Vasex]

And i want to add before a sleep: if std is scum, the next scum is windows. Im pretty sure. He tried to avoid the elim of both of them, seeking other targets. Even if xp hammers std it doesnt matter.

[Vasex]

And xp sees andre town, but andre kinda start to sr xp and not the first time, so dkkoba is scummier.

[Vasex]

both of them,

Std and t3

[DrippingGoofball]

Okay @Rathe, I’ve read closer. I understand your skepticism. I think there’s good reasons to SR XP here. I might have been wrong there.

Vote!

I think there’s Scummier players this game. Like Nero.

VOTE: Nero

[Andresvmb]

Look I’m going to be honest. From almost completely finishing reading D1 (and I’ve been active/reading for a lot of D2), I think the pool of {Nero Cain, Vasex, WindowsXP, NDMath} contains multiple Scum.

I would probably carry {Marky Mark, Enchant, Rathe, Kerset, Cabd (as the counterwagon to Scum), Samantha, and DGB} as Town unless something dramatic happens.